{
  "source_commit": "multiple snapshots; see each run",
  "protocol": "baseline and challenge",
  "note": "Regraded with zero-noop-v1: every no-op gate now fails. Historical journals replay under their original runtimes; original grades are retained in provenance. These are regrades, not new model executions.",
  "rules": {
    "a-schedule": {
      "id": "a-schedule",
      "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
      "rule": "Feed on days 0, 2, 4, and 6. The entire workflow, including imaging, review and incubator return, must fit within 09:00\u201317:00 on each day.",
      "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
    },
    "a-before": {
      "id": "a-before",
      "title": "Image and review before feeding",
      "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
      "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
    },
    "a-remove": {
      "id": "a-remove",
      "title": "Remove all spent medium",
      "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
      "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
    },
    "a-add": {
      "id": "a-add",
      "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
      "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
      "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
    },
    "a-after": {
      "id": "a-after",
      "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
      "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
      "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
    },
    "a-return": {
      "id": "a-return",
      "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
      "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
      "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
    },
    "a-final": {
      "id": "a-final",
      "title": "A \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
      "rule": "Complete all assigned A feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
    },
    "b-rock": {
      "id": "b-rock",
      "title": "Remove recovery medium at 24 \u00b12 hours",
      "rule": "B starts already thawed and plated in ROCK-containing medium. Remove that medium 22\u201326 hours after recovery, inclusive. With recovery at previous-day 19:00, removal is due on day 0 at 17:00\u201321:00. This window applies to removal, not the full imaging/review/return workflow.",
      "fail": "ROCK-containing medium is removed before 22 hours or after 26 hours, or any remains."
    },
    "b-schedule": {
      "id": "b-schedule",
      "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
      "rule": "After the recovery feed, feed on days 2, 4, and 6, with the entire workflow within 09:00\u201317:00. The first feed uses the ROCK-removal exception in step 01.",
      "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
    },
    "b-before": {
      "id": "b-before",
      "title": "Image and review before feeding",
      "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
      "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
    },
    "b-remove": {
      "id": "b-remove",
      "title": "Remove all spent medium",
      "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
      "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
    },
    "b-add": {
      "id": "b-add",
      "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
      "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
      "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
    },
    "b-after": {
      "id": "b-after",
      "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
      "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
      "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
    },
    "b-return": {
      "id": "b-return",
      "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
      "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
      "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
    },
    "b-final": {
      "id": "b-final",
      "title": "B \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
      "rule": "Complete all assigned B feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
    },
    "cd-eligible": {
      "id": "cd-eligible",
      "title": "Check C before passaging",
      "rule": "Obtain a pre-passage image and scientist assessment. Confluence of 70\u2013100% is acceptable, including both endpoints.",
      "fail": "Confluence is below 70% or eligibility evidence is missing. There is no block at 100%."
    },
    "cd-coating": {
      "id": "cd-coating",
      "title": "Empty all six coated D wells",
      "rule": "Remove all coating liquid from every destination well before source treatment.",
      "fail": "Any coating liquid remains in any of the six wells."
    },
    "cd-wash": {
      "id": "cd-wash",
      "title": "Remove medium, wash, and remove PBS",
      "rule": "Remove all spent medium from C. Wash with 1\u20134 mL PBS inclusive, then remove all wash liquid without a deliberate pause.",
      "fail": "Spent medium or PBS remains at its removal checkpoint, wash volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, or a deliberate hold interrupts washing/removal."
    },
    "cd-release": {
      "id": "cd-release",
      "title": "Add and fully remove ReLeSR",
      "rule": "Add 800\u20131,200 \u00b5L ReLeSR inclusive, then remove all of it. No thin film or fixed residual remains.",
      "fail": "Addition is outside the range or any ReLeSR liquid remains after removal."
    },
    "cd-incubate-first": {
      "id": "cd-incubate-first",
      "title": "Incubate for 2\u20134 minutes",
      "rule": "Place C in the incubator for 120\u2013240 seconds inclusive after ReLeSR removal.",
      "fail": "Initial incubation is missing, shorter than 120 seconds, or longer than 240 seconds."
    },
    "cd-review-first": {
      "id": "cd-review-first",
      "title": "Image and receive the first negative review",
      "rule": "Complete a new microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review. The first review deliberately fails and requires reincubation.",
      "fail": "Imaging/review is skipped or the model proceeds to collection despite the negative result."
    },
    "cd-incubate-second": {
      "id": "cd-incubate-second",
      "title": "Return C for a second incubation",
      "rule": "Return the plate to the incubator and execute a second incubation of at most 240 seconds. There is no lower-duration gate. These are separate limits, not a four-minute total cap.",
      "fail": "The model skips incubator return or the incubation step, or the second incubation exceeds 240 seconds."
    },
    "cd-review-second": {
      "id": "cd-review-second",
      "title": "Image again and obtain approval",
      "rule": "After reincubation, complete another microscope acquisition and scientist review. This second review always passes.",
      "fail": "The model proceeds before the second acquisition and review finish."
    },
    "cd-dislodge": {
      "id": "cd-dislodge",
      "title": "Dispense directly onto cells at faster speed",
      "rule": "After approval, add 1\u20134 mL medium inclusive directly onto C\u2019s cells and explicitly acknowledge faster pipette speed to the simulator. This replaces tapping and is the exception to wall dispensing.",
      "fail": "Volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, dispense is not directed onto cells, or the faster-speed acknowledgment is missing."
    },
    "cd-collect": {
      "id": "cd-collect",
      "title": "Choose P1000 wide-bore and collect",
      "rule": "Explicitly select and use the P1000 wide-bore variant to transfer the suspension into a separate collection tube, using capacity-respecting draws.",
      "fail": "Collection uses standard/non-wide-bore tips or omits the required model selection."
    },
    "cd-dilute": {
      "id": "cd-dilute",
      "title": "Calculate dilution to exactly 12 mL",
      "rule": "Choose added medium as 12 mL minus the actual collected suspension volume. The tube must contain exactly 12 mL after dilution. The dilution addition has no 1\u20134 mL restriction.",
      "fail": "The model does not choose the dilution or the resulting tube volume is not 12 mL."
    },
    "cd-mix": {
      "id": "cd-mix",
      "title": "Mix after dilution with wide-bore",
      "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, complete 1\u20135 up-and-down cycles inclusive after dilution and before distribution.",
      "fail": "Mixing is absent, exceeds five cycles, uses non-wide-bore, or occurs only before dilution."
    },
    "cd-distribute": {
      "id": "cd-distribute",
      "title": "Give each D well one-sixth",
      "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, transfer one-sixth of the tube\u2019s starting, post-dilution volume into each of D\u2019s six wells: 2 mL each from 12 mL. Do not recalculate from the shrinking remainder.",
      "fail": "Any well receives a different share, a well is omitted, or distribution uses non-wide-bore."
    },
    "cd-motion": {
      "id": "cd-motion",
      "title": "Close D and distribute cells within wells",
      "rule": "Close D\u2019s lid and perform the simulated side-to-side and front-to-back plate-motion step before incubation.",
      "fail": "The required plate motion is skipped."
    },
    "cd-d-review": {
      "id": "cd-d-review",
      "title": "Image and review D",
      "rule": "Complete microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review after plate motion and before incubator placement. This review always passes.",
      "fail": "Acquisition or completed review is missing or incubation occurs first."
    },
    "cd-d-return": {
      "id": "cd-d-return",
      "title": "Put D in the incubator within 10 minutes",
      "rule": "From the final dispense into D\u2019s last well to incubator entry, allow at most 600 seconds, including plate motion, imaging and review.",
      "fail": "More than 600 seconds elapse or required intervening steps are bypassed."
    },
    "cd-lineage": {
      "id": "cd-lineage",
      "title": "Register D and dispose of C",
      "rule": "Register D as C\u2019s daughter with passage number increased by one (5 \u2192 6 here). Dispose of emptied C and preserve its lineage record.",
      "fail": "C is not disposed, or D\u2019s parentage/passage number is missing or incorrect."
    },
    "cd-day0": {
      "id": "cd-day0",
      "title": "Complete passage on day 0",
      "rule": "Complete C\u2192D passage, D registration and C disposal by day 0 24:00 (57600 seconds after the 08:00 epoch).",
      "fail": "Passage, registration or C disposal remains incomplete after day 0."
    },
    "cd-maintain": {
      "id": "cd-maintain",
      "title": "Maintain D every 48 hours, \u00b12 hours",
      "rule": "First feed is due 48 hours after initial incubator entry, with a 46\u201350-hour window. Repeat every 48 hours on the anchored schedule. The entire feeding workflow must fit within each \u00b12-hour window. Use A\u2019s pre/post imaging and review, full removal with tilt/no scraping, 2\u20134 mL wall addition per well, and 600-second return limit.",
      "fail": "Any subsequent feeding rule or the full-workflow timing window is missed."
    },
    "cd-final": {
      "id": "cd-final",
      "title": "Leave D ready",
      "rule": "At final submission, D is in its assigned incubator with its lid closed; source C is disposed.",
      "fail": "D is elsewhere, its lid is open, or C has not been disposed."
    },
    "d-schedule": {
      "id": "d-schedule",
      "title": "D feed schedule",
      "rule": "Complete each D feed within its assigned \u00b12-hour window."
    },
    "d-before": {
      "id": "d-before",
      "title": "D pre-feed image and review",
      "rule": "Acquire and review a fresh image for every D feed."
    },
    "d-remove": {
      "id": "d-remove",
      "title": "D complete removal",
      "rule": "Remove all old medium from every well with tilt, no scraping and at most one bottom touch."
    },
    "d-add": {
      "id": "d-add",
      "title": "D fresh medium",
      "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall into each emptied well."
    },
    "d-after": {
      "id": "d-after",
      "title": "D post-feed image and review",
      "rule": "Acquire and review a new image after each D feed."
    },
    "d-return": {
      "id": "d-return",
      "title": "D incubator return",
      "rule": "Return within 600 seconds of the final dispense."
    },
    "d-final": {
      "id": "d-final",
      "title": "D \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
      "rule": "Complete all assigned D feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
    },
    "final-jobs": {
      "id": "final-jobs",
      "title": "Finish the workflow and complete all jobs",
      "rule": "Submit at day seven after running the workflow; all initiated jobs must be done, with no unfinished feed or wash sequence."
    },
    "final-robot": {
      "id": "final-robot",
      "title": "Finish pipetting and release the robot",
      "rule": "After executing pipetting and submitting at day seven, leave no held plate or attached tip."
    },
    "material-accounting": {
      "id": "material-accounting",
      "title": "Execute and conserve material",
      "rule": "After actual liquid transfers and day-seven submission, preserve material conservation and leave no cell clumps in waste."
    },
    "no-violation": {
      "id": "no-violation",
      "title": "Complete execution without violations",
      "rule": "Execute liquid handling and submit at day seven without terminal protocol violations or truncation."
    },
    "submitted": {
      "id": "submitted",
      "title": "Final submission",
      "rule": "Submit finish at exactly 604800 seconds."
    },
    "e-schedule": {
      "id": "e-schedule",
      "title": "E \u00b7 schedule",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "e-before": {
      "id": "e-before",
      "title": "E \u00b7 before",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "e-remove": {
      "id": "e-remove",
      "title": "E \u00b7 remove",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "e-add": {
      "id": "e-add",
      "title": "E \u00b7 add",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "e-after": {
      "id": "e-after",
      "title": "E \u00b7 after",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "e-return": {
      "id": "e-return",
      "title": "E \u00b7 return",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "e-final": {
      "id": "e-final",
      "title": "E \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
      "rule": "Complete all assigned E feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
    },
    "f-schedule": {
      "id": "f-schedule",
      "title": "F \u00b7 schedule",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "f-before": {
      "id": "f-before",
      "title": "F \u00b7 before",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "f-remove": {
      "id": "f-remove",
      "title": "F \u00b7 remove",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "f-add": {
      "id": "f-add",
      "title": "F \u00b7 add",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "f-after": {
      "id": "f-after",
      "title": "F \u00b7 after",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "f-return": {
      "id": "f-return",
      "title": "F \u00b7 return",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "f-final": {
      "id": "f-final",
      "title": "F \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
      "rule": "Complete all assigned F feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
    },
    "g-schedule": {
      "id": "g-schedule",
      "title": "G \u00b7 schedule",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "g-before": {
      "id": "g-before",
      "title": "G \u00b7 before",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "g-remove": {
      "id": "g-remove",
      "title": "G \u00b7 remove",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "g-add": {
      "id": "g-add",
      "title": "G \u00b7 add",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "g-after": {
      "id": "g-after",
      "title": "G \u00b7 after",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "g-return": {
      "id": "g-return",
      "title": "G \u00b7 return",
      "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
    },
    "g-final": {
      "id": "g-final",
      "title": "G \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
      "rule": "Complete all assigned G feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
    },
    "cd-intervention": {
      "id": "cd-intervention",
      "title": "Scientist intervention",
      "rule": "Complete scientist intervention when requested; do not invent an intervention on a branch that does not require it."
    },
    "equipment-recovery": {
      "id": "equipment-recovery",
      "title": "Recover failed acquisitions",
      "rule": "A failed acquisition must be followed by a successful image of the same plate and purpose without repeating material transfers."
    }
  },
  "runs": [
    {
      "id": "challenge-01__wnXfLqD",
      "label": "Nova Micro \u00b7 Challenge v7 \u00b7 numeric dispense coordinates \u00b7 run 1",
      "role": "solver",
      "grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-challenge-v1",
        "scoring": "binary-challenge-decoupled-v1",
        "success": false,
        "reward": 0,
        "violations": [],
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": false,
          "a-before": false,
          "a-remove": false,
          "a-add": false,
          "a-after": false,
          "a-return": false,
          "a-final": false,
          "b-schedule": false,
          "b-before": false,
          "b-remove": false,
          "b-add": false,
          "b-after": false,
          "b-return": false,
          "b-final": false,
          "d-schedule": false,
          "d-before": false,
          "d-remove": false,
          "d-add": false,
          "d-after": false,
          "d-return": false,
          "d-final": false,
          "e-schedule": false,
          "e-before": false,
          "e-remove": false,
          "e-add": false,
          "e-after": false,
          "e-return": false,
          "e-final": false,
          "f-schedule": false,
          "f-before": false,
          "f-remove": false,
          "f-add": false,
          "f-after": false,
          "f-return": false,
          "f-final": false,
          "g-schedule": false,
          "g-before": false,
          "g-remove": false,
          "g-add": false,
          "g-after": false,
          "g-return": false,
          "g-final": false,
          "b-rock": false,
          "cd-eligible": false,
          "cd-coating": false,
          "cd-wash": false,
          "cd-release": false,
          "cd-incubate-first": false,
          "cd-review-first": false,
          "cd-incubate-second": false,
          "cd-review-second": false,
          "cd-intervention": false,
          "equipment-recovery": false,
          "cd-dislodge": false,
          "cd-collect": false,
          "cd-dilute": false,
          "cd-mix": false,
          "cd-distribute": false,
          "cd-motion": false,
          "cd-d-review": false,
          "cd-d-return": false,
          "cd-lineage": false,
          "cd-day0": false,
          "cd-maintain": false,
          "cd-final": false,
          "final-jobs": false,
          "final-robot": false,
          "material-accounting": false,
          "no-violation": false,
          "submitted": false
        },
        "failed_gates": [
          "a-schedule",
          "a-before",
          "a-remove",
          "a-add",
          "a-after",
          "a-return",
          "a-final",
          "b-schedule",
          "b-before",
          "b-remove",
          "b-add",
          "b-after",
          "b-return",
          "b-final",
          "d-schedule",
          "d-before",
          "d-remove",
          "d-add",
          "d-after",
          "d-return",
          "d-final",
          "e-schedule",
          "e-before",
          "e-remove",
          "e-add",
          "e-after",
          "e-return",
          "e-final",
          "f-schedule",
          "f-before",
          "f-remove",
          "f-add",
          "f-after",
          "f-return",
          "f-final",
          "g-schedule",
          "g-before",
          "g-remove",
          "g-add",
          "g-after",
          "g-return",
          "g-final",
          "b-rock",
          "cd-eligible",
          "cd-coating",
          "cd-wash",
          "cd-release",
          "cd-incubate-first",
          "cd-review-first",
          "cd-incubate-second",
          "cd-review-second",
          "cd-intervention",
          "equipment-recovery",
          "cd-dislodge",
          "cd-collect",
          "cd-dilute",
          "cd-mix",
          "cd-distribute",
          "cd-motion",
          "cd-d-review",
          "cd-d-return",
          "cd-lineage",
          "cd-day0",
          "cd-maintain",
          "cd-final",
          "final-jobs",
          "final-robot",
          "material-accounting",
          "no-violation",
          "submitted"
        ],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 0.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 0
      },
      "original_grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-challenge-v1",
        "scoring": "binary-challenge-decoupled-v1",
        "success": false,
        "reward": 0,
        "violations": [],
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": false,
          "a-before": false,
          "a-remove": false,
          "a-add": false,
          "a-after": false,
          "a-return": false,
          "a-final": false,
          "b-schedule": false,
          "b-before": false,
          "b-remove": false,
          "b-add": false,
          "b-after": false,
          "b-return": false,
          "b-final": false,
          "d-schedule": false,
          "d-before": false,
          "d-remove": false,
          "d-add": false,
          "d-after": false,
          "d-return": false,
          "d-final": false,
          "e-schedule": false,
          "e-before": false,
          "e-remove": false,
          "e-add": false,
          "e-after": false,
          "e-return": false,
          "e-final": false,
          "f-schedule": false,
          "f-before": false,
          "f-remove": false,
          "f-add": false,
          "f-after": false,
          "f-return": false,
          "f-final": false,
          "g-schedule": false,
          "g-before": false,
          "g-remove": false,
          "g-add": false,
          "g-after": false,
          "g-return": false,
          "g-final": false,
          "b-rock": false,
          "cd-eligible": false,
          "cd-coating": false,
          "cd-wash": false,
          "cd-release": false,
          "cd-incubate-first": false,
          "cd-review-first": false,
          "cd-incubate-second": false,
          "cd-review-second": false,
          "cd-intervention": false,
          "equipment-recovery": false,
          "cd-dislodge": false,
          "cd-collect": false,
          "cd-dilute": false,
          "cd-mix": false,
          "cd-distribute": false,
          "cd-motion": false,
          "cd-d-review": false,
          "cd-d-return": false,
          "cd-lineage": false,
          "cd-day0": false,
          "cd-maintain": false,
          "cd-final": false,
          "final-jobs": false,
          "final-robot": false,
          "material-accounting": false,
          "no-violation": false,
          "submitted": false
        },
        "failed_gates": [
          "a-schedule",
          "a-before",
          "a-remove",
          "a-add",
          "a-after",
          "a-return",
          "a-final",
          "b-schedule",
          "b-before",
          "b-remove",
          "b-add",
          "b-after",
          "b-return",
          "b-final",
          "d-schedule",
          "d-before",
          "d-remove",
          "d-add",
          "d-after",
          "d-return",
          "d-final",
          "e-schedule",
          "e-before",
          "e-remove",
          "e-add",
          "e-after",
          "e-return",
          "e-final",
          "f-schedule",
          "f-before",
          "f-remove",
          "f-add",
          "f-after",
          "f-return",
          "f-final",
          "g-schedule",
          "g-before",
          "g-remove",
          "g-add",
          "g-after",
          "g-return",
          "g-final",
          "b-rock",
          "cd-eligible",
          "cd-coating",
          "cd-wash",
          "cd-release",
          "cd-incubate-first",
          "cd-review-first",
          "cd-incubate-second",
          "cd-review-second",
          "cd-intervention",
          "equipment-recovery",
          "cd-dislodge",
          "cd-collect",
          "cd-dilute",
          "cd-mix",
          "cd-distribute",
          "cd-motion",
          "cd-d-review",
          "cd-d-return",
          "cd-lineage",
          "cd-day0",
          "cd-maintain",
          "cd-final",
          "final-jobs",
          "final-robot",
          "material-accounting",
          "no-violation",
          "submitted"
        ],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 0.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 0
      },
      "grading_revision": "zero-noop-v1",
      "grader_sha256": "5c742ba12ef754a3db66f062cecc7597574707b064dc911de553871c50079fbd",
      "execution_note": "No protocol work completed: all 7 action requests were rejected. Dispensing and coordinate gates were not reached.",
      "source_commit": "4377e6ab7ac8581764bade2622b42b4ec65cca51",
      "edition": "Challenge v7 \u00b7 numeric dispense coordinates",
      "runtime": "5d68499ad97c03811fc95eef2fe286ebc17571e3a6ba379f1f2b30e1d2683437",
      "sha256": "3c396f5f54193d5e92beec4905bd3480dd15689584f630d99cd110e92d25f927",
      "source": "jobs/nova-v7-results/jobs/ipsc-challenge-v7-nova-micro-single-20261112T181444Z/challenge-01__wnXfLqD/artifacts/attempt.json",
      "exact_replay": true,
      "regraded": true,
      "rules": {
        "a-schedule": {
          "id": "a-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "Feed on days 0, 2, 4, and 6. The entire workflow, including imaging, review and incubator return, must fit within 09:00\u201317:00 on each day.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "a-before": {
          "id": "a-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "a-remove": {
          "id": "a-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "a-add": {
          "id": "a-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "a-after": {
          "id": "a-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "a-return": {
          "id": "a-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "a-final": {
          "id": "a-final",
          "title": "A \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned A feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "b-rock": {
          "id": "b-rock",
          "title": "B ROCK removal window",
          "rule": "Complete removal 22\u201326 hours after the observed recovery timestamp."
        },
        "b-schedule": {
          "id": "b-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "After the recovery feed, feed on days 2, 4, and 6, with the entire workflow within 09:00\u201317:00. The first feed uses the ROCK-removal exception in step 01.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "b-before": {
          "id": "b-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "b-remove": {
          "id": "b-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "b-add": {
          "id": "b-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "b-after": {
          "id": "b-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "b-return": {
          "id": "b-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "b-final": {
          "id": "b-final",
          "title": "B \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned B feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-eligible": {
          "id": "cd-eligible",
          "title": "Check C before passaging",
          "rule": "Obtain a pre-passage image and scientist assessment. Confluence of 70\u2013100% is acceptable, including both endpoints.",
          "fail": "Confluence is below 70% or eligibility evidence is missing. There is no block at 100%."
        },
        "cd-coating": {
          "id": "cd-coating",
          "title": "Empty all six coated D wells",
          "rule": "Remove all coating liquid from every destination well before source treatment.",
          "fail": "Any coating liquid remains in any of the six wells."
        },
        "cd-wash": {
          "id": "cd-wash",
          "title": "Remove medium, wash, and remove PBS",
          "rule": "Remove all spent medium from C. Wash with 1\u20134 mL PBS inclusive, then remove all wash liquid without a deliberate pause.",
          "fail": "Spent medium or PBS remains at its removal checkpoint, wash volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, or a deliberate hold interrupts washing/removal."
        },
        "cd-release": {
          "id": "cd-release",
          "title": "Add and fully remove ReLeSR",
          "rule": "Add 800\u20131,200 \u00b5L ReLeSR inclusive, then remove all of it. No thin film or fixed residual remains.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside the range or any ReLeSR liquid remains after removal."
        },
        "cd-incubate-first": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-first",
          "title": "Incubate for 2\u20134 minutes",
          "rule": "Place C in the incubator for 120\u2013240 seconds inclusive after ReLeSR removal.",
          "fail": "Initial incubation is missing, shorter than 120 seconds, or longer than 240 seconds."
        },
        "cd-review-first": {
          "id": "cd-review-first",
          "title": "Image and receive the first negative review",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-incubate-second": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-second",
          "title": "Return C for a second incubation",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-review-second": {
          "id": "cd-review-second",
          "title": "Image again and obtain approval",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-dislodge": {
          "id": "cd-dislodge",
          "title": "Dispense directly onto cells at faster speed",
          "rule": "After approval, add 1\u20134 mL medium inclusive directly onto C\u2019s cells and explicitly acknowledge faster pipette speed to the simulator. This replaces tapping and is the exception to wall dispensing.",
          "fail": "Volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, dispense is not directed onto cells, or the faster-speed acknowledgment is missing."
        },
        "cd-collect": {
          "id": "cd-collect",
          "title": "Choose P1000 wide-bore and collect",
          "rule": "Explicitly select and use the P1000 wide-bore variant to transfer the suspension into a separate collection tube, using capacity-respecting draws.",
          "fail": "Collection uses standard/non-wide-bore tips or omits the required model selection."
        },
        "cd-dilute": {
          "id": "cd-dilute",
          "title": "Calculate dilution to exactly 12 mL",
          "rule": "Choose added medium as 12 mL minus the actual collected suspension volume. The tube must contain exactly 12 mL after dilution. The dilution addition has no 1\u20134 mL restriction.",
          "fail": "The model does not choose the dilution or the resulting tube volume is not 12 mL."
        },
        "cd-mix": {
          "id": "cd-mix",
          "title": "Mix after dilution with wide-bore",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, complete 1\u20135 up-and-down cycles inclusive after dilution and before distribution.",
          "fail": "Mixing is absent, exceeds five cycles, uses non-wide-bore, or occurs only before dilution."
        },
        "cd-distribute": {
          "id": "cd-distribute",
          "title": "Give each D well one-sixth",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, transfer one-sixth of the tube\u2019s starting, post-dilution volume into each of D\u2019s six wells: 2 mL each from 12 mL. Do not recalculate from the shrinking remainder.",
          "fail": "Any well receives a different share, a well is omitted, or distribution uses non-wide-bore."
        },
        "cd-motion": {
          "id": "cd-motion",
          "title": "Close D and distribute cells within wells",
          "rule": "Close D\u2019s lid and perform the simulated side-to-side and front-to-back plate-motion step before incubation.",
          "fail": "The required plate motion is skipped."
        },
        "cd-d-review": {
          "id": "cd-d-review",
          "title": "Image and review D",
          "rule": "Complete microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review after plate motion and before incubator placement. This review always passes.",
          "fail": "Acquisition or completed review is missing or incubation occurs first."
        },
        "cd-d-return": {
          "id": "cd-d-return",
          "title": "Put D in the incubator within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "From the final dispense into D\u2019s last well to incubator entry, allow at most 600 seconds, including plate motion, imaging and review.",
          "fail": "More than 600 seconds elapse or required intervening steps are bypassed."
        },
        "cd-lineage": {
          "id": "cd-lineage",
          "title": "Register D and dispose of C",
          "rule": "Register D as C\u2019s daughter with passage number increased by one (5 \u2192 6 here). Dispose of emptied C and preserve its lineage record.",
          "fail": "C is not disposed, or D\u2019s parentage/passage number is missing or incorrect."
        },
        "cd-day0": {
          "id": "cd-day0",
          "title": "Complete passage on day 0",
          "rule": "Complete C\u2192D passage, D registration and C disposal by day 0 24:00 (57600 seconds after the 08:00 epoch).",
          "fail": "Passage, registration or C disposal remains incomplete after day 0."
        },
        "cd-maintain": {
          "id": "cd-maintain",
          "title": "Maintain D every 48 hours, \u00b12 hours",
          "rule": "First feed is due 48 hours after initial incubator entry, with a 46\u201350-hour window. Repeat every 48 hours on the anchored schedule. The entire feeding workflow must fit within each \u00b12-hour window. Use A\u2019s pre/post imaging and review, full removal with tilt/no scraping, 2\u20134 mL wall addition per well, and 600-second return limit.",
          "fail": "Any subsequent feeding rule or the full-workflow timing window is missed."
        },
        "cd-final": {
          "id": "cd-final",
          "title": "Leave D ready",
          "rule": "At final submission, D is in its assigned incubator with its lid closed; source C is disposed.",
          "fail": "D is elsewhere, its lid is open, or C has not been disposed."
        },
        "d-schedule": {
          "id": "d-schedule",
          "title": "D feed schedule",
          "rule": "Complete each D feed within its assigned \u00b12-hour window."
        },
        "d-before": {
          "id": "d-before",
          "title": "D pre-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a fresh image for every D feed."
        },
        "d-remove": {
          "id": "d-remove",
          "title": "D complete removal",
          "rule": "Remove all old medium from every well with tilt, no scraping and at most one bottom touch."
        },
        "d-add": {
          "id": "d-add",
          "title": "D fresh medium",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall into each emptied well."
        },
        "d-after": {
          "id": "d-after",
          "title": "D post-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a new image after each D feed."
        },
        "d-return": {
          "id": "d-return",
          "title": "D incubator return",
          "rule": "Return within 600 seconds of the final dispense."
        },
        "d-final": {
          "id": "d-final",
          "title": "D \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned D feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "final-jobs": {
          "id": "final-jobs",
          "title": "Finish the workflow and complete all jobs",
          "rule": "Submit at day seven after running the workflow; all initiated jobs must be done, with no unfinished feed or wash sequence."
        },
        "final-robot": {
          "id": "final-robot",
          "title": "Finish pipetting and release the robot",
          "rule": "After executing pipetting and submitting at day seven, leave no held plate or attached tip."
        },
        "material-accounting": {
          "id": "material-accounting",
          "title": "Execute and conserve material",
          "rule": "After actual liquid transfers and day-seven submission, preserve material conservation and leave no cell clumps in waste."
        },
        "no-violation": {
          "id": "no-violation",
          "title": "Complete execution without violations",
          "rule": "Execute liquid handling and submit at day seven without terminal protocol violations or truncation."
        },
        "submitted": {
          "id": "submitted",
          "title": "Final submission",
          "rule": "Submit finish at exactly 604800 seconds."
        },
        "e-schedule": {
          "id": "e-schedule",
          "title": "E \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-before": {
          "id": "e-before",
          "title": "E \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-remove": {
          "id": "e-remove",
          "title": "E \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-add": {
          "id": "e-add",
          "title": "E \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-after": {
          "id": "e-after",
          "title": "E \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-return": {
          "id": "e-return",
          "title": "E \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-final": {
          "id": "e-final",
          "title": "E \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned E feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "f-schedule": {
          "id": "f-schedule",
          "title": "F \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-before": {
          "id": "f-before",
          "title": "F \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-remove": {
          "id": "f-remove",
          "title": "F \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-add": {
          "id": "f-add",
          "title": "F \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-after": {
          "id": "f-after",
          "title": "F \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-return": {
          "id": "f-return",
          "title": "F \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-final": {
          "id": "f-final",
          "title": "F \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned F feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "g-schedule": {
          "id": "g-schedule",
          "title": "G \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-before": {
          "id": "g-before",
          "title": "G \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-remove": {
          "id": "g-remove",
          "title": "G \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-add": {
          "id": "g-add",
          "title": "G \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-after": {
          "id": "g-after",
          "title": "G \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-return": {
          "id": "g-return",
          "title": "G \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-final": {
          "id": "g-final",
          "title": "G \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned G feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-intervention": {
          "id": "cd-intervention",
          "title": "Scientist intervention",
          "rule": "Complete scientist intervention when requested; do not invent an intervention on a branch that does not require it."
        },
        "equipment-recovery": {
          "id": "equipment-recovery",
          "title": "Recover failed acquisitions",
          "rule": "A failed acquisition must be followed by a successful image of the same plate and purpose without repeating material transfers."
        }
      },
      "journal_url": "data/gate-dashboard/journal-3c396f5f54193d5e.json",
      "agent_trace_url": "data/gate-dashboard/agent-challenge-01__wnXfLqD.json",
      "agent_trace_summary": {
        "available": true,
        "turn_count": 16,
        "tool_call_count": 20,
        "tool_error_count": 8
      },
      "url": "data/gate-dashboard/challenge-01__wnXfLqD.json",
      "gate_results": {
        "a-schedule": false,
        "a-before": false,
        "a-remove": false,
        "a-add": false,
        "a-after": false,
        "a-return": false,
        "a-final": false,
        "b-schedule": false,
        "b-before": false,
        "b-remove": false,
        "b-add": false,
        "b-after": false,
        "b-return": false,
        "b-final": false,
        "d-schedule": false,
        "d-before": false,
        "d-remove": false,
        "d-add": false,
        "d-after": false,
        "d-return": false,
        "d-final": false,
        "e-schedule": false,
        "e-before": false,
        "e-remove": false,
        "e-add": false,
        "e-after": false,
        "e-return": false,
        "e-final": false,
        "f-schedule": false,
        "f-before": false,
        "f-remove": false,
        "f-add": false,
        "f-after": false,
        "f-return": false,
        "f-final": false,
        "g-schedule": false,
        "g-before": false,
        "g-remove": false,
        "g-add": false,
        "g-after": false,
        "g-return": false,
        "g-final": false,
        "b-rock": false,
        "cd-eligible": false,
        "cd-coating": false,
        "cd-wash": false,
        "cd-release": false,
        "cd-incubate-first": false,
        "cd-review-first": false,
        "cd-incubate-second": false,
        "cd-review-second": false,
        "cd-intervention": false,
        "equipment-recovery": false,
        "cd-dislodge": false,
        "cd-collect": false,
        "cd-dilute": false,
        "cd-mix": false,
        "cd-distribute": false,
        "cd-motion": false,
        "cd-d-review": false,
        "cd-d-return": false,
        "cd-lineage": false,
        "cd-day0": false,
        "cd-maintain": false,
        "cd-final": false,
        "final-jobs": false,
        "final-robot": false,
        "material-accounting": false,
        "no-violation": false,
        "submitted": false
      },
      "gate_status": {
        "a-schedule": "failed",
        "a-before": "failed",
        "a-remove": "failed",
        "a-add": "failed",
        "a-after": "failed",
        "a-return": "failed",
        "a-final": "failed",
        "b-schedule": "failed",
        "b-before": "failed",
        "b-remove": "failed",
        "b-add": "failed",
        "b-after": "failed",
        "b-return": "failed",
        "b-final": "failed",
        "d-schedule": "failed",
        "d-before": "failed",
        "d-remove": "failed",
        "d-add": "failed",
        "d-after": "failed",
        "d-return": "failed",
        "d-final": "failed",
        "e-schedule": "failed",
        "e-before": "failed",
        "e-remove": "failed",
        "e-add": "failed",
        "e-after": "failed",
        "e-return": "failed",
        "e-final": "failed",
        "f-schedule": "failed",
        "f-before": "failed",
        "f-remove": "failed",
        "f-add": "failed",
        "f-after": "failed",
        "f-return": "failed",
        "f-final": "failed",
        "g-schedule": "failed",
        "g-before": "failed",
        "g-remove": "failed",
        "g-add": "failed",
        "g-after": "failed",
        "g-return": "failed",
        "g-final": "failed",
        "b-rock": "failed",
        "cd-eligible": "failed",
        "cd-coating": "failed",
        "cd-wash": "failed",
        "cd-release": "failed",
        "cd-incubate-first": "failed",
        "cd-review-first": "failed",
        "cd-incubate-second": "failed",
        "cd-review-second": "failed",
        "cd-intervention": "failed",
        "equipment-recovery": "failed",
        "cd-dislodge": "failed",
        "cd-collect": "failed",
        "cd-dilute": "failed",
        "cd-mix": "failed",
        "cd-distribute": "failed",
        "cd-motion": "failed",
        "cd-d-review": "failed",
        "cd-d-return": "failed",
        "cd-lineage": "failed",
        "cd-day0": "failed",
        "cd-maintain": "failed",
        "cd-final": "failed",
        "final-jobs": "failed",
        "final-robot": "failed",
        "material-accounting": "failed",
        "no-violation": "failed",
        "submitted": "failed"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "challenge-01__JEZkqfk",
      "label": "Astra Max \u00b7 Challenge v6 \u00b7 decoupled execution and grading \u00b7 run 1",
      "role": "solver",
      "grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-challenge-v1",
        "scoring": "binary-challenge-decoupled-v1",
        "success": true,
        "reward": 1,
        "violations": [],
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": true,
          "a-before": true,
          "a-remove": true,
          "a-add": true,
          "a-after": true,
          "a-return": true,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": true,
          "b-before": true,
          "b-remove": true,
          "b-add": true,
          "b-after": true,
          "b-return": true,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": true,
          "d-before": true,
          "d-remove": true,
          "d-add": true,
          "d-after": true,
          "d-return": true,
          "d-final": true,
          "e-schedule": true,
          "e-before": true,
          "e-remove": true,
          "e-add": true,
          "e-after": true,
          "e-return": true,
          "e-final": true,
          "f-schedule": true,
          "f-before": true,
          "f-remove": true,
          "f-add": true,
          "f-after": true,
          "f-return": true,
          "f-final": true,
          "g-schedule": true,
          "g-before": true,
          "g-remove": true,
          "g-add": true,
          "g-after": true,
          "g-return": true,
          "g-final": true,
          "b-rock": true,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": true,
          "cd-wash": true,
          "cd-release": true,
          "cd-incubate-first": true,
          "cd-review-first": true,
          "cd-incubate-second": true,
          "cd-review-second": true,
          "cd-intervention": true,
          "equipment-recovery": true,
          "cd-dislodge": true,
          "cd-collect": true,
          "cd-dilute": true,
          "cd-mix": true,
          "cd-distribute": true,
          "cd-motion": true,
          "cd-d-review": true,
          "cd-d-return": true,
          "cd-lineage": true,
          "cd-day0": true,
          "cd-maintain": true,
          "cd-final": true,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": true,
          "submitted": true
        },
        "failed_gates": [],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 604800.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 82
      },
      "original_grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-challenge-v1",
        "scoring": "binary-challenge-decoupled-v1",
        "success": true,
        "reward": 1,
        "violations": [],
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": true,
          "a-before": true,
          "a-remove": true,
          "a-add": true,
          "a-after": true,
          "a-return": true,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": true,
          "b-before": true,
          "b-remove": true,
          "b-add": true,
          "b-after": true,
          "b-return": true,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": true,
          "d-before": true,
          "d-remove": true,
          "d-add": true,
          "d-after": true,
          "d-return": true,
          "d-final": true,
          "e-schedule": true,
          "e-before": true,
          "e-remove": true,
          "e-add": true,
          "e-after": true,
          "e-return": true,
          "e-final": true,
          "f-schedule": true,
          "f-before": true,
          "f-remove": true,
          "f-add": true,
          "f-after": true,
          "f-return": true,
          "f-final": true,
          "g-schedule": true,
          "g-before": true,
          "g-remove": true,
          "g-add": true,
          "g-after": true,
          "g-return": true,
          "g-final": true,
          "b-rock": true,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": true,
          "cd-wash": true,
          "cd-release": true,
          "cd-incubate-first": true,
          "cd-review-first": true,
          "cd-incubate-second": true,
          "cd-review-second": true,
          "cd-intervention": true,
          "equipment-recovery": true,
          "cd-dislodge": true,
          "cd-collect": true,
          "cd-dilute": true,
          "cd-mix": true,
          "cd-distribute": true,
          "cd-motion": true,
          "cd-d-review": true,
          "cd-d-return": true,
          "cd-lineage": true,
          "cd-day0": true,
          "cd-maintain": true,
          "cd-final": true,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": true,
          "submitted": true
        },
        "failed_gates": [],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 604800.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 82
      },
      "grading_revision": "zero-noop-v1",
      "grader_sha256": "67893bf51fc12e627fde0a30a3d807dcc9bd3ae4b3a1fc7af19f93ea8bb35cdd",
      "execution_note": null,
      "source_commit": "c5082d233b4d4b7e9db1515e5700d2276584139a",
      "edition": "Challenge v6 \u00b7 decoupled execution and grading",
      "runtime": "a56980af1793c204bd4265f1deb343d0c818e18aae1ef4dd71508f1f4ccb304e",
      "sha256": "043ca2e731767f0196a92d831c98efe4055bbee20be84fee8af10f1bbb5b57e7",
      "source": "jobs/challenge-v6-results/jobs/ipsc-challenge-v6-single-20261112T073129Z/challenge-01__JEZkqfk/artifacts/attempt.json",
      "exact_replay": true,
      "regraded": true,
      "rules": {
        "a-schedule": {
          "id": "a-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "Feed on days 0, 2, 4, and 6. The entire workflow, including imaging, review and incubator return, must fit within 09:00\u201317:00 on each day.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "a-before": {
          "id": "a-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "a-remove": {
          "id": "a-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "a-add": {
          "id": "a-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "a-after": {
          "id": "a-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "a-return": {
          "id": "a-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "a-final": {
          "id": "a-final",
          "title": "A \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned A feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "b-rock": {
          "id": "b-rock",
          "title": "B ROCK removal window",
          "rule": "Complete removal 22\u201326 hours after the observed recovery timestamp."
        },
        "b-schedule": {
          "id": "b-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "After the recovery feed, feed on days 2, 4, and 6, with the entire workflow within 09:00\u201317:00. The first feed uses the ROCK-removal exception in step 01.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "b-before": {
          "id": "b-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "b-remove": {
          "id": "b-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "b-add": {
          "id": "b-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "b-after": {
          "id": "b-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "b-return": {
          "id": "b-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "b-final": {
          "id": "b-final",
          "title": "B \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned B feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-eligible": {
          "id": "cd-eligible",
          "title": "Check C before passaging",
          "rule": "Obtain a pre-passage image and scientist assessment. Confluence of 70\u2013100% is acceptable, including both endpoints.",
          "fail": "Confluence is below 70% or eligibility evidence is missing. There is no block at 100%."
        },
        "cd-coating": {
          "id": "cd-coating",
          "title": "Empty all six coated D wells",
          "rule": "Remove all coating liquid from every destination well before source treatment.",
          "fail": "Any coating liquid remains in any of the six wells."
        },
        "cd-wash": {
          "id": "cd-wash",
          "title": "Remove medium, wash, and remove PBS",
          "rule": "Remove all spent medium from C. Wash with 1\u20134 mL PBS inclusive, then remove all wash liquid without a deliberate pause.",
          "fail": "Spent medium or PBS remains at its removal checkpoint, wash volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, or a deliberate hold interrupts washing/removal."
        },
        "cd-release": {
          "id": "cd-release",
          "title": "Add and fully remove ReLeSR",
          "rule": "Add 800\u20131,200 \u00b5L ReLeSR inclusive, then remove all of it. No thin film or fixed residual remains.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside the range or any ReLeSR liquid remains after removal."
        },
        "cd-incubate-first": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-first",
          "title": "Incubate for 2\u20134 minutes",
          "rule": "Place C in the incubator for 120\u2013240 seconds inclusive after ReLeSR removal.",
          "fail": "Initial incubation is missing, shorter than 120 seconds, or longer than 240 seconds."
        },
        "cd-review-first": {
          "id": "cd-review-first",
          "title": "Image and receive the first negative review",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-incubate-second": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-second",
          "title": "Return C for a second incubation",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-review-second": {
          "id": "cd-review-second",
          "title": "Image again and obtain approval",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-dislodge": {
          "id": "cd-dislodge",
          "title": "Dispense directly onto cells at faster speed",
          "rule": "After approval, add 1\u20134 mL medium inclusive directly onto C\u2019s cells and explicitly acknowledge faster pipette speed to the simulator. This replaces tapping and is the exception to wall dispensing.",
          "fail": "Volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, dispense is not directed onto cells, or the faster-speed acknowledgment is missing."
        },
        "cd-collect": {
          "id": "cd-collect",
          "title": "Choose P1000 wide-bore and collect",
          "rule": "Explicitly select and use the P1000 wide-bore variant to transfer the suspension into a separate collection tube, using capacity-respecting draws.",
          "fail": "Collection uses standard/non-wide-bore tips or omits the required model selection."
        },
        "cd-dilute": {
          "id": "cd-dilute",
          "title": "Calculate dilution to exactly 12 mL",
          "rule": "Choose added medium as 12 mL minus the actual collected suspension volume. The tube must contain exactly 12 mL after dilution. The dilution addition has no 1\u20134 mL restriction.",
          "fail": "The model does not choose the dilution or the resulting tube volume is not 12 mL."
        },
        "cd-mix": {
          "id": "cd-mix",
          "title": "Mix after dilution with wide-bore",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, complete 1\u20135 up-and-down cycles inclusive after dilution and before distribution.",
          "fail": "Mixing is absent, exceeds five cycles, uses non-wide-bore, or occurs only before dilution."
        },
        "cd-distribute": {
          "id": "cd-distribute",
          "title": "Give each D well one-sixth",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, transfer one-sixth of the tube\u2019s starting, post-dilution volume into each of D\u2019s six wells: 2 mL each from 12 mL. Do not recalculate from the shrinking remainder.",
          "fail": "Any well receives a different share, a well is omitted, or distribution uses non-wide-bore."
        },
        "cd-motion": {
          "id": "cd-motion",
          "title": "Close D and distribute cells within wells",
          "rule": "Close D\u2019s lid and perform the simulated side-to-side and front-to-back plate-motion step before incubation.",
          "fail": "The required plate motion is skipped."
        },
        "cd-d-review": {
          "id": "cd-d-review",
          "title": "Image and review D",
          "rule": "Complete microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review after plate motion and before incubator placement. This review always passes.",
          "fail": "Acquisition or completed review is missing or incubation occurs first."
        },
        "cd-d-return": {
          "id": "cd-d-return",
          "title": "Put D in the incubator within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "From the final dispense into D\u2019s last well to incubator entry, allow at most 600 seconds, including plate motion, imaging and review.",
          "fail": "More than 600 seconds elapse or required intervening steps are bypassed."
        },
        "cd-lineage": {
          "id": "cd-lineage",
          "title": "Register D and dispose of C",
          "rule": "Register D as C\u2019s daughter with passage number increased by one (5 \u2192 6 here). Dispose of emptied C and preserve its lineage record.",
          "fail": "C is not disposed, or D\u2019s parentage/passage number is missing or incorrect."
        },
        "cd-day0": {
          "id": "cd-day0",
          "title": "Complete passage on day 0",
          "rule": "Complete C\u2192D passage, D registration and C disposal by day 0 24:00 (57600 seconds after the 08:00 epoch).",
          "fail": "Passage, registration or C disposal remains incomplete after day 0."
        },
        "cd-maintain": {
          "id": "cd-maintain",
          "title": "Maintain D every 48 hours, \u00b12 hours",
          "rule": "First feed is due 48 hours after initial incubator entry, with a 46\u201350-hour window. Repeat every 48 hours on the anchored schedule. The entire feeding workflow must fit within each \u00b12-hour window. Use A\u2019s pre/post imaging and review, full removal with tilt/no scraping, 2\u20134 mL wall addition per well, and 600-second return limit.",
          "fail": "Any subsequent feeding rule or the full-workflow timing window is missed."
        },
        "cd-final": {
          "id": "cd-final",
          "title": "Leave D ready",
          "rule": "At final submission, D is in its assigned incubator with its lid closed; source C is disposed.",
          "fail": "D is elsewhere, its lid is open, or C has not been disposed."
        },
        "d-schedule": {
          "id": "d-schedule",
          "title": "D feed schedule",
          "rule": "Complete each D feed within its assigned \u00b12-hour window."
        },
        "d-before": {
          "id": "d-before",
          "title": "D pre-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a fresh image for every D feed."
        },
        "d-remove": {
          "id": "d-remove",
          "title": "D complete removal",
          "rule": "Remove all old medium from every well with tilt, no scraping and at most one bottom touch."
        },
        "d-add": {
          "id": "d-add",
          "title": "D fresh medium",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall into each emptied well."
        },
        "d-after": {
          "id": "d-after",
          "title": "D post-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a new image after each D feed."
        },
        "d-return": {
          "id": "d-return",
          "title": "D incubator return",
          "rule": "Return within 600 seconds of the final dispense."
        },
        "d-final": {
          "id": "d-final",
          "title": "D \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned D feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "final-jobs": {
          "id": "final-jobs",
          "title": "Finish the workflow and complete all jobs",
          "rule": "Submit at day seven after running the workflow; all initiated jobs must be done, with no unfinished feed or wash sequence."
        },
        "final-robot": {
          "id": "final-robot",
          "title": "Finish pipetting and release the robot",
          "rule": "After executing pipetting and submitting at day seven, leave no held plate or attached tip."
        },
        "material-accounting": {
          "id": "material-accounting",
          "title": "Execute and conserve material",
          "rule": "After actual liquid transfers and day-seven submission, preserve material conservation and leave no cell clumps in waste."
        },
        "no-violation": {
          "id": "no-violation",
          "title": "Complete execution without violations",
          "rule": "Execute liquid handling and submit at day seven without terminal protocol violations or truncation."
        },
        "submitted": {
          "id": "submitted",
          "title": "Final submission",
          "rule": "Submit finish at exactly 604800 seconds."
        },
        "e-schedule": {
          "id": "e-schedule",
          "title": "E \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-before": {
          "id": "e-before",
          "title": "E \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-remove": {
          "id": "e-remove",
          "title": "E \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-add": {
          "id": "e-add",
          "title": "E \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-after": {
          "id": "e-after",
          "title": "E \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-return": {
          "id": "e-return",
          "title": "E \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-final": {
          "id": "e-final",
          "title": "E \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned E feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "f-schedule": {
          "id": "f-schedule",
          "title": "F \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-before": {
          "id": "f-before",
          "title": "F \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-remove": {
          "id": "f-remove",
          "title": "F \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-add": {
          "id": "f-add",
          "title": "F \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-after": {
          "id": "f-after",
          "title": "F \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-return": {
          "id": "f-return",
          "title": "F \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-final": {
          "id": "f-final",
          "title": "F \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned F feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "g-schedule": {
          "id": "g-schedule",
          "title": "G \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-before": {
          "id": "g-before",
          "title": "G \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-remove": {
          "id": "g-remove",
          "title": "G \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-add": {
          "id": "g-add",
          "title": "G \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-after": {
          "id": "g-after",
          "title": "G \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-return": {
          "id": "g-return",
          "title": "G \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-final": {
          "id": "g-final",
          "title": "G \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned G feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-intervention": {
          "id": "cd-intervention",
          "title": "Scientist intervention",
          "rule": "Complete scientist intervention when requested; do not invent an intervention on a branch that does not require it."
        },
        "equipment-recovery": {
          "id": "equipment-recovery",
          "title": "Recover failed acquisitions",
          "rule": "A failed acquisition must be followed by a successful image of the same plate and purpose without repeating material transfers."
        }
      },
      "journal_url": "data/gate-dashboard/journal-043ca2e731767f01.json",
      "agent_trace_url": "data/gate-dashboard/agent-challenge-01__JEZkqfk.json",
      "agent_trace_summary": {
        "available": true,
        "turn_count": 21,
        "tool_call_count": 21,
        "tool_error_count": 1
      },
      "url": "data/gate-dashboard/challenge-01__JEZkqfk.json",
      "gate_results": {
        "a-schedule": true,
        "a-before": true,
        "a-remove": true,
        "a-add": true,
        "a-after": true,
        "a-return": true,
        "a-final": true,
        "b-schedule": true,
        "b-before": true,
        "b-remove": true,
        "b-add": true,
        "b-after": true,
        "b-return": true,
        "b-final": true,
        "d-schedule": true,
        "d-before": true,
        "d-remove": true,
        "d-add": true,
        "d-after": true,
        "d-return": true,
        "d-final": true,
        "e-schedule": true,
        "e-before": true,
        "e-remove": true,
        "e-add": true,
        "e-after": true,
        "e-return": true,
        "e-final": true,
        "f-schedule": true,
        "f-before": true,
        "f-remove": true,
        "f-add": true,
        "f-after": true,
        "f-return": true,
        "f-final": true,
        "g-schedule": true,
        "g-before": true,
        "g-remove": true,
        "g-add": true,
        "g-after": true,
        "g-return": true,
        "g-final": true,
        "b-rock": true,
        "cd-eligible": true,
        "cd-coating": true,
        "cd-wash": true,
        "cd-release": true,
        "cd-incubate-first": true,
        "cd-review-first": true,
        "cd-incubate-second": true,
        "cd-review-second": true,
        "cd-intervention": true,
        "equipment-recovery": true,
        "cd-dislodge": true,
        "cd-collect": true,
        "cd-dilute": true,
        "cd-mix": true,
        "cd-distribute": true,
        "cd-motion": true,
        "cd-d-review": true,
        "cd-d-return": true,
        "cd-lineage": true,
        "cd-day0": true,
        "cd-maintain": true,
        "cd-final": true,
        "final-jobs": true,
        "final-robot": true,
        "material-accounting": true,
        "no-violation": true,
        "submitted": true
      },
      "gate_status": {
        "a-schedule": "completed",
        "a-before": "completed",
        "a-remove": "completed",
        "a-add": "completed",
        "a-after": "completed",
        "a-return": "completed",
        "a-final": "completed",
        "b-schedule": "completed",
        "b-before": "completed",
        "b-remove": "completed",
        "b-add": "completed",
        "b-after": "completed",
        "b-return": "completed",
        "b-final": "completed",
        "d-schedule": "completed",
        "d-before": "completed",
        "d-remove": "completed",
        "d-add": "completed",
        "d-after": "completed",
        "d-return": "completed",
        "d-final": "completed",
        "e-schedule": "completed",
        "e-before": "completed",
        "e-remove": "completed",
        "e-add": "completed",
        "e-after": "completed",
        "e-return": "completed",
        "e-final": "completed",
        "f-schedule": "completed",
        "f-before": "completed",
        "f-remove": "completed",
        "f-add": "completed",
        "f-after": "completed",
        "f-return": "completed",
        "f-final": "completed",
        "g-schedule": "completed",
        "g-before": "completed",
        "g-remove": "completed",
        "g-add": "completed",
        "g-after": "completed",
        "g-return": "completed",
        "g-final": "completed",
        "b-rock": "completed",
        "cd-eligible": "completed",
        "cd-coating": "completed",
        "cd-wash": "completed",
        "cd-release": "completed",
        "cd-incubate-first": "completed",
        "cd-review-first": "completed",
        "cd-incubate-second": "not_required",
        "cd-review-second": "not_required",
        "cd-intervention": "not_required",
        "equipment-recovery": "completed",
        "cd-dislodge": "completed",
        "cd-collect": "completed",
        "cd-dilute": "completed",
        "cd-mix": "completed",
        "cd-distribute": "completed",
        "cd-motion": "completed",
        "cd-d-review": "completed",
        "cd-d-return": "completed",
        "cd-lineage": "completed",
        "cd-day0": "completed",
        "cd-maintain": "completed",
        "cd-final": "completed",
        "final-jobs": "completed",
        "final-robot": "completed",
        "material-accounting": "completed",
        "no-violation": "completed",
        "submitted": "completed"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "challenge-01__6eDoxT9",
      "label": "Astra Max \u00b7 Challenge v4 \u00b7 reduced hints \u00b7 C return failure \u00b7 run 1",
      "role": "solver",
      "grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-challenge-v1",
        "scoring": "binary-challenge-decoupled-v1",
        "success": false,
        "reward": 0,
        "violations": [],
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": false,
          "a-before": false,
          "a-remove": false,
          "a-add": false,
          "a-after": false,
          "a-return": false,
          "a-final": false,
          "b-schedule": false,
          "b-before": false,
          "b-remove": false,
          "b-add": false,
          "b-after": false,
          "b-return": false,
          "b-final": false,
          "d-schedule": false,
          "d-before": false,
          "d-remove": false,
          "d-add": false,
          "d-after": false,
          "d-return": false,
          "d-final": false,
          "e-schedule": false,
          "e-before": false,
          "e-remove": false,
          "e-add": false,
          "e-after": false,
          "e-return": false,
          "e-final": false,
          "f-schedule": false,
          "f-before": false,
          "f-remove": false,
          "f-add": false,
          "f-after": false,
          "f-return": false,
          "f-final": false,
          "g-schedule": false,
          "g-before": false,
          "g-remove": false,
          "g-add": false,
          "g-after": false,
          "g-return": false,
          "g-final": false,
          "b-rock": false,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": false,
          "cd-wash": false,
          "cd-release": false,
          "cd-incubate-first": false,
          "cd-review-first": false,
          "cd-incubate-second": false,
          "cd-review-second": false,
          "cd-intervention": false,
          "equipment-recovery": false,
          "cd-dislodge": false,
          "cd-collect": false,
          "cd-dilute": false,
          "cd-mix": false,
          "cd-distribute": false,
          "cd-motion": false,
          "cd-d-review": false,
          "cd-d-return": false,
          "cd-lineage": false,
          "cd-day0": false,
          "cd-maintain": false,
          "cd-final": false,
          "final-jobs": false,
          "final-robot": false,
          "material-accounting": false,
          "no-violation": false,
          "submitted": false
        },
        "failed_gates": [
          "a-schedule",
          "a-before",
          "a-remove",
          "a-add",
          "a-after",
          "a-return",
          "a-final",
          "b-schedule",
          "b-before",
          "b-remove",
          "b-add",
          "b-after",
          "b-return",
          "b-final",
          "d-schedule",
          "d-before",
          "d-remove",
          "d-add",
          "d-after",
          "d-return",
          "d-final",
          "e-schedule",
          "e-before",
          "e-remove",
          "e-add",
          "e-after",
          "e-return",
          "e-final",
          "f-schedule",
          "f-before",
          "f-remove",
          "f-add",
          "f-after",
          "f-return",
          "f-final",
          "g-schedule",
          "g-before",
          "g-remove",
          "g-add",
          "g-after",
          "g-return",
          "g-final",
          "b-rock",
          "cd-coating",
          "cd-wash",
          "cd-release",
          "cd-incubate-first",
          "cd-review-first",
          "cd-incubate-second",
          "cd-review-second",
          "cd-intervention",
          "equipment-recovery",
          "cd-dislodge",
          "cd-collect",
          "cd-dilute",
          "cd-mix",
          "cd-distribute",
          "cd-motion",
          "cd-d-review",
          "cd-d-return",
          "cd-lineage",
          "cd-day0",
          "cd-maintain",
          "cd-final",
          "final-jobs",
          "final-robot",
          "material-accounting",
          "no-violation",
          "submitted"
        ],
        "failure": "C must reincubate when directed; empty C must be disposed",
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 180.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 0
      },
      "original_grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-challenge-v1",
        "scoring": "binary-challenge-v1",
        "success": false,
        "reward": 0,
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": false,
          "a-before": false,
          "a-remove": false,
          "a-add": false,
          "a-after": false,
          "a-return": false,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": false,
          "b-before": false,
          "b-remove": false,
          "b-add": false,
          "b-after": false,
          "b-return": false,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": false,
          "d-before": false,
          "d-remove": false,
          "d-add": false,
          "d-after": false,
          "d-return": false,
          "d-final": false,
          "e-schedule": false,
          "e-before": false,
          "e-remove": false,
          "e-add": false,
          "e-after": false,
          "e-return": false,
          "e-final": true,
          "f-schedule": false,
          "f-before": false,
          "f-remove": false,
          "f-add": false,
          "f-after": false,
          "f-return": false,
          "f-final": true,
          "g-schedule": false,
          "g-before": false,
          "g-remove": false,
          "g-add": false,
          "g-after": false,
          "g-return": false,
          "g-final": true,
          "b-rock": false,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": false,
          "cd-wash": false,
          "cd-release": false,
          "cd-incubate-first": false,
          "cd-review-first": false,
          "cd-incubate-second": false,
          "cd-review-second": false,
          "cd-intervention": true,
          "equipment-recovery": true,
          "cd-dislodge": false,
          "cd-collect": false,
          "cd-dilute": false,
          "cd-mix": false,
          "cd-distribute": false,
          "cd-motion": false,
          "cd-d-review": false,
          "cd-d-return": false,
          "cd-lineage": false,
          "cd-day0": false,
          "cd-maintain": false,
          "cd-final": false,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": false,
          "submitted": false
        },
        "failed_gates": [
          "a-schedule",
          "a-before",
          "a-remove",
          "a-add",
          "a-after",
          "a-return",
          "b-schedule",
          "b-before",
          "b-remove",
          "b-add",
          "b-after",
          "b-return",
          "d-schedule",
          "d-before",
          "d-remove",
          "d-add",
          "d-after",
          "d-return",
          "d-final",
          "e-schedule",
          "e-before",
          "e-remove",
          "e-add",
          "e-after",
          "e-return",
          "f-schedule",
          "f-before",
          "f-remove",
          "f-add",
          "f-after",
          "f-return",
          "g-schedule",
          "g-before",
          "g-remove",
          "g-add",
          "g-after",
          "g-return",
          "b-rock",
          "cd-coating",
          "cd-wash",
          "cd-release",
          "cd-incubate-first",
          "cd-review-first",
          "cd-incubate-second",
          "cd-review-second",
          "cd-dislodge",
          "cd-collect",
          "cd-dilute",
          "cd-mix",
          "cd-distribute",
          "cd-motion",
          "cd-d-review",
          "cd-d-return",
          "cd-lineage",
          "cd-day0",
          "cd-maintain",
          "cd-final",
          "no-violation",
          "submitted"
        ],
        "failure": "C must reincubate when directed; empty C must be disposed",
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 180.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 0
      },
      "grading_revision": "zero-noop-v1",
      "grader_sha256": "67893bf51fc12e627fde0a30a3d807dcc9bd3ae4b3a1fc7af19f93ea8bb35cdd",
      "execution_note": null,
      "source_commit": "a6fa4c88ca030a29244882093e26b5fa75cdfe7c",
      "edition": "Challenge v4 \u00b7 reduced hints \u00b7 C return failure",
      "runtime": "b08a0a51736ddd5ea7001b71798a33e41a3c14dd93fc14dc97ba4480b6d56470",
      "sha256": "059a95c8bd6a2e62340124f7f5fda8a9f8d66965b08e0de8c74560640f8faefa",
      "source": "jobs/challenge-v4-results/jobs/ipsc-challenge-v4-single-20261112T064620Z/challenge-01__6eDoxT9/artifacts/attempt.json",
      "exact_replay": true,
      "regraded": true,
      "rules": {
        "a-schedule": {
          "id": "a-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "Feed on days 0, 2, 4, and 6. The entire workflow, including imaging, review and incubator return, must fit within 09:00\u201317:00 on each day.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "a-before": {
          "id": "a-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "a-remove": {
          "id": "a-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "a-add": {
          "id": "a-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "a-after": {
          "id": "a-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "a-return": {
          "id": "a-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "a-final": {
          "id": "a-final",
          "title": "A \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned A feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "b-rock": {
          "id": "b-rock",
          "title": "B ROCK removal window",
          "rule": "Complete removal 22\u201326 hours after the observed recovery timestamp."
        },
        "b-schedule": {
          "id": "b-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "After the recovery feed, feed on days 2, 4, and 6, with the entire workflow within 09:00\u201317:00. The first feed uses the ROCK-removal exception in step 01.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "b-before": {
          "id": "b-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "b-remove": {
          "id": "b-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "b-add": {
          "id": "b-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "b-after": {
          "id": "b-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "b-return": {
          "id": "b-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "b-final": {
          "id": "b-final",
          "title": "B \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned B feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-eligible": {
          "id": "cd-eligible",
          "title": "Check C before passaging",
          "rule": "Obtain a pre-passage image and scientist assessment. Confluence of 70\u2013100% is acceptable, including both endpoints.",
          "fail": "Confluence is below 70% or eligibility evidence is missing. There is no block at 100%."
        },
        "cd-coating": {
          "id": "cd-coating",
          "title": "Empty all six coated D wells",
          "rule": "Remove all coating liquid from every destination well before source treatment.",
          "fail": "Any coating liquid remains in any of the six wells."
        },
        "cd-wash": {
          "id": "cd-wash",
          "title": "Remove medium, wash, and remove PBS",
          "rule": "Remove all spent medium from C. Wash with 1\u20134 mL PBS inclusive, then remove all wash liquid without a deliberate pause.",
          "fail": "Spent medium or PBS remains at its removal checkpoint, wash volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, or a deliberate hold interrupts washing/removal."
        },
        "cd-release": {
          "id": "cd-release",
          "title": "Add and fully remove ReLeSR",
          "rule": "Add 800\u20131,200 \u00b5L ReLeSR inclusive, then remove all of it. No thin film or fixed residual remains.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside the range or any ReLeSR liquid remains after removal."
        },
        "cd-incubate-first": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-first",
          "title": "Incubate for 2\u20134 minutes",
          "rule": "Place C in the incubator for 120\u2013240 seconds inclusive after ReLeSR removal.",
          "fail": "Initial incubation is missing, shorter than 120 seconds, or longer than 240 seconds."
        },
        "cd-review-first": {
          "id": "cd-review-first",
          "title": "Image and receive the first negative review",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-incubate-second": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-second",
          "title": "Return C for a second incubation",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-review-second": {
          "id": "cd-review-second",
          "title": "Image again and obtain approval",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-dislodge": {
          "id": "cd-dislodge",
          "title": "Dispense directly onto cells at faster speed",
          "rule": "After approval, add 1\u20134 mL medium inclusive directly onto C\u2019s cells and explicitly acknowledge faster pipette speed to the simulator. This replaces tapping and is the exception to wall dispensing.",
          "fail": "Volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, dispense is not directed onto cells, or the faster-speed acknowledgment is missing."
        },
        "cd-collect": {
          "id": "cd-collect",
          "title": "Choose P1000 wide-bore and collect",
          "rule": "Explicitly select and use the P1000 wide-bore variant to transfer the suspension into a separate collection tube, using capacity-respecting draws.",
          "fail": "Collection uses standard/non-wide-bore tips or omits the required model selection."
        },
        "cd-dilute": {
          "id": "cd-dilute",
          "title": "Calculate dilution to exactly 12 mL",
          "rule": "Choose added medium as 12 mL minus the actual collected suspension volume. The tube must contain exactly 12 mL after dilution. The dilution addition has no 1\u20134 mL restriction.",
          "fail": "The model does not choose the dilution or the resulting tube volume is not 12 mL."
        },
        "cd-mix": {
          "id": "cd-mix",
          "title": "Mix after dilution with wide-bore",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, complete 1\u20135 up-and-down cycles inclusive after dilution and before distribution.",
          "fail": "Mixing is absent, exceeds five cycles, uses non-wide-bore, or occurs only before dilution."
        },
        "cd-distribute": {
          "id": "cd-distribute",
          "title": "Give each D well one-sixth",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, transfer one-sixth of the tube\u2019s starting, post-dilution volume into each of D\u2019s six wells: 2 mL each from 12 mL. Do not recalculate from the shrinking remainder.",
          "fail": "Any well receives a different share, a well is omitted, or distribution uses non-wide-bore."
        },
        "cd-motion": {
          "id": "cd-motion",
          "title": "Close D and distribute cells within wells",
          "rule": "Close D\u2019s lid and perform the simulated side-to-side and front-to-back plate-motion step before incubation.",
          "fail": "The required plate motion is skipped."
        },
        "cd-d-review": {
          "id": "cd-d-review",
          "title": "Image and review D",
          "rule": "Complete microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review after plate motion and before incubator placement. This review always passes.",
          "fail": "Acquisition or completed review is missing or incubation occurs first."
        },
        "cd-d-return": {
          "id": "cd-d-return",
          "title": "Put D in the incubator within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "From the final dispense into D\u2019s last well to incubator entry, allow at most 600 seconds, including plate motion, imaging and review.",
          "fail": "More than 600 seconds elapse or required intervening steps are bypassed."
        },
        "cd-lineage": {
          "id": "cd-lineage",
          "title": "Register D and dispose of C",
          "rule": "Register D as C\u2019s daughter with passage number increased by one (5 \u2192 6 here). Dispose of emptied C and preserve its lineage record.",
          "fail": "C is not disposed, or D\u2019s parentage/passage number is missing or incorrect."
        },
        "cd-day0": {
          "id": "cd-day0",
          "title": "Complete passage on day 0",
          "rule": "Complete C\u2192D passage, D registration and C disposal by day 0 24:00 (57600 seconds after the 08:00 epoch).",
          "fail": "Passage, registration or C disposal remains incomplete after day 0."
        },
        "cd-maintain": {
          "id": "cd-maintain",
          "title": "Maintain D every 48 hours, \u00b12 hours",
          "rule": "First feed is due 48 hours after initial incubator entry, with a 46\u201350-hour window. Repeat every 48 hours on the anchored schedule. The entire feeding workflow must fit within each \u00b12-hour window. Use A\u2019s pre/post imaging and review, full removal with tilt/no scraping, 2\u20134 mL wall addition per well, and 600-second return limit.",
          "fail": "Any subsequent feeding rule or the full-workflow timing window is missed."
        },
        "cd-final": {
          "id": "cd-final",
          "title": "Leave D ready",
          "rule": "At final submission, D is in its assigned incubator with its lid closed; source C is disposed.",
          "fail": "D is elsewhere, its lid is open, or C has not been disposed."
        },
        "d-schedule": {
          "id": "d-schedule",
          "title": "D feed schedule",
          "rule": "Complete each D feed within its assigned \u00b12-hour window."
        },
        "d-before": {
          "id": "d-before",
          "title": "D pre-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a fresh image for every D feed."
        },
        "d-remove": {
          "id": "d-remove",
          "title": "D complete removal",
          "rule": "Remove all old medium from every well with tilt, no scraping and at most one bottom touch."
        },
        "d-add": {
          "id": "d-add",
          "title": "D fresh medium",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall into each emptied well."
        },
        "d-after": {
          "id": "d-after",
          "title": "D post-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a new image after each D feed."
        },
        "d-return": {
          "id": "d-return",
          "title": "D incubator return",
          "rule": "Return within 600 seconds of the final dispense."
        },
        "d-final": {
          "id": "d-final",
          "title": "D \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned D feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "final-jobs": {
          "id": "final-jobs",
          "title": "Finish the workflow and complete all jobs",
          "rule": "Submit at day seven after running the workflow; all initiated jobs must be done, with no unfinished feed or wash sequence."
        },
        "final-robot": {
          "id": "final-robot",
          "title": "Finish pipetting and release the robot",
          "rule": "After executing pipetting and submitting at day seven, leave no held plate or attached tip."
        },
        "material-accounting": {
          "id": "material-accounting",
          "title": "Execute and conserve material",
          "rule": "After actual liquid transfers and day-seven submission, preserve material conservation and leave no cell clumps in waste."
        },
        "no-violation": {
          "id": "no-violation",
          "title": "Complete execution without violations",
          "rule": "Execute liquid handling and submit at day seven without terminal protocol violations or truncation."
        },
        "submitted": {
          "id": "submitted",
          "title": "Final submission",
          "rule": "Submit finish at exactly 604800 seconds."
        },
        "e-schedule": {
          "id": "e-schedule",
          "title": "E \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-before": {
          "id": "e-before",
          "title": "E \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-remove": {
          "id": "e-remove",
          "title": "E \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-add": {
          "id": "e-add",
          "title": "E \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-after": {
          "id": "e-after",
          "title": "E \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-return": {
          "id": "e-return",
          "title": "E \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-final": {
          "id": "e-final",
          "title": "E \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned E feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "f-schedule": {
          "id": "f-schedule",
          "title": "F \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-before": {
          "id": "f-before",
          "title": "F \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-remove": {
          "id": "f-remove",
          "title": "F \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-add": {
          "id": "f-add",
          "title": "F \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-after": {
          "id": "f-after",
          "title": "F \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-return": {
          "id": "f-return",
          "title": "F \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-final": {
          "id": "f-final",
          "title": "F \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned F feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "g-schedule": {
          "id": "g-schedule",
          "title": "G \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-before": {
          "id": "g-before",
          "title": "G \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-remove": {
          "id": "g-remove",
          "title": "G \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-add": {
          "id": "g-add",
          "title": "G \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-after": {
          "id": "g-after",
          "title": "G \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-return": {
          "id": "g-return",
          "title": "G \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-final": {
          "id": "g-final",
          "title": "G \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned G feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-intervention": {
          "id": "cd-intervention",
          "title": "Scientist intervention",
          "rule": "Complete scientist intervention when requested; do not invent an intervention on a branch that does not require it."
        },
        "equipment-recovery": {
          "id": "equipment-recovery",
          "title": "Recover failed acquisitions",
          "rule": "A failed acquisition must be followed by a successful image of the same plate and purpose without repeating material transfers."
        }
      },
      "journal_url": "data/gate-dashboard/journal-059a95c8bd6a2e62.json",
      "agent_trace_url": "data/gate-dashboard/agent-challenge-01__6eDoxT9.json",
      "agent_trace_summary": {
        "available": true,
        "turn_count": 8,
        "tool_call_count": 7,
        "tool_error_count": 1
      },
      "url": "data/gate-dashboard/challenge-01__6eDoxT9.json",
      "gate_results": {
        "a-schedule": false,
        "a-before": false,
        "a-remove": false,
        "a-add": false,
        "a-after": false,
        "a-return": false,
        "a-final": false,
        "b-schedule": false,
        "b-before": false,
        "b-remove": false,
        "b-add": false,
        "b-after": false,
        "b-return": false,
        "b-final": false,
        "d-schedule": false,
        "d-before": false,
        "d-remove": false,
        "d-add": false,
        "d-after": false,
        "d-return": false,
        "d-final": false,
        "e-schedule": false,
        "e-before": false,
        "e-remove": false,
        "e-add": false,
        "e-after": false,
        "e-return": false,
        "e-final": false,
        "f-schedule": false,
        "f-before": false,
        "f-remove": false,
        "f-add": false,
        "f-after": false,
        "f-return": false,
        "f-final": false,
        "g-schedule": false,
        "g-before": false,
        "g-remove": false,
        "g-add": false,
        "g-after": false,
        "g-return": false,
        "g-final": false,
        "b-rock": false,
        "cd-eligible": true,
        "cd-coating": false,
        "cd-wash": false,
        "cd-release": false,
        "cd-incubate-first": false,
        "cd-review-first": false,
        "cd-incubate-second": false,
        "cd-review-second": false,
        "cd-intervention": false,
        "equipment-recovery": false,
        "cd-dislodge": false,
        "cd-collect": false,
        "cd-dilute": false,
        "cd-mix": false,
        "cd-distribute": false,
        "cd-motion": false,
        "cd-d-review": false,
        "cd-d-return": false,
        "cd-lineage": false,
        "cd-day0": false,
        "cd-maintain": false,
        "cd-final": false,
        "final-jobs": false,
        "final-robot": false,
        "material-accounting": false,
        "no-violation": false,
        "submitted": false
      },
      "gate_status": {
        "a-schedule": "failed",
        "a-before": "failed",
        "a-remove": "failed",
        "a-add": "failed",
        "a-after": "failed",
        "a-return": "failed",
        "a-final": "failed",
        "b-schedule": "failed",
        "b-before": "failed",
        "b-remove": "failed",
        "b-add": "failed",
        "b-after": "failed",
        "b-return": "failed",
        "b-final": "failed",
        "d-schedule": "failed",
        "d-before": "failed",
        "d-remove": "failed",
        "d-add": "failed",
        "d-after": "failed",
        "d-return": "failed",
        "d-final": "failed",
        "e-schedule": "failed",
        "e-before": "failed",
        "e-remove": "failed",
        "e-add": "failed",
        "e-after": "failed",
        "e-return": "failed",
        "e-final": "failed",
        "f-schedule": "failed",
        "f-before": "failed",
        "f-remove": "failed",
        "f-add": "failed",
        "f-after": "failed",
        "f-return": "failed",
        "f-final": "failed",
        "g-schedule": "failed",
        "g-before": "failed",
        "g-remove": "failed",
        "g-add": "failed",
        "g-after": "failed",
        "g-return": "failed",
        "g-final": "failed",
        "b-rock": "failed",
        "cd-eligible": "completed",
        "cd-coating": "failed",
        "cd-wash": "failed",
        "cd-release": "failed",
        "cd-incubate-first": "failed",
        "cd-review-first": "failed",
        "cd-incubate-second": "failed",
        "cd-review-second": "failed",
        "cd-intervention": "failed",
        "equipment-recovery": "failed",
        "cd-dislodge": "failed",
        "cd-collect": "failed",
        "cd-dilute": "failed",
        "cd-mix": "failed",
        "cd-distribute": "failed",
        "cd-motion": "failed",
        "cd-d-review": "failed",
        "cd-d-return": "failed",
        "cd-lineage": "failed",
        "cd-day0": "failed",
        "cd-maintain": "failed",
        "cd-final": "failed",
        "final-jobs": "failed",
        "final-robot": "failed",
        "material-accounting": "failed",
        "no-violation": "failed",
        "submitted": "failed"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "challenge-01__at29Xqf",
      "label": "Astra Max \u00b7 Challenge v3 \u00b7 no technique instructions \u00b7 run 1",
      "role": "solver",
      "grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-challenge-v1",
        "scoring": "binary-challenge-decoupled-v1",
        "success": true,
        "reward": 1,
        "violations": [],
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": true,
          "a-before": true,
          "a-remove": true,
          "a-add": true,
          "a-after": true,
          "a-return": true,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": true,
          "b-before": true,
          "b-remove": true,
          "b-add": true,
          "b-after": true,
          "b-return": true,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": true,
          "d-before": true,
          "d-remove": true,
          "d-add": true,
          "d-after": true,
          "d-return": true,
          "d-final": true,
          "e-schedule": true,
          "e-before": true,
          "e-remove": true,
          "e-add": true,
          "e-after": true,
          "e-return": true,
          "e-final": true,
          "f-schedule": true,
          "f-before": true,
          "f-remove": true,
          "f-add": true,
          "f-after": true,
          "f-return": true,
          "f-final": true,
          "g-schedule": true,
          "g-before": true,
          "g-remove": true,
          "g-add": true,
          "g-after": true,
          "g-return": true,
          "g-final": true,
          "b-rock": true,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": true,
          "cd-wash": true,
          "cd-release": true,
          "cd-incubate-first": true,
          "cd-review-first": true,
          "cd-incubate-second": true,
          "cd-review-second": true,
          "cd-intervention": true,
          "equipment-recovery": true,
          "cd-dislodge": true,
          "cd-collect": true,
          "cd-dilute": true,
          "cd-mix": true,
          "cd-distribute": true,
          "cd-motion": true,
          "cd-d-review": true,
          "cd-d-return": true,
          "cd-lineage": true,
          "cd-day0": true,
          "cd-maintain": true,
          "cd-final": true,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": true,
          "submitted": true
        },
        "failed_gates": [],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 604800.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 97
      },
      "original_grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-challenge-v1",
        "scoring": "binary-challenge-v1",
        "success": true,
        "reward": 1,
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": true,
          "a-before": true,
          "a-remove": true,
          "a-add": true,
          "a-after": true,
          "a-return": true,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": true,
          "b-before": true,
          "b-remove": true,
          "b-add": true,
          "b-after": true,
          "b-return": true,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": true,
          "d-before": true,
          "d-remove": true,
          "d-add": true,
          "d-after": true,
          "d-return": true,
          "d-final": true,
          "e-schedule": true,
          "e-before": true,
          "e-remove": true,
          "e-add": true,
          "e-after": true,
          "e-return": true,
          "e-final": true,
          "f-schedule": true,
          "f-before": true,
          "f-remove": true,
          "f-add": true,
          "f-after": true,
          "f-return": true,
          "f-final": true,
          "g-schedule": true,
          "g-before": true,
          "g-remove": true,
          "g-add": true,
          "g-after": true,
          "g-return": true,
          "g-final": true,
          "b-rock": true,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": true,
          "cd-wash": true,
          "cd-release": true,
          "cd-incubate-first": true,
          "cd-review-first": true,
          "cd-incubate-second": true,
          "cd-review-second": true,
          "cd-intervention": true,
          "equipment-recovery": true,
          "cd-dislodge": true,
          "cd-collect": true,
          "cd-dilute": true,
          "cd-mix": true,
          "cd-distribute": true,
          "cd-motion": true,
          "cd-d-review": true,
          "cd-d-return": true,
          "cd-lineage": true,
          "cd-day0": true,
          "cd-maintain": true,
          "cd-final": true,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": true,
          "submitted": true
        },
        "failed_gates": [],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 604800.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 97
      },
      "grading_revision": "zero-noop-v1",
      "grader_sha256": "67893bf51fc12e627fde0a30a3d807dcc9bd3ae4b3a1fc7af19f93ea8bb35cdd",
      "execution_note": null,
      "source_commit": "8bc403c69e22",
      "edition": "Challenge v3 \u00b7 no technique instructions",
      "runtime": "91e73641e256c604590d696c4010469d2030ccb106760a81484e244f99dd1a34",
      "sha256": "c45374842e0e316e3019ba842c753a075c0b1b1c5327d460f1ed6ab6a3cd5d70",
      "source": "jobs/challenge-v3-results/jobs/ipsc-challenge-v3-single-20261112T054559Z/challenge-01__at29Xqf/artifacts/attempt.json",
      "exact_replay": true,
      "regraded": true,
      "rules": {
        "a-schedule": {
          "id": "a-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "Feed on days 0, 2, 4, and 6. The entire workflow, including imaging, review and incubator return, must fit within 09:00\u201317:00 on each day.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "a-before": {
          "id": "a-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "a-remove": {
          "id": "a-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "a-add": {
          "id": "a-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "a-after": {
          "id": "a-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "a-return": {
          "id": "a-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "a-final": {
          "id": "a-final",
          "title": "A \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned A feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "b-rock": {
          "id": "b-rock",
          "title": "B ROCK removal window",
          "rule": "Complete removal 22\u201326 hours after the observed recovery timestamp."
        },
        "b-schedule": {
          "id": "b-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "After the recovery feed, feed on days 2, 4, and 6, with the entire workflow within 09:00\u201317:00. The first feed uses the ROCK-removal exception in step 01.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "b-before": {
          "id": "b-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "b-remove": {
          "id": "b-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "b-add": {
          "id": "b-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "b-after": {
          "id": "b-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "b-return": {
          "id": "b-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "b-final": {
          "id": "b-final",
          "title": "B \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned B feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-eligible": {
          "id": "cd-eligible",
          "title": "Check C before passaging",
          "rule": "Obtain a pre-passage image and scientist assessment. Confluence of 70\u2013100% is acceptable, including both endpoints.",
          "fail": "Confluence is below 70% or eligibility evidence is missing. There is no block at 100%."
        },
        "cd-coating": {
          "id": "cd-coating",
          "title": "Empty all six coated D wells",
          "rule": "Remove all coating liquid from every destination well before source treatment.",
          "fail": "Any coating liquid remains in any of the six wells."
        },
        "cd-wash": {
          "id": "cd-wash",
          "title": "Remove medium, wash, and remove PBS",
          "rule": "Remove all spent medium from C. Wash with 1\u20134 mL PBS inclusive, then remove all wash liquid without a deliberate pause.",
          "fail": "Spent medium or PBS remains at its removal checkpoint, wash volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, or a deliberate hold interrupts washing/removal."
        },
        "cd-release": {
          "id": "cd-release",
          "title": "Add and fully remove ReLeSR",
          "rule": "Add 800\u20131,200 \u00b5L ReLeSR inclusive, then remove all of it. No thin film or fixed residual remains.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside the range or any ReLeSR liquid remains after removal."
        },
        "cd-incubate-first": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-first",
          "title": "Incubate for 2\u20134 minutes",
          "rule": "Place C in the incubator for 120\u2013240 seconds inclusive after ReLeSR removal.",
          "fail": "Initial incubation is missing, shorter than 120 seconds, or longer than 240 seconds."
        },
        "cd-review-first": {
          "id": "cd-review-first",
          "title": "Image and receive the first negative review",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-incubate-second": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-second",
          "title": "Return C for a second incubation",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-review-second": {
          "id": "cd-review-second",
          "title": "Image again and obtain approval",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-dislodge": {
          "id": "cd-dislodge",
          "title": "Dispense directly onto cells at faster speed",
          "rule": "After approval, add 1\u20134 mL medium inclusive directly onto C\u2019s cells and explicitly acknowledge faster pipette speed to the simulator. This replaces tapping and is the exception to wall dispensing.",
          "fail": "Volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, dispense is not directed onto cells, or the faster-speed acknowledgment is missing."
        },
        "cd-collect": {
          "id": "cd-collect",
          "title": "Choose P1000 wide-bore and collect",
          "rule": "Explicitly select and use the P1000 wide-bore variant to transfer the suspension into a separate collection tube, using capacity-respecting draws.",
          "fail": "Collection uses standard/non-wide-bore tips or omits the required model selection."
        },
        "cd-dilute": {
          "id": "cd-dilute",
          "title": "Calculate dilution to exactly 12 mL",
          "rule": "Choose added medium as 12 mL minus the actual collected suspension volume. The tube must contain exactly 12 mL after dilution. The dilution addition has no 1\u20134 mL restriction.",
          "fail": "The model does not choose the dilution or the resulting tube volume is not 12 mL."
        },
        "cd-mix": {
          "id": "cd-mix",
          "title": "Mix after dilution with wide-bore",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, complete 1\u20135 up-and-down cycles inclusive after dilution and before distribution.",
          "fail": "Mixing is absent, exceeds five cycles, uses non-wide-bore, or occurs only before dilution."
        },
        "cd-distribute": {
          "id": "cd-distribute",
          "title": "Give each D well one-sixth",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, transfer one-sixth of the tube\u2019s starting, post-dilution volume into each of D\u2019s six wells: 2 mL each from 12 mL. Do not recalculate from the shrinking remainder.",
          "fail": "Any well receives a different share, a well is omitted, or distribution uses non-wide-bore."
        },
        "cd-motion": {
          "id": "cd-motion",
          "title": "Close D and distribute cells within wells",
          "rule": "Close D\u2019s lid and perform the simulated side-to-side and front-to-back plate-motion step before incubation.",
          "fail": "The required plate motion is skipped."
        },
        "cd-d-review": {
          "id": "cd-d-review",
          "title": "Image and review D",
          "rule": "Complete microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review after plate motion and before incubator placement. This review always passes.",
          "fail": "Acquisition or completed review is missing or incubation occurs first."
        },
        "cd-d-return": {
          "id": "cd-d-return",
          "title": "Put D in the incubator within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "From the final dispense into D\u2019s last well to incubator entry, allow at most 600 seconds, including plate motion, imaging and review.",
          "fail": "More than 600 seconds elapse or required intervening steps are bypassed."
        },
        "cd-lineage": {
          "id": "cd-lineage",
          "title": "Register D and dispose of C",
          "rule": "Register D as C\u2019s daughter with passage number increased by one (5 \u2192 6 here). Dispose of emptied C and preserve its lineage record.",
          "fail": "C is not disposed, or D\u2019s parentage/passage number is missing or incorrect."
        },
        "cd-day0": {
          "id": "cd-day0",
          "title": "Complete passage on day 0",
          "rule": "Complete C\u2192D passage, D registration and C disposal by day 0 24:00 (57600 seconds after the 08:00 epoch).",
          "fail": "Passage, registration or C disposal remains incomplete after day 0."
        },
        "cd-maintain": {
          "id": "cd-maintain",
          "title": "Maintain D every 48 hours, \u00b12 hours",
          "rule": "First feed is due 48 hours after initial incubator entry, with a 46\u201350-hour window. Repeat every 48 hours on the anchored schedule. The entire feeding workflow must fit within each \u00b12-hour window. Use A\u2019s pre/post imaging and review, full removal with tilt/no scraping, 2\u20134 mL wall addition per well, and 600-second return limit.",
          "fail": "Any subsequent feeding rule or the full-workflow timing window is missed."
        },
        "cd-final": {
          "id": "cd-final",
          "title": "Leave D ready",
          "rule": "At final submission, D is in its assigned incubator with its lid closed; source C is disposed.",
          "fail": "D is elsewhere, its lid is open, or C has not been disposed."
        },
        "d-schedule": {
          "id": "d-schedule",
          "title": "D feed schedule",
          "rule": "Complete each D feed within its assigned \u00b12-hour window."
        },
        "d-before": {
          "id": "d-before",
          "title": "D pre-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a fresh image for every D feed."
        },
        "d-remove": {
          "id": "d-remove",
          "title": "D complete removal",
          "rule": "Remove all old medium from every well with tilt, no scraping and at most one bottom touch."
        },
        "d-add": {
          "id": "d-add",
          "title": "D fresh medium",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall into each emptied well."
        },
        "d-after": {
          "id": "d-after",
          "title": "D post-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a new image after each D feed."
        },
        "d-return": {
          "id": "d-return",
          "title": "D incubator return",
          "rule": "Return within 600 seconds of the final dispense."
        },
        "d-final": {
          "id": "d-final",
          "title": "D \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned D feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "final-jobs": {
          "id": "final-jobs",
          "title": "Finish the workflow and complete all jobs",
          "rule": "Submit at day seven after running the workflow; all initiated jobs must be done, with no unfinished feed or wash sequence."
        },
        "final-robot": {
          "id": "final-robot",
          "title": "Finish pipetting and release the robot",
          "rule": "After executing pipetting and submitting at day seven, leave no held plate or attached tip."
        },
        "material-accounting": {
          "id": "material-accounting",
          "title": "Execute and conserve material",
          "rule": "After actual liquid transfers and day-seven submission, preserve material conservation and leave no cell clumps in waste."
        },
        "no-violation": {
          "id": "no-violation",
          "title": "Complete execution without violations",
          "rule": "Execute liquid handling and submit at day seven without terminal protocol violations or truncation."
        },
        "submitted": {
          "id": "submitted",
          "title": "Final submission",
          "rule": "Submit finish at exactly 604800 seconds."
        },
        "e-schedule": {
          "id": "e-schedule",
          "title": "E \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-before": {
          "id": "e-before",
          "title": "E \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-remove": {
          "id": "e-remove",
          "title": "E \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-add": {
          "id": "e-add",
          "title": "E \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-after": {
          "id": "e-after",
          "title": "E \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-return": {
          "id": "e-return",
          "title": "E \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-final": {
          "id": "e-final",
          "title": "E \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned E feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "f-schedule": {
          "id": "f-schedule",
          "title": "F \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-before": {
          "id": "f-before",
          "title": "F \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-remove": {
          "id": "f-remove",
          "title": "F \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-add": {
          "id": "f-add",
          "title": "F \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-after": {
          "id": "f-after",
          "title": "F \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-return": {
          "id": "f-return",
          "title": "F \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-final": {
          "id": "f-final",
          "title": "F \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned F feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "g-schedule": {
          "id": "g-schedule",
          "title": "G \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-before": {
          "id": "g-before",
          "title": "G \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-remove": {
          "id": "g-remove",
          "title": "G \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-add": {
          "id": "g-add",
          "title": "G \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-after": {
          "id": "g-after",
          "title": "G \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-return": {
          "id": "g-return",
          "title": "G \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-final": {
          "id": "g-final",
          "title": "G \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned G feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-intervention": {
          "id": "cd-intervention",
          "title": "Scientist intervention",
          "rule": "Complete scientist intervention when requested; do not invent an intervention on a branch that does not require it."
        },
        "equipment-recovery": {
          "id": "equipment-recovery",
          "title": "Recover failed acquisitions",
          "rule": "A failed acquisition must be followed by a successful image of the same plate and purpose without repeating material transfers."
        }
      },
      "journal_url": "data/gate-dashboard/journal-c45374842e0e316e.json",
      "agent_trace_url": "data/gate-dashboard/agent-challenge-01__at29Xqf.json",
      "agent_trace_summary": {
        "available": true,
        "turn_count": 19,
        "tool_call_count": 18,
        "tool_error_count": 0
      },
      "url": "data/gate-dashboard/challenge-01__at29Xqf.json",
      "gate_results": {
        "a-schedule": true,
        "a-before": true,
        "a-remove": true,
        "a-add": true,
        "a-after": true,
        "a-return": true,
        "a-final": true,
        "b-schedule": true,
        "b-before": true,
        "b-remove": true,
        "b-add": true,
        "b-after": true,
        "b-return": true,
        "b-final": true,
        "d-schedule": true,
        "d-before": true,
        "d-remove": true,
        "d-add": true,
        "d-after": true,
        "d-return": true,
        "d-final": true,
        "e-schedule": true,
        "e-before": true,
        "e-remove": true,
        "e-add": true,
        "e-after": true,
        "e-return": true,
        "e-final": true,
        "f-schedule": true,
        "f-before": true,
        "f-remove": true,
        "f-add": true,
        "f-after": true,
        "f-return": true,
        "f-final": true,
        "g-schedule": true,
        "g-before": true,
        "g-remove": true,
        "g-add": true,
        "g-after": true,
        "g-return": true,
        "g-final": true,
        "b-rock": true,
        "cd-eligible": true,
        "cd-coating": true,
        "cd-wash": true,
        "cd-release": true,
        "cd-incubate-first": true,
        "cd-review-first": true,
        "cd-incubate-second": true,
        "cd-review-second": true,
        "cd-intervention": true,
        "equipment-recovery": true,
        "cd-dislodge": true,
        "cd-collect": true,
        "cd-dilute": true,
        "cd-mix": true,
        "cd-distribute": true,
        "cd-motion": true,
        "cd-d-review": true,
        "cd-d-return": true,
        "cd-lineage": true,
        "cd-day0": true,
        "cd-maintain": true,
        "cd-final": true,
        "final-jobs": true,
        "final-robot": true,
        "material-accounting": true,
        "no-violation": true,
        "submitted": true
      },
      "gate_status": {
        "a-schedule": "completed",
        "a-before": "completed",
        "a-remove": "completed",
        "a-add": "completed",
        "a-after": "completed",
        "a-return": "completed",
        "a-final": "completed",
        "b-schedule": "completed",
        "b-before": "completed",
        "b-remove": "completed",
        "b-add": "completed",
        "b-after": "completed",
        "b-return": "completed",
        "b-final": "completed",
        "d-schedule": "completed",
        "d-before": "completed",
        "d-remove": "completed",
        "d-add": "completed",
        "d-after": "completed",
        "d-return": "completed",
        "d-final": "completed",
        "e-schedule": "completed",
        "e-before": "completed",
        "e-remove": "completed",
        "e-add": "completed",
        "e-after": "completed",
        "e-return": "completed",
        "e-final": "completed",
        "f-schedule": "completed",
        "f-before": "completed",
        "f-remove": "completed",
        "f-add": "completed",
        "f-after": "completed",
        "f-return": "completed",
        "f-final": "completed",
        "g-schedule": "completed",
        "g-before": "completed",
        "g-remove": "completed",
        "g-add": "completed",
        "g-after": "completed",
        "g-return": "completed",
        "g-final": "completed",
        "b-rock": "completed",
        "cd-eligible": "completed",
        "cd-coating": "completed",
        "cd-wash": "completed",
        "cd-release": "completed",
        "cd-incubate-first": "completed",
        "cd-review-first": "completed",
        "cd-incubate-second": "not_required",
        "cd-review-second": "not_required",
        "cd-intervention": "not_required",
        "equipment-recovery": "completed",
        "cd-dislodge": "completed",
        "cd-collect": "completed",
        "cd-dilute": "completed",
        "cd-mix": "completed",
        "cd-distribute": "completed",
        "cd-motion": "completed",
        "cd-d-review": "completed",
        "cd-d-return": "completed",
        "cd-lineage": "completed",
        "cd-day0": "completed",
        "cd-maintain": "completed",
        "cd-final": "completed",
        "final-jobs": "completed",
        "final-robot": "completed",
        "material-accounting": "completed",
        "no-violation": "completed",
        "submitted": "completed"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "challenge-01__RHZVmSK",
      "label": "Astra Max \u00b7 Challenge v1 \u00b7 technique instructions supplied \u00b7 run 1",
      "role": "solver",
      "grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-challenge-v1",
        "scoring": "binary-challenge-decoupled-v1",
        "success": true,
        "reward": 1,
        "violations": [],
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": true,
          "a-before": true,
          "a-remove": true,
          "a-add": true,
          "a-after": true,
          "a-return": true,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": true,
          "b-before": true,
          "b-remove": true,
          "b-add": true,
          "b-after": true,
          "b-return": true,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": true,
          "d-before": true,
          "d-remove": true,
          "d-add": true,
          "d-after": true,
          "d-return": true,
          "d-final": true,
          "e-schedule": true,
          "e-before": true,
          "e-remove": true,
          "e-add": true,
          "e-after": true,
          "e-return": true,
          "e-final": true,
          "f-schedule": true,
          "f-before": true,
          "f-remove": true,
          "f-add": true,
          "f-after": true,
          "f-return": true,
          "f-final": true,
          "g-schedule": true,
          "g-before": true,
          "g-remove": true,
          "g-add": true,
          "g-after": true,
          "g-return": true,
          "g-final": true,
          "b-rock": true,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": true,
          "cd-wash": true,
          "cd-release": true,
          "cd-incubate-first": true,
          "cd-review-first": true,
          "cd-incubate-second": true,
          "cd-review-second": true,
          "cd-intervention": true,
          "equipment-recovery": true,
          "cd-dislodge": true,
          "cd-collect": true,
          "cd-dilute": true,
          "cd-mix": true,
          "cd-distribute": true,
          "cd-motion": true,
          "cd-d-review": true,
          "cd-d-return": true,
          "cd-lineage": true,
          "cd-day0": true,
          "cd-maintain": true,
          "cd-final": true,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": true,
          "submitted": true
        },
        "failed_gates": [],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 604800.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 92
      },
      "original_grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-challenge-v1",
        "scoring": "binary-challenge-v1",
        "success": true,
        "reward": 1,
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": true,
          "a-before": true,
          "a-remove": true,
          "a-add": true,
          "a-after": true,
          "a-return": true,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": true,
          "b-before": true,
          "b-remove": true,
          "b-add": true,
          "b-after": true,
          "b-return": true,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": true,
          "d-before": true,
          "d-remove": true,
          "d-add": true,
          "d-after": true,
          "d-return": true,
          "d-final": true,
          "e-schedule": true,
          "e-before": true,
          "e-remove": true,
          "e-add": true,
          "e-after": true,
          "e-return": true,
          "e-final": true,
          "f-schedule": true,
          "f-before": true,
          "f-remove": true,
          "f-add": true,
          "f-after": true,
          "f-return": true,
          "f-final": true,
          "g-schedule": true,
          "g-before": true,
          "g-remove": true,
          "g-add": true,
          "g-after": true,
          "g-return": true,
          "g-final": true,
          "b-rock": true,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": true,
          "cd-wash": true,
          "cd-release": true,
          "cd-incubate-first": true,
          "cd-review-first": true,
          "cd-incubate-second": true,
          "cd-review-second": true,
          "cd-intervention": true,
          "equipment-recovery": true,
          "cd-dislodge": true,
          "cd-collect": true,
          "cd-dilute": true,
          "cd-mix": true,
          "cd-distribute": true,
          "cd-motion": true,
          "cd-d-review": true,
          "cd-d-return": true,
          "cd-lineage": true,
          "cd-day0": true,
          "cd-maintain": true,
          "cd-final": true,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": true,
          "submitted": true
        },
        "failed_gates": [],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 604800.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 92
      },
      "grading_revision": "zero-noop-v1",
      "grader_sha256": "67893bf51fc12e627fde0a30a3d807dcc9bd3ae4b3a1fc7af19f93ea8bb35cdd",
      "execution_note": null,
      "source_commit": "d1a9f49e0f35",
      "edition": "Challenge v1 \u00b7 technique instructions supplied",
      "runtime": "91e73641e256c604590d696c4010469d2030ccb106760a81484e244f99dd1a34",
      "sha256": "0f88fc7019f02499e14aec32c0370c0ee6576a79bd8fc72dd59178e41259f96d",
      "source": "jobs/challenge-results/jobs/ipsc-challenge-astra-max-20261112T051220Z/challenge-01__RHZVmSK/artifacts/attempt.json",
      "exact_replay": true,
      "regraded": true,
      "rules": {
        "a-schedule": {
          "id": "a-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "Feed on days 0, 2, 4, and 6. The entire workflow, including imaging, review and incubator return, must fit within 09:00\u201317:00 on each day.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "a-before": {
          "id": "a-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "a-remove": {
          "id": "a-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "a-add": {
          "id": "a-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "a-after": {
          "id": "a-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "a-return": {
          "id": "a-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "a-final": {
          "id": "a-final",
          "title": "A \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned A feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "b-rock": {
          "id": "b-rock",
          "title": "B ROCK removal window",
          "rule": "Complete removal 22\u201326 hours after the observed recovery timestamp."
        },
        "b-schedule": {
          "id": "b-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "After the recovery feed, feed on days 2, 4, and 6, with the entire workflow within 09:00\u201317:00. The first feed uses the ROCK-removal exception in step 01.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "b-before": {
          "id": "b-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "b-remove": {
          "id": "b-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "b-add": {
          "id": "b-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "b-after": {
          "id": "b-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "b-return": {
          "id": "b-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "b-final": {
          "id": "b-final",
          "title": "B \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned B feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-eligible": {
          "id": "cd-eligible",
          "title": "Check C before passaging",
          "rule": "Obtain a pre-passage image and scientist assessment. Confluence of 70\u2013100% is acceptable, including both endpoints.",
          "fail": "Confluence is below 70% or eligibility evidence is missing. There is no block at 100%."
        },
        "cd-coating": {
          "id": "cd-coating",
          "title": "Empty all six coated D wells",
          "rule": "Remove all coating liquid from every destination well before source treatment.",
          "fail": "Any coating liquid remains in any of the six wells."
        },
        "cd-wash": {
          "id": "cd-wash",
          "title": "Remove medium, wash, and remove PBS",
          "rule": "Remove all spent medium from C. Wash with 1\u20134 mL PBS inclusive, then remove all wash liquid without a deliberate pause.",
          "fail": "Spent medium or PBS remains at its removal checkpoint, wash volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, or a deliberate hold interrupts washing/removal."
        },
        "cd-release": {
          "id": "cd-release",
          "title": "Add and fully remove ReLeSR",
          "rule": "Add 800\u20131,200 \u00b5L ReLeSR inclusive, then remove all of it. No thin film or fixed residual remains.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside the range or any ReLeSR liquid remains after removal."
        },
        "cd-incubate-first": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-first",
          "title": "Incubate for 2\u20134 minutes",
          "rule": "Place C in the incubator for 120\u2013240 seconds inclusive after ReLeSR removal.",
          "fail": "Initial incubation is missing, shorter than 120 seconds, or longer than 240 seconds."
        },
        "cd-review-first": {
          "id": "cd-review-first",
          "title": "Image and receive the first negative review",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-incubate-second": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-second",
          "title": "Return C for a second incubation",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-review-second": {
          "id": "cd-review-second",
          "title": "Image again and obtain approval",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-dislodge": {
          "id": "cd-dislodge",
          "title": "Dispense directly onto cells at faster speed",
          "rule": "After approval, add 1\u20134 mL medium inclusive directly onto C\u2019s cells and explicitly acknowledge faster pipette speed to the simulator. This replaces tapping and is the exception to wall dispensing.",
          "fail": "Volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, dispense is not directed onto cells, or the faster-speed acknowledgment is missing."
        },
        "cd-collect": {
          "id": "cd-collect",
          "title": "Choose P1000 wide-bore and collect",
          "rule": "Explicitly select and use the P1000 wide-bore variant to transfer the suspension into a separate collection tube, using capacity-respecting draws.",
          "fail": "Collection uses standard/non-wide-bore tips or omits the required model selection."
        },
        "cd-dilute": {
          "id": "cd-dilute",
          "title": "Calculate dilution to exactly 12 mL",
          "rule": "Choose added medium as 12 mL minus the actual collected suspension volume. The tube must contain exactly 12 mL after dilution. The dilution addition has no 1\u20134 mL restriction.",
          "fail": "The model does not choose the dilution or the resulting tube volume is not 12 mL."
        },
        "cd-mix": {
          "id": "cd-mix",
          "title": "Mix after dilution with wide-bore",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, complete 1\u20135 up-and-down cycles inclusive after dilution and before distribution.",
          "fail": "Mixing is absent, exceeds five cycles, uses non-wide-bore, or occurs only before dilution."
        },
        "cd-distribute": {
          "id": "cd-distribute",
          "title": "Give each D well one-sixth",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, transfer one-sixth of the tube\u2019s starting, post-dilution volume into each of D\u2019s six wells: 2 mL each from 12 mL. Do not recalculate from the shrinking remainder.",
          "fail": "Any well receives a different share, a well is omitted, or distribution uses non-wide-bore."
        },
        "cd-motion": {
          "id": "cd-motion",
          "title": "Close D and distribute cells within wells",
          "rule": "Close D\u2019s lid and perform the simulated side-to-side and front-to-back plate-motion step before incubation.",
          "fail": "The required plate motion is skipped."
        },
        "cd-d-review": {
          "id": "cd-d-review",
          "title": "Image and review D",
          "rule": "Complete microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review after plate motion and before incubator placement. This review always passes.",
          "fail": "Acquisition or completed review is missing or incubation occurs first."
        },
        "cd-d-return": {
          "id": "cd-d-return",
          "title": "Put D in the incubator within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "From the final dispense into D\u2019s last well to incubator entry, allow at most 600 seconds, including plate motion, imaging and review.",
          "fail": "More than 600 seconds elapse or required intervening steps are bypassed."
        },
        "cd-lineage": {
          "id": "cd-lineage",
          "title": "Register D and dispose of C",
          "rule": "Register D as C\u2019s daughter with passage number increased by one (5 \u2192 6 here). Dispose of emptied C and preserve its lineage record.",
          "fail": "C is not disposed, or D\u2019s parentage/passage number is missing or incorrect."
        },
        "cd-day0": {
          "id": "cd-day0",
          "title": "Complete passage on day 0",
          "rule": "Complete C\u2192D passage, D registration and C disposal by day 0 24:00 (57600 seconds after the 08:00 epoch).",
          "fail": "Passage, registration or C disposal remains incomplete after day 0."
        },
        "cd-maintain": {
          "id": "cd-maintain",
          "title": "Maintain D every 48 hours, \u00b12 hours",
          "rule": "First feed is due 48 hours after initial incubator entry, with a 46\u201350-hour window. Repeat every 48 hours on the anchored schedule. The entire feeding workflow must fit within each \u00b12-hour window. Use A\u2019s pre/post imaging and review, full removal with tilt/no scraping, 2\u20134 mL wall addition per well, and 600-second return limit.",
          "fail": "Any subsequent feeding rule or the full-workflow timing window is missed."
        },
        "cd-final": {
          "id": "cd-final",
          "title": "Leave D ready",
          "rule": "At final submission, D is in its assigned incubator with its lid closed; source C is disposed.",
          "fail": "D is elsewhere, its lid is open, or C has not been disposed."
        },
        "d-schedule": {
          "id": "d-schedule",
          "title": "D feed schedule",
          "rule": "Complete each D feed within its assigned \u00b12-hour window."
        },
        "d-before": {
          "id": "d-before",
          "title": "D pre-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a fresh image for every D feed."
        },
        "d-remove": {
          "id": "d-remove",
          "title": "D complete removal",
          "rule": "Remove all old medium from every well with tilt, no scraping and at most one bottom touch."
        },
        "d-add": {
          "id": "d-add",
          "title": "D fresh medium",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall into each emptied well."
        },
        "d-after": {
          "id": "d-after",
          "title": "D post-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a new image after each D feed."
        },
        "d-return": {
          "id": "d-return",
          "title": "D incubator return",
          "rule": "Return within 600 seconds of the final dispense."
        },
        "d-final": {
          "id": "d-final",
          "title": "D \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned D feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "final-jobs": {
          "id": "final-jobs",
          "title": "Finish the workflow and complete all jobs",
          "rule": "Submit at day seven after running the workflow; all initiated jobs must be done, with no unfinished feed or wash sequence."
        },
        "final-robot": {
          "id": "final-robot",
          "title": "Finish pipetting and release the robot",
          "rule": "After executing pipetting and submitting at day seven, leave no held plate or attached tip."
        },
        "material-accounting": {
          "id": "material-accounting",
          "title": "Execute and conserve material",
          "rule": "After actual liquid transfers and day-seven submission, preserve material conservation and leave no cell clumps in waste."
        },
        "no-violation": {
          "id": "no-violation",
          "title": "Complete execution without violations",
          "rule": "Execute liquid handling and submit at day seven without terminal protocol violations or truncation."
        },
        "submitted": {
          "id": "submitted",
          "title": "Final submission",
          "rule": "Submit finish at exactly 604800 seconds."
        },
        "e-schedule": {
          "id": "e-schedule",
          "title": "E \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-before": {
          "id": "e-before",
          "title": "E \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-remove": {
          "id": "e-remove",
          "title": "E \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-add": {
          "id": "e-add",
          "title": "E \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-after": {
          "id": "e-after",
          "title": "E \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-return": {
          "id": "e-return",
          "title": "E \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-final": {
          "id": "e-final",
          "title": "E \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned E feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "f-schedule": {
          "id": "f-schedule",
          "title": "F \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-before": {
          "id": "f-before",
          "title": "F \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-remove": {
          "id": "f-remove",
          "title": "F \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-add": {
          "id": "f-add",
          "title": "F \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-after": {
          "id": "f-after",
          "title": "F \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-return": {
          "id": "f-return",
          "title": "F \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-final": {
          "id": "f-final",
          "title": "F \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned F feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "g-schedule": {
          "id": "g-schedule",
          "title": "G \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-before": {
          "id": "g-before",
          "title": "G \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-remove": {
          "id": "g-remove",
          "title": "G \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-add": {
          "id": "g-add",
          "title": "G \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-after": {
          "id": "g-after",
          "title": "G \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-return": {
          "id": "g-return",
          "title": "G \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-final": {
          "id": "g-final",
          "title": "G \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned G feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-intervention": {
          "id": "cd-intervention",
          "title": "Scientist intervention",
          "rule": "Complete scientist intervention when requested; do not invent an intervention on a branch that does not require it."
        },
        "equipment-recovery": {
          "id": "equipment-recovery",
          "title": "Recover failed acquisitions",
          "rule": "A failed acquisition must be followed by a successful image of the same plate and purpose without repeating material transfers."
        }
      },
      "journal_url": "data/gate-dashboard/journal-0f88fc7019f02499.json",
      "agent_trace_url": "data/gate-dashboard/agent-challenge-01__RHZVmSK.json",
      "agent_trace_summary": {
        "available": true,
        "turn_count": 18,
        "tool_call_count": 17,
        "tool_error_count": 0
      },
      "url": "data/gate-dashboard/challenge-01__RHZVmSK.json",
      "gate_results": {
        "a-schedule": true,
        "a-before": true,
        "a-remove": true,
        "a-add": true,
        "a-after": true,
        "a-return": true,
        "a-final": true,
        "b-schedule": true,
        "b-before": true,
        "b-remove": true,
        "b-add": true,
        "b-after": true,
        "b-return": true,
        "b-final": true,
        "d-schedule": true,
        "d-before": true,
        "d-remove": true,
        "d-add": true,
        "d-after": true,
        "d-return": true,
        "d-final": true,
        "e-schedule": true,
        "e-before": true,
        "e-remove": true,
        "e-add": true,
        "e-after": true,
        "e-return": true,
        "e-final": true,
        "f-schedule": true,
        "f-before": true,
        "f-remove": true,
        "f-add": true,
        "f-after": true,
        "f-return": true,
        "f-final": true,
        "g-schedule": true,
        "g-before": true,
        "g-remove": true,
        "g-add": true,
        "g-after": true,
        "g-return": true,
        "g-final": true,
        "b-rock": true,
        "cd-eligible": true,
        "cd-coating": true,
        "cd-wash": true,
        "cd-release": true,
        "cd-incubate-first": true,
        "cd-review-first": true,
        "cd-incubate-second": true,
        "cd-review-second": true,
        "cd-intervention": true,
        "equipment-recovery": true,
        "cd-dislodge": true,
        "cd-collect": true,
        "cd-dilute": true,
        "cd-mix": true,
        "cd-distribute": true,
        "cd-motion": true,
        "cd-d-review": true,
        "cd-d-return": true,
        "cd-lineage": true,
        "cd-day0": true,
        "cd-maintain": true,
        "cd-final": true,
        "final-jobs": true,
        "final-robot": true,
        "material-accounting": true,
        "no-violation": true,
        "submitted": true
      },
      "gate_status": {
        "a-schedule": "completed",
        "a-before": "completed",
        "a-remove": "completed",
        "a-add": "completed",
        "a-after": "completed",
        "a-return": "completed",
        "a-final": "completed",
        "b-schedule": "completed",
        "b-before": "completed",
        "b-remove": "completed",
        "b-add": "completed",
        "b-after": "completed",
        "b-return": "completed",
        "b-final": "completed",
        "d-schedule": "completed",
        "d-before": "completed",
        "d-remove": "completed",
        "d-add": "completed",
        "d-after": "completed",
        "d-return": "completed",
        "d-final": "completed",
        "e-schedule": "completed",
        "e-before": "completed",
        "e-remove": "completed",
        "e-add": "completed",
        "e-after": "completed",
        "e-return": "completed",
        "e-final": "completed",
        "f-schedule": "completed",
        "f-before": "completed",
        "f-remove": "completed",
        "f-add": "completed",
        "f-after": "completed",
        "f-return": "completed",
        "f-final": "completed",
        "g-schedule": "completed",
        "g-before": "completed",
        "g-remove": "completed",
        "g-add": "completed",
        "g-after": "completed",
        "g-return": "completed",
        "g-final": "completed",
        "b-rock": "completed",
        "cd-eligible": "completed",
        "cd-coating": "completed",
        "cd-wash": "completed",
        "cd-release": "completed",
        "cd-incubate-first": "completed",
        "cd-review-first": "completed",
        "cd-incubate-second": "not_required",
        "cd-review-second": "not_required",
        "cd-intervention": "not_required",
        "equipment-recovery": "completed",
        "cd-dislodge": "completed",
        "cd-collect": "completed",
        "cd-dilute": "completed",
        "cd-mix": "completed",
        "cd-distribute": "completed",
        "cd-motion": "completed",
        "cd-d-review": "completed",
        "cd-d-return": "completed",
        "cd-lineage": "completed",
        "cd-day0": "completed",
        "cd-maintain": "completed",
        "cd-final": "completed",
        "final-jobs": "completed",
        "final-robot": "completed",
        "material-accounting": "completed",
        "no-violation": "completed",
        "submitted": "completed"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "challenge-02__5e9Yasr",
      "label": "Astra Max \u00b7 Challenge v1 \u00b7 technique instructions supplied \u00b7 run 2",
      "role": "solver",
      "grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-challenge-v1",
        "scoring": "binary-challenge-decoupled-v1",
        "success": true,
        "reward": 1,
        "violations": [],
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": true,
          "a-before": true,
          "a-remove": true,
          "a-add": true,
          "a-after": true,
          "a-return": true,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": true,
          "b-before": true,
          "b-remove": true,
          "b-add": true,
          "b-after": true,
          "b-return": true,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": true,
          "d-before": true,
          "d-remove": true,
          "d-add": true,
          "d-after": true,
          "d-return": true,
          "d-final": true,
          "e-schedule": true,
          "e-before": true,
          "e-remove": true,
          "e-add": true,
          "e-after": true,
          "e-return": true,
          "e-final": true,
          "f-schedule": true,
          "f-before": true,
          "f-remove": true,
          "f-add": true,
          "f-after": true,
          "f-return": true,
          "f-final": true,
          "g-schedule": true,
          "g-before": true,
          "g-remove": true,
          "g-add": true,
          "g-after": true,
          "g-return": true,
          "g-final": true,
          "b-rock": true,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": true,
          "cd-wash": true,
          "cd-release": true,
          "cd-incubate-first": true,
          "cd-review-first": true,
          "cd-incubate-second": true,
          "cd-review-second": true,
          "cd-intervention": true,
          "equipment-recovery": true,
          "cd-dislodge": true,
          "cd-collect": true,
          "cd-dilute": true,
          "cd-mix": true,
          "cd-distribute": true,
          "cd-motion": true,
          "cd-d-review": true,
          "cd-d-return": true,
          "cd-lineage": true,
          "cd-day0": true,
          "cd-maintain": true,
          "cd-final": true,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": true,
          "submitted": true
        },
        "failed_gates": [],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 604800.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 97
      },
      "original_grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-challenge-v1",
        "scoring": "binary-challenge-v1",
        "success": true,
        "reward": 1,
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": true,
          "a-before": true,
          "a-remove": true,
          "a-add": true,
          "a-after": true,
          "a-return": true,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": true,
          "b-before": true,
          "b-remove": true,
          "b-add": true,
          "b-after": true,
          "b-return": true,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": true,
          "d-before": true,
          "d-remove": true,
          "d-add": true,
          "d-after": true,
          "d-return": true,
          "d-final": true,
          "e-schedule": true,
          "e-before": true,
          "e-remove": true,
          "e-add": true,
          "e-after": true,
          "e-return": true,
          "e-final": true,
          "f-schedule": true,
          "f-before": true,
          "f-remove": true,
          "f-add": true,
          "f-after": true,
          "f-return": true,
          "f-final": true,
          "g-schedule": true,
          "g-before": true,
          "g-remove": true,
          "g-add": true,
          "g-after": true,
          "g-return": true,
          "g-final": true,
          "b-rock": true,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": true,
          "cd-wash": true,
          "cd-release": true,
          "cd-incubate-first": true,
          "cd-review-first": true,
          "cd-incubate-second": true,
          "cd-review-second": true,
          "cd-intervention": true,
          "equipment-recovery": true,
          "cd-dislodge": true,
          "cd-collect": true,
          "cd-dilute": true,
          "cd-mix": true,
          "cd-distribute": true,
          "cd-motion": true,
          "cd-d-review": true,
          "cd-d-return": true,
          "cd-lineage": true,
          "cd-day0": true,
          "cd-maintain": true,
          "cd-final": true,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": true,
          "submitted": true
        },
        "failed_gates": [],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 604800.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 97
      },
      "grading_revision": "zero-noop-v1",
      "grader_sha256": "67893bf51fc12e627fde0a30a3d807dcc9bd3ae4b3a1fc7af19f93ea8bb35cdd",
      "execution_note": null,
      "source_commit": "d1a9f49e0f35",
      "edition": "Challenge v1 \u00b7 technique instructions supplied",
      "runtime": "91e73641e256c604590d696c4010469d2030ccb106760a81484e244f99dd1a34",
      "sha256": "dafc55a69175186b58cde3a4c4e417dbe43dee44211287aa1ff268cc6fe35275",
      "source": "jobs/challenge-results/jobs/ipsc-challenge-astra-max-20261112T051220Z/challenge-02__5e9Yasr/artifacts/attempt.json",
      "exact_replay": true,
      "regraded": true,
      "rules": {
        "a-schedule": {
          "id": "a-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "Feed on days 0, 2, 4, and 6. The entire workflow, including imaging, review and incubator return, must fit within 09:00\u201317:00 on each day.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "a-before": {
          "id": "a-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "a-remove": {
          "id": "a-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "a-add": {
          "id": "a-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "a-after": {
          "id": "a-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "a-return": {
          "id": "a-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "a-final": {
          "id": "a-final",
          "title": "A \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned A feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "b-rock": {
          "id": "b-rock",
          "title": "B ROCK removal window",
          "rule": "Complete removal 22\u201326 hours after the observed recovery timestamp."
        },
        "b-schedule": {
          "id": "b-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "After the recovery feed, feed on days 2, 4, and 6, with the entire workflow within 09:00\u201317:00. The first feed uses the ROCK-removal exception in step 01.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "b-before": {
          "id": "b-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "b-remove": {
          "id": "b-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "b-add": {
          "id": "b-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "b-after": {
          "id": "b-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "b-return": {
          "id": "b-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "b-final": {
          "id": "b-final",
          "title": "B \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned B feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-eligible": {
          "id": "cd-eligible",
          "title": "Check C before passaging",
          "rule": "Obtain a pre-passage image and scientist assessment. Confluence of 70\u2013100% is acceptable, including both endpoints.",
          "fail": "Confluence is below 70% or eligibility evidence is missing. There is no block at 100%."
        },
        "cd-coating": {
          "id": "cd-coating",
          "title": "Empty all six coated D wells",
          "rule": "Remove all coating liquid from every destination well before source treatment.",
          "fail": "Any coating liquid remains in any of the six wells."
        },
        "cd-wash": {
          "id": "cd-wash",
          "title": "Remove medium, wash, and remove PBS",
          "rule": "Remove all spent medium from C. Wash with 1\u20134 mL PBS inclusive, then remove all wash liquid without a deliberate pause.",
          "fail": "Spent medium or PBS remains at its removal checkpoint, wash volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, or a deliberate hold interrupts washing/removal."
        },
        "cd-release": {
          "id": "cd-release",
          "title": "Add and fully remove ReLeSR",
          "rule": "Add 800\u20131,200 \u00b5L ReLeSR inclusive, then remove all of it. No thin film or fixed residual remains.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside the range or any ReLeSR liquid remains after removal."
        },
        "cd-incubate-first": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-first",
          "title": "Incubate for 2\u20134 minutes",
          "rule": "Place C in the incubator for 120\u2013240 seconds inclusive after ReLeSR removal.",
          "fail": "Initial incubation is missing, shorter than 120 seconds, or longer than 240 seconds."
        },
        "cd-review-first": {
          "id": "cd-review-first",
          "title": "Image and receive the first negative review",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-incubate-second": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-second",
          "title": "Return C for a second incubation",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-review-second": {
          "id": "cd-review-second",
          "title": "Image again and obtain approval",
          "rule": "Follow the observed review decision. First approval permits continuation; extend requires repeat incubation and review; intervention requires completed consultation. Unused branches are not required."
        },
        "cd-dislodge": {
          "id": "cd-dislodge",
          "title": "Dispense directly onto cells at faster speed",
          "rule": "After approval, add 1\u20134 mL medium inclusive directly onto C\u2019s cells and explicitly acknowledge faster pipette speed to the simulator. This replaces tapping and is the exception to wall dispensing.",
          "fail": "Volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, dispense is not directed onto cells, or the faster-speed acknowledgment is missing."
        },
        "cd-collect": {
          "id": "cd-collect",
          "title": "Choose P1000 wide-bore and collect",
          "rule": "Explicitly select and use the P1000 wide-bore variant to transfer the suspension into a separate collection tube, using capacity-respecting draws.",
          "fail": "Collection uses standard/non-wide-bore tips or omits the required model selection."
        },
        "cd-dilute": {
          "id": "cd-dilute",
          "title": "Calculate dilution to exactly 12 mL",
          "rule": "Choose added medium as 12 mL minus the actual collected suspension volume. The tube must contain exactly 12 mL after dilution. The dilution addition has no 1\u20134 mL restriction.",
          "fail": "The model does not choose the dilution or the resulting tube volume is not 12 mL."
        },
        "cd-mix": {
          "id": "cd-mix",
          "title": "Mix after dilution with wide-bore",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, complete 1\u20135 up-and-down cycles inclusive after dilution and before distribution.",
          "fail": "Mixing is absent, exceeds five cycles, uses non-wide-bore, or occurs only before dilution."
        },
        "cd-distribute": {
          "id": "cd-distribute",
          "title": "Give each D well one-sixth",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, transfer one-sixth of the tube\u2019s starting, post-dilution volume into each of D\u2019s six wells: 2 mL each from 12 mL. Do not recalculate from the shrinking remainder.",
          "fail": "Any well receives a different share, a well is omitted, or distribution uses non-wide-bore."
        },
        "cd-motion": {
          "id": "cd-motion",
          "title": "Close D and distribute cells within wells",
          "rule": "Close D\u2019s lid and perform the simulated side-to-side and front-to-back plate-motion step before incubation.",
          "fail": "The required plate motion is skipped."
        },
        "cd-d-review": {
          "id": "cd-d-review",
          "title": "Image and review D",
          "rule": "Complete microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review after plate motion and before incubator placement. This review always passes.",
          "fail": "Acquisition or completed review is missing or incubation occurs first."
        },
        "cd-d-return": {
          "id": "cd-d-return",
          "title": "Put D in the incubator within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "From the final dispense into D\u2019s last well to incubator entry, allow at most 600 seconds, including plate motion, imaging and review.",
          "fail": "More than 600 seconds elapse or required intervening steps are bypassed."
        },
        "cd-lineage": {
          "id": "cd-lineage",
          "title": "Register D and dispose of C",
          "rule": "Register D as C\u2019s daughter with passage number increased by one (5 \u2192 6 here). Dispose of emptied C and preserve its lineage record.",
          "fail": "C is not disposed, or D\u2019s parentage/passage number is missing or incorrect."
        },
        "cd-day0": {
          "id": "cd-day0",
          "title": "Complete passage on day 0",
          "rule": "Complete C\u2192D passage, D registration and C disposal by day 0 24:00 (57600 seconds after the 08:00 epoch).",
          "fail": "Passage, registration or C disposal remains incomplete after day 0."
        },
        "cd-maintain": {
          "id": "cd-maintain",
          "title": "Maintain D every 48 hours, \u00b12 hours",
          "rule": "First feed is due 48 hours after initial incubator entry, with a 46\u201350-hour window. Repeat every 48 hours on the anchored schedule. The entire feeding workflow must fit within each \u00b12-hour window. Use A\u2019s pre/post imaging and review, full removal with tilt/no scraping, 2\u20134 mL wall addition per well, and 600-second return limit.",
          "fail": "Any subsequent feeding rule or the full-workflow timing window is missed."
        },
        "cd-final": {
          "id": "cd-final",
          "title": "Leave D ready",
          "rule": "At final submission, D is in its assigned incubator with its lid closed; source C is disposed.",
          "fail": "D is elsewhere, its lid is open, or C has not been disposed."
        },
        "d-schedule": {
          "id": "d-schedule",
          "title": "D feed schedule",
          "rule": "Complete each D feed within its assigned \u00b12-hour window."
        },
        "d-before": {
          "id": "d-before",
          "title": "D pre-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a fresh image for every D feed."
        },
        "d-remove": {
          "id": "d-remove",
          "title": "D complete removal",
          "rule": "Remove all old medium from every well with tilt, no scraping and at most one bottom touch."
        },
        "d-add": {
          "id": "d-add",
          "title": "D fresh medium",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall into each emptied well."
        },
        "d-after": {
          "id": "d-after",
          "title": "D post-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a new image after each D feed."
        },
        "d-return": {
          "id": "d-return",
          "title": "D incubator return",
          "rule": "Return within 600 seconds of the final dispense."
        },
        "d-final": {
          "id": "d-final",
          "title": "D \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned D feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "final-jobs": {
          "id": "final-jobs",
          "title": "Finish the workflow and complete all jobs",
          "rule": "Submit at day seven after running the workflow; all initiated jobs must be done, with no unfinished feed or wash sequence."
        },
        "final-robot": {
          "id": "final-robot",
          "title": "Finish pipetting and release the robot",
          "rule": "After executing pipetting and submitting at day seven, leave no held plate or attached tip."
        },
        "material-accounting": {
          "id": "material-accounting",
          "title": "Execute and conserve material",
          "rule": "After actual liquid transfers and day-seven submission, preserve material conservation and leave no cell clumps in waste."
        },
        "no-violation": {
          "id": "no-violation",
          "title": "Complete execution without violations",
          "rule": "Execute liquid handling and submit at day seven without terminal protocol violations or truncation."
        },
        "submitted": {
          "id": "submitted",
          "title": "Final submission",
          "rule": "Submit finish at exactly 604800 seconds."
        },
        "e-schedule": {
          "id": "e-schedule",
          "title": "E \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-before": {
          "id": "e-before",
          "title": "E \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-remove": {
          "id": "e-remove",
          "title": "E \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-add": {
          "id": "e-add",
          "title": "E \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-after": {
          "id": "e-after",
          "title": "E \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-return": {
          "id": "e-return",
          "title": "E \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-final": {
          "id": "e-final",
          "title": "E \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned E feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "f-schedule": {
          "id": "f-schedule",
          "title": "F \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-before": {
          "id": "f-before",
          "title": "F \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-remove": {
          "id": "f-remove",
          "title": "F \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-add": {
          "id": "f-add",
          "title": "F \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-after": {
          "id": "f-after",
          "title": "F \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-return": {
          "id": "f-return",
          "title": "F \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-final": {
          "id": "f-final",
          "title": "F \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned F feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "g-schedule": {
          "id": "g-schedule",
          "title": "G \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-before": {
          "id": "g-before",
          "title": "G \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-remove": {
          "id": "g-remove",
          "title": "G \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-add": {
          "id": "g-add",
          "title": "G \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-after": {
          "id": "g-after",
          "title": "G \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-return": {
          "id": "g-return",
          "title": "G \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-final": {
          "id": "g-final",
          "title": "G \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned G feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-intervention": {
          "id": "cd-intervention",
          "title": "Scientist intervention",
          "rule": "Complete scientist intervention when requested; do not invent an intervention on a branch that does not require it."
        },
        "equipment-recovery": {
          "id": "equipment-recovery",
          "title": "Recover failed acquisitions",
          "rule": "A failed acquisition must be followed by a successful image of the same plate and purpose without repeating material transfers."
        }
      },
      "journal_url": "data/gate-dashboard/journal-dafc55a69175186b.json",
      "agent_trace_url": "data/gate-dashboard/agent-challenge-02__5e9Yasr.json",
      "agent_trace_summary": {
        "available": true,
        "turn_count": 20,
        "tool_call_count": 19,
        "tool_error_count": 0
      },
      "url": "data/gate-dashboard/challenge-02__5e9Yasr.json",
      "gate_results": {
        "a-schedule": true,
        "a-before": true,
        "a-remove": true,
        "a-add": true,
        "a-after": true,
        "a-return": true,
        "a-final": true,
        "b-schedule": true,
        "b-before": true,
        "b-remove": true,
        "b-add": true,
        "b-after": true,
        "b-return": true,
        "b-final": true,
        "d-schedule": true,
        "d-before": true,
        "d-remove": true,
        "d-add": true,
        "d-after": true,
        "d-return": true,
        "d-final": true,
        "e-schedule": true,
        "e-before": true,
        "e-remove": true,
        "e-add": true,
        "e-after": true,
        "e-return": true,
        "e-final": true,
        "f-schedule": true,
        "f-before": true,
        "f-remove": true,
        "f-add": true,
        "f-after": true,
        "f-return": true,
        "f-final": true,
        "g-schedule": true,
        "g-before": true,
        "g-remove": true,
        "g-add": true,
        "g-after": true,
        "g-return": true,
        "g-final": true,
        "b-rock": true,
        "cd-eligible": true,
        "cd-coating": true,
        "cd-wash": true,
        "cd-release": true,
        "cd-incubate-first": true,
        "cd-review-first": true,
        "cd-incubate-second": true,
        "cd-review-second": true,
        "cd-intervention": true,
        "equipment-recovery": true,
        "cd-dislodge": true,
        "cd-collect": true,
        "cd-dilute": true,
        "cd-mix": true,
        "cd-distribute": true,
        "cd-motion": true,
        "cd-d-review": true,
        "cd-d-return": true,
        "cd-lineage": true,
        "cd-day0": true,
        "cd-maintain": true,
        "cd-final": true,
        "final-jobs": true,
        "final-robot": true,
        "material-accounting": true,
        "no-violation": true,
        "submitted": true
      },
      "gate_status": {
        "a-schedule": "completed",
        "a-before": "completed",
        "a-remove": "completed",
        "a-add": "completed",
        "a-after": "completed",
        "a-return": "completed",
        "a-final": "completed",
        "b-schedule": "completed",
        "b-before": "completed",
        "b-remove": "completed",
        "b-add": "completed",
        "b-after": "completed",
        "b-return": "completed",
        "b-final": "completed",
        "d-schedule": "completed",
        "d-before": "completed",
        "d-remove": "completed",
        "d-add": "completed",
        "d-after": "completed",
        "d-return": "completed",
        "d-final": "completed",
        "e-schedule": "completed",
        "e-before": "completed",
        "e-remove": "completed",
        "e-add": "completed",
        "e-after": "completed",
        "e-return": "completed",
        "e-final": "completed",
        "f-schedule": "completed",
        "f-before": "completed",
        "f-remove": "completed",
        "f-add": "completed",
        "f-after": "completed",
        "f-return": "completed",
        "f-final": "completed",
        "g-schedule": "completed",
        "g-before": "completed",
        "g-remove": "completed",
        "g-add": "completed",
        "g-after": "completed",
        "g-return": "completed",
        "g-final": "completed",
        "b-rock": "completed",
        "cd-eligible": "completed",
        "cd-coating": "completed",
        "cd-wash": "completed",
        "cd-release": "completed",
        "cd-incubate-first": "completed",
        "cd-review-first": "completed",
        "cd-incubate-second": "not_required",
        "cd-review-second": "not_required",
        "cd-intervention": "completed",
        "equipment-recovery": "completed",
        "cd-dislodge": "completed",
        "cd-collect": "completed",
        "cd-dilute": "completed",
        "cd-mix": "completed",
        "cd-distribute": "completed",
        "cd-motion": "completed",
        "cd-d-review": "completed",
        "cd-d-return": "completed",
        "cd-lineage": "completed",
        "cd-day0": "completed",
        "cd-maintain": "completed",
        "cd-final": "completed",
        "final-jobs": "completed",
        "final-robot": "completed",
        "material-accounting": "completed",
        "no-violation": "completed",
        "submitted": "completed"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "trillo-ipsc-maintenance__5yM2ZXk",
      "label": "Astra Max \u00b7 attempt 1",
      "role": "solver",
      "grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-reviewed-v2",
        "scoring": "binary-reviewed-v2",
        "success": true,
        "reward": 1,
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": true,
          "a-before": true,
          "a-remove": true,
          "a-add": true,
          "a-after": true,
          "a-return": true,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": true,
          "b-before": true,
          "b-remove": true,
          "b-add": true,
          "b-after": true,
          "b-return": true,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": true,
          "d-before": true,
          "d-remove": true,
          "d-add": true,
          "d-after": true,
          "d-return": true,
          "d-final": true,
          "b-rock": true,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": true,
          "cd-wash": true,
          "cd-release": true,
          "cd-incubate-first": true,
          "cd-review-first": true,
          "cd-incubate-second": true,
          "cd-review-second": true,
          "cd-dislodge": true,
          "cd-collect": true,
          "cd-dilute": true,
          "cd-mix": true,
          "cd-distribute": true,
          "cd-motion": true,
          "cd-d-review": true,
          "cd-d-return": true,
          "cd-lineage": true,
          "cd-day0": true,
          "cd-maintain": true,
          "cd-final": true,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": true,
          "submitted": true
        },
        "failed_gates": [],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 604800.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 44
      },
      "original_grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-reviewed-v2",
        "scoring": "binary-reviewed-v2",
        "success": true,
        "reward": 1,
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": true,
          "a-before": true,
          "a-remove": true,
          "a-add": true,
          "a-after": true,
          "a-return": true,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": true,
          "b-before": true,
          "b-remove": true,
          "b-add": true,
          "b-after": true,
          "b-return": true,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": true,
          "d-before": true,
          "d-remove": true,
          "d-add": true,
          "d-after": true,
          "d-return": true,
          "d-final": true,
          "b-rock": true,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": true,
          "cd-wash": true,
          "cd-release": true,
          "cd-incubate-first": true,
          "cd-review-first": true,
          "cd-incubate-second": true,
          "cd-review-second": true,
          "cd-dislodge": true,
          "cd-collect": true,
          "cd-dilute": true,
          "cd-mix": true,
          "cd-distribute": true,
          "cd-motion": true,
          "cd-d-review": true,
          "cd-d-return": true,
          "cd-lineage": true,
          "cd-day0": true,
          "cd-maintain": true,
          "cd-final": true,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": true,
          "submitted": true
        },
        "failed_gates": [],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 604800.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 44
      },
      "grading_revision": "zero-noop-v1",
      "grader_sha256": "01457fa8f4015c8263a0f1df0db7830ee76ce23c78a2806b8b98d8181807a767",
      "execution_note": null,
      "source_commit": "c9e6facd1e8c",
      "edition": "Baseline \u00b7 original instructions",
      "runtime": "8527cf0e77eae513b236f5df47f8fca9a810b3966019c7fcb7a6b707f0b412ed",
      "sha256": "83821e9aa5d7371b49f2df946e52021b99161fac792f84bcb9c512a0416592fe",
      "source": "jobs/astra-current/jobs/ipsc-reviewed-astra-max-20261112T014349Z/trillo-ipsc-maintenance__5yM2ZXk/artifacts/attempt.json",
      "exact_replay": true,
      "regraded": true,
      "rules": {
        "a-schedule": {
          "id": "a-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "Feed on days 0, 2, 4, and 6. The entire workflow, including imaging, review and incubator return, must fit within 09:00\u201317:00 on each day.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "a-before": {
          "id": "a-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "a-remove": {
          "id": "a-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "a-add": {
          "id": "a-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "a-after": {
          "id": "a-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "a-return": {
          "id": "a-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "a-final": {
          "id": "a-final",
          "title": "A \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned A feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "b-rock": {
          "id": "b-rock",
          "title": "Remove recovery medium at 24 \u00b12 hours",
          "rule": "B starts already thawed and plated in ROCK-containing medium. Remove that medium 22\u201326 hours after recovery, inclusive. With recovery at previous-day 19:00, removal is due on day 0 at 17:00\u201321:00. This window applies to removal, not the full imaging/review/return workflow.",
          "fail": "ROCK-containing medium is removed before 22 hours or after 26 hours, or any remains."
        },
        "b-schedule": {
          "id": "b-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "After the recovery feed, feed on days 2, 4, and 6, with the entire workflow within 09:00\u201317:00. The first feed uses the ROCK-removal exception in step 01.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "b-before": {
          "id": "b-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "b-remove": {
          "id": "b-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "b-add": {
          "id": "b-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "b-after": {
          "id": "b-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "b-return": {
          "id": "b-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "b-final": {
          "id": "b-final",
          "title": "B \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned B feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-eligible": {
          "id": "cd-eligible",
          "title": "Check C before passaging",
          "rule": "Obtain a pre-passage image and scientist assessment. Confluence of 70\u2013100% is acceptable, including both endpoints.",
          "fail": "Confluence is below 70% or eligibility evidence is missing. There is no block at 100%."
        },
        "cd-coating": {
          "id": "cd-coating",
          "title": "Empty all six coated D wells",
          "rule": "Remove all coating liquid from every destination well before source treatment.",
          "fail": "Any coating liquid remains in any of the six wells."
        },
        "cd-wash": {
          "id": "cd-wash",
          "title": "Remove medium, wash, and remove PBS",
          "rule": "Remove all spent medium from C. Wash with 1\u20134 mL PBS inclusive, then remove all wash liquid without a deliberate pause.",
          "fail": "Spent medium or PBS remains at its removal checkpoint, wash volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, or a deliberate hold interrupts washing/removal."
        },
        "cd-release": {
          "id": "cd-release",
          "title": "Add and fully remove ReLeSR",
          "rule": "Add 800\u20131,200 \u00b5L ReLeSR inclusive, then remove all of it. No thin film or fixed residual remains.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside the range or any ReLeSR liquid remains after removal."
        },
        "cd-incubate-first": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-first",
          "title": "Incubate for 2\u20134 minutes",
          "rule": "Place C in the incubator for 120\u2013240 seconds inclusive after ReLeSR removal.",
          "fail": "Initial incubation is missing, shorter than 120 seconds, or longer than 240 seconds."
        },
        "cd-review-first": {
          "id": "cd-review-first",
          "title": "Image and receive the first negative review",
          "rule": "Complete a new microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review. The first review deliberately fails and requires reincubation.",
          "fail": "Imaging/review is skipped or the model proceeds to collection despite the negative result."
        },
        "cd-incubate-second": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-second",
          "title": "Return C for a second incubation",
          "rule": "Return the plate to the incubator and execute a second incubation of at most 240 seconds. There is no lower-duration gate. These are separate limits, not a four-minute total cap.",
          "fail": "The model skips incubator return or the incubation step, or the second incubation exceeds 240 seconds."
        },
        "cd-review-second": {
          "id": "cd-review-second",
          "title": "Image again and obtain approval",
          "rule": "After reincubation, complete another microscope acquisition and scientist review. This second review always passes.",
          "fail": "The model proceeds before the second acquisition and review finish."
        },
        "cd-dislodge": {
          "id": "cd-dislodge",
          "title": "Dispense directly onto cells at faster speed",
          "rule": "After approval, add 1\u20134 mL medium inclusive directly onto C\u2019s cells and explicitly acknowledge faster pipette speed to the simulator. This replaces tapping and is the exception to wall dispensing.",
          "fail": "Volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, dispense is not directed onto cells, or the faster-speed acknowledgment is missing."
        },
        "cd-collect": {
          "id": "cd-collect",
          "title": "Choose P1000 wide-bore and collect",
          "rule": "Explicitly select and use the P1000 wide-bore variant to transfer the suspension into a separate collection tube, using capacity-respecting draws.",
          "fail": "Collection uses standard/non-wide-bore tips or omits the required model selection."
        },
        "cd-dilute": {
          "id": "cd-dilute",
          "title": "Calculate dilution to exactly 12 mL",
          "rule": "Choose added medium as 12 mL minus the actual collected suspension volume. The tube must contain exactly 12 mL after dilution. The dilution addition has no 1\u20134 mL restriction.",
          "fail": "The model does not choose the dilution or the resulting tube volume is not 12 mL."
        },
        "cd-mix": {
          "id": "cd-mix",
          "title": "Mix after dilution with wide-bore",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, complete 1\u20135 up-and-down cycles inclusive after dilution and before distribution.",
          "fail": "Mixing is absent, exceeds five cycles, uses non-wide-bore, or occurs only before dilution."
        },
        "cd-distribute": {
          "id": "cd-distribute",
          "title": "Give each D well one-sixth",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, transfer one-sixth of the tube\u2019s starting, post-dilution volume into each of D\u2019s six wells: 2 mL each from 12 mL. Do not recalculate from the shrinking remainder.",
          "fail": "Any well receives a different share, a well is omitted, or distribution uses non-wide-bore."
        },
        "cd-motion": {
          "id": "cd-motion",
          "title": "Close D and distribute cells within wells",
          "rule": "Close D\u2019s lid and perform the simulated side-to-side and front-to-back plate-motion step before incubation.",
          "fail": "The required plate motion is skipped."
        },
        "cd-d-review": {
          "id": "cd-d-review",
          "title": "Image and review D",
          "rule": "Complete microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review after plate motion and before incubator placement. This review always passes.",
          "fail": "Acquisition or completed review is missing or incubation occurs first."
        },
        "cd-d-return": {
          "id": "cd-d-return",
          "title": "Put D in the incubator within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "From the final dispense into D\u2019s last well to incubator entry, allow at most 600 seconds, including plate motion, imaging and review.",
          "fail": "More than 600 seconds elapse or required intervening steps are bypassed."
        },
        "cd-lineage": {
          "id": "cd-lineage",
          "title": "Register D and dispose of C",
          "rule": "Register D as C\u2019s daughter with passage number increased by one (5 \u2192 6 here). Dispose of emptied C and preserve its lineage record.",
          "fail": "C is not disposed, or D\u2019s parentage/passage number is missing or incorrect."
        },
        "cd-day0": {
          "id": "cd-day0",
          "title": "Complete passage on day 0",
          "rule": "Complete C\u2192D passage, D registration and C disposal by day 0 24:00 (57600 seconds after the 08:00 epoch).",
          "fail": "Passage, registration or C disposal remains incomplete after day 0."
        },
        "cd-maintain": {
          "id": "cd-maintain",
          "title": "Maintain D every 48 hours, \u00b12 hours",
          "rule": "First feed is due 48 hours after initial incubator entry, with a 46\u201350-hour window. Repeat every 48 hours on the anchored schedule. The entire feeding workflow must fit within each \u00b12-hour window. Use A\u2019s pre/post imaging and review, full removal with tilt/no scraping, 2\u20134 mL wall addition per well, and 600-second return limit.",
          "fail": "Any subsequent feeding rule or the full-workflow timing window is missed."
        },
        "cd-final": {
          "id": "cd-final",
          "title": "Leave D ready",
          "rule": "At final submission, D is in its assigned incubator with its lid closed; source C is disposed.",
          "fail": "D is elsewhere, its lid is open, or C has not been disposed."
        },
        "d-schedule": {
          "id": "d-schedule",
          "title": "D feed schedule",
          "rule": "Complete each D feed within its assigned \u00b12-hour window."
        },
        "d-before": {
          "id": "d-before",
          "title": "D pre-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a fresh image for every D feed."
        },
        "d-remove": {
          "id": "d-remove",
          "title": "D complete removal",
          "rule": "Remove all old medium from every well with tilt, no scraping and at most one bottom touch."
        },
        "d-add": {
          "id": "d-add",
          "title": "D fresh medium",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall into each emptied well."
        },
        "d-after": {
          "id": "d-after",
          "title": "D post-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a new image after each D feed."
        },
        "d-return": {
          "id": "d-return",
          "title": "D incubator return",
          "rule": "Return within 600 seconds of the final dispense."
        },
        "d-final": {
          "id": "d-final",
          "title": "D \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned D feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "final-jobs": {
          "id": "final-jobs",
          "title": "Finish the workflow and complete all jobs",
          "rule": "Submit at day seven after running the workflow; all initiated jobs must be done, with no unfinished feed or wash sequence."
        },
        "final-robot": {
          "id": "final-robot",
          "title": "Finish pipetting and release the robot",
          "rule": "After executing pipetting and submitting at day seven, leave no held plate or attached tip."
        },
        "material-accounting": {
          "id": "material-accounting",
          "title": "Execute and conserve material",
          "rule": "After actual liquid transfers and day-seven submission, preserve material conservation and leave no cell clumps in waste."
        },
        "no-violation": {
          "id": "no-violation",
          "title": "Complete execution without violations",
          "rule": "Execute liquid handling and submit at day seven without terminal protocol violations or truncation."
        },
        "submitted": {
          "id": "submitted",
          "title": "Final submission",
          "rule": "Submit finish at exactly 604800 seconds."
        },
        "e-schedule": {
          "id": "e-schedule",
          "title": "E \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-before": {
          "id": "e-before",
          "title": "E \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-remove": {
          "id": "e-remove",
          "title": "E \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-add": {
          "id": "e-add",
          "title": "E \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-after": {
          "id": "e-after",
          "title": "E \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-return": {
          "id": "e-return",
          "title": "E \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-final": {
          "id": "e-final",
          "title": "E \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned E feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "f-schedule": {
          "id": "f-schedule",
          "title": "F \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-before": {
          "id": "f-before",
          "title": "F \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-remove": {
          "id": "f-remove",
          "title": "F \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-add": {
          "id": "f-add",
          "title": "F \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-after": {
          "id": "f-after",
          "title": "F \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-return": {
          "id": "f-return",
          "title": "F \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-final": {
          "id": "f-final",
          "title": "F \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned F feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "g-schedule": {
          "id": "g-schedule",
          "title": "G \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-before": {
          "id": "g-before",
          "title": "G \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-remove": {
          "id": "g-remove",
          "title": "G \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-add": {
          "id": "g-add",
          "title": "G \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-after": {
          "id": "g-after",
          "title": "G \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-return": {
          "id": "g-return",
          "title": "G \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-final": {
          "id": "g-final",
          "title": "G \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned G feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-intervention": {
          "id": "cd-intervention",
          "title": "Scientist intervention",
          "rule": "Complete scientist intervention when requested; do not invent an intervention on a branch that does not require it."
        },
        "equipment-recovery": {
          "id": "equipment-recovery",
          "title": "Recover failed acquisitions",
          "rule": "A failed acquisition must be followed by a successful image of the same plate and purpose without repeating material transfers."
        }
      },
      "journal_url": "data/gate-dashboard/journal-83821e9aa5d7371b.json",
      "agent_trace_url": "data/gate-dashboard/agent-trillo-ipsc-maintenance__5yM2ZXk.json",
      "agent_trace_summary": {
        "available": true,
        "turn_count": 17,
        "tool_call_count": 16,
        "tool_error_count": 0
      },
      "url": "data/gate-dashboard/trillo-ipsc-maintenance__5yM2ZXk.json",
      "gate_results": {
        "a-schedule": true,
        "a-before": true,
        "a-remove": true,
        "a-add": true,
        "a-after": true,
        "a-return": true,
        "a-final": true,
        "b-schedule": true,
        "b-before": true,
        "b-remove": true,
        "b-add": true,
        "b-after": true,
        "b-return": true,
        "b-final": true,
        "d-schedule": true,
        "d-before": true,
        "d-remove": true,
        "d-add": true,
        "d-after": true,
        "d-return": true,
        "d-final": true,
        "b-rock": true,
        "cd-eligible": true,
        "cd-coating": true,
        "cd-wash": true,
        "cd-release": true,
        "cd-incubate-first": true,
        "cd-review-first": true,
        "cd-incubate-second": true,
        "cd-review-second": true,
        "cd-dislodge": true,
        "cd-collect": true,
        "cd-dilute": true,
        "cd-mix": true,
        "cd-distribute": true,
        "cd-motion": true,
        "cd-d-review": true,
        "cd-d-return": true,
        "cd-lineage": true,
        "cd-day0": true,
        "cd-maintain": true,
        "cd-final": true,
        "final-jobs": true,
        "final-robot": true,
        "material-accounting": true,
        "no-violation": true,
        "submitted": true
      },
      "gate_status": {
        "a-schedule": "completed",
        "a-before": "completed",
        "a-remove": "completed",
        "a-add": "completed",
        "a-after": "completed",
        "a-return": "completed",
        "a-final": "completed",
        "b-schedule": "completed",
        "b-before": "completed",
        "b-remove": "completed",
        "b-add": "completed",
        "b-after": "completed",
        "b-return": "completed",
        "b-final": "completed",
        "d-schedule": "completed",
        "d-before": "completed",
        "d-remove": "completed",
        "d-add": "completed",
        "d-after": "completed",
        "d-return": "completed",
        "d-final": "completed",
        "b-rock": "completed",
        "cd-eligible": "completed",
        "cd-coating": "completed",
        "cd-wash": "completed",
        "cd-release": "completed",
        "cd-incubate-first": "completed",
        "cd-review-first": "completed",
        "cd-incubate-second": "completed",
        "cd-review-second": "completed",
        "cd-dislodge": "completed",
        "cd-collect": "completed",
        "cd-dilute": "completed",
        "cd-mix": "completed",
        "cd-distribute": "completed",
        "cd-motion": "completed",
        "cd-d-review": "completed",
        "cd-d-return": "completed",
        "cd-lineage": "completed",
        "cd-day0": "completed",
        "cd-maintain": "completed",
        "cd-final": "completed",
        "final-jobs": "completed",
        "final-robot": "completed",
        "material-accounting": "completed",
        "no-violation": "completed",
        "submitted": "completed"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "trillo-ipsc-maintenance__nzAALY5",
      "label": "Astra Max \u00b7 attempt 2",
      "role": "solver",
      "grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-reviewed-v2",
        "scoring": "binary-reviewed-v2",
        "success": true,
        "reward": 1,
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": true,
          "a-before": true,
          "a-remove": true,
          "a-add": true,
          "a-after": true,
          "a-return": true,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": true,
          "b-before": true,
          "b-remove": true,
          "b-add": true,
          "b-after": true,
          "b-return": true,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": true,
          "d-before": true,
          "d-remove": true,
          "d-add": true,
          "d-after": true,
          "d-return": true,
          "d-final": true,
          "b-rock": true,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": true,
          "cd-wash": true,
          "cd-release": true,
          "cd-incubate-first": true,
          "cd-review-first": true,
          "cd-incubate-second": true,
          "cd-review-second": true,
          "cd-dislodge": true,
          "cd-collect": true,
          "cd-dilute": true,
          "cd-mix": true,
          "cd-distribute": true,
          "cd-motion": true,
          "cd-d-review": true,
          "cd-d-return": true,
          "cd-lineage": true,
          "cd-day0": true,
          "cd-maintain": true,
          "cd-final": true,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": true,
          "submitted": true
        },
        "failed_gates": [],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 604800.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 44
      },
      "original_grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-reviewed-v2",
        "scoring": "binary-reviewed-v2",
        "success": true,
        "reward": 1,
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": true,
          "a-before": true,
          "a-remove": true,
          "a-add": true,
          "a-after": true,
          "a-return": true,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": true,
          "b-before": true,
          "b-remove": true,
          "b-add": true,
          "b-after": true,
          "b-return": true,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": true,
          "d-before": true,
          "d-remove": true,
          "d-add": true,
          "d-after": true,
          "d-return": true,
          "d-final": true,
          "b-rock": true,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": true,
          "cd-wash": true,
          "cd-release": true,
          "cd-incubate-first": true,
          "cd-review-first": true,
          "cd-incubate-second": true,
          "cd-review-second": true,
          "cd-dislodge": true,
          "cd-collect": true,
          "cd-dilute": true,
          "cd-mix": true,
          "cd-distribute": true,
          "cd-motion": true,
          "cd-d-review": true,
          "cd-d-return": true,
          "cd-lineage": true,
          "cd-day0": true,
          "cd-maintain": true,
          "cd-final": true,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": true,
          "submitted": true
        },
        "failed_gates": [],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 604800.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 44
      },
      "grading_revision": "zero-noop-v1",
      "grader_sha256": "01457fa8f4015c8263a0f1df0db7830ee76ce23c78a2806b8b98d8181807a767",
      "execution_note": null,
      "source_commit": "c9e6facd1e8c",
      "edition": "Baseline \u00b7 original instructions",
      "runtime": "8527cf0e77eae513b236f5df47f8fca9a810b3966019c7fcb7a6b707f0b412ed",
      "sha256": "6aed5327ce592c90c55df4c9467e449d9eb0344a62a052895e6e00ab819263c6",
      "source": "jobs/astra-current/jobs/ipsc-reviewed-astra-max-20261112T014349Z/trillo-ipsc-maintenance__nzAALY5/artifacts/attempt.json",
      "exact_replay": true,
      "regraded": true,
      "rules": {
        "a-schedule": {
          "id": "a-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "Feed on days 0, 2, 4, and 6. The entire workflow, including imaging, review and incubator return, must fit within 09:00\u201317:00 on each day.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "a-before": {
          "id": "a-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "a-remove": {
          "id": "a-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "a-add": {
          "id": "a-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "a-after": {
          "id": "a-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "a-return": {
          "id": "a-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "a-final": {
          "id": "a-final",
          "title": "A \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned A feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "b-rock": {
          "id": "b-rock",
          "title": "Remove recovery medium at 24 \u00b12 hours",
          "rule": "B starts already thawed and plated in ROCK-containing medium. Remove that medium 22\u201326 hours after recovery, inclusive. With recovery at previous-day 19:00, removal is due on day 0 at 17:00\u201321:00. This window applies to removal, not the full imaging/review/return workflow.",
          "fail": "ROCK-containing medium is removed before 22 hours or after 26 hours, or any remains."
        },
        "b-schedule": {
          "id": "b-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "After the recovery feed, feed on days 2, 4, and 6, with the entire workflow within 09:00\u201317:00. The first feed uses the ROCK-removal exception in step 01.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "b-before": {
          "id": "b-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "b-remove": {
          "id": "b-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "b-add": {
          "id": "b-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "b-after": {
          "id": "b-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "b-return": {
          "id": "b-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "b-final": {
          "id": "b-final",
          "title": "B \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned B feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-eligible": {
          "id": "cd-eligible",
          "title": "Check C before passaging",
          "rule": "Obtain a pre-passage image and scientist assessment. Confluence of 70\u2013100% is acceptable, including both endpoints.",
          "fail": "Confluence is below 70% or eligibility evidence is missing. There is no block at 100%."
        },
        "cd-coating": {
          "id": "cd-coating",
          "title": "Empty all six coated D wells",
          "rule": "Remove all coating liquid from every destination well before source treatment.",
          "fail": "Any coating liquid remains in any of the six wells."
        },
        "cd-wash": {
          "id": "cd-wash",
          "title": "Remove medium, wash, and remove PBS",
          "rule": "Remove all spent medium from C. Wash with 1\u20134 mL PBS inclusive, then remove all wash liquid without a deliberate pause.",
          "fail": "Spent medium or PBS remains at its removal checkpoint, wash volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, or a deliberate hold interrupts washing/removal."
        },
        "cd-release": {
          "id": "cd-release",
          "title": "Add and fully remove ReLeSR",
          "rule": "Add 800\u20131,200 \u00b5L ReLeSR inclusive, then remove all of it. No thin film or fixed residual remains.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside the range or any ReLeSR liquid remains after removal."
        },
        "cd-incubate-first": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-first",
          "title": "Incubate for 2\u20134 minutes",
          "rule": "Place C in the incubator for 120\u2013240 seconds inclusive after ReLeSR removal.",
          "fail": "Initial incubation is missing, shorter than 120 seconds, or longer than 240 seconds."
        },
        "cd-review-first": {
          "id": "cd-review-first",
          "title": "Image and receive the first negative review",
          "rule": "Complete a new microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review. The first review deliberately fails and requires reincubation.",
          "fail": "Imaging/review is skipped or the model proceeds to collection despite the negative result."
        },
        "cd-incubate-second": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-second",
          "title": "Return C for a second incubation",
          "rule": "Return the plate to the incubator and execute a second incubation of at most 240 seconds. There is no lower-duration gate. These are separate limits, not a four-minute total cap.",
          "fail": "The model skips incubator return or the incubation step, or the second incubation exceeds 240 seconds."
        },
        "cd-review-second": {
          "id": "cd-review-second",
          "title": "Image again and obtain approval",
          "rule": "After reincubation, complete another microscope acquisition and scientist review. This second review always passes.",
          "fail": "The model proceeds before the second acquisition and review finish."
        },
        "cd-dislodge": {
          "id": "cd-dislodge",
          "title": "Dispense directly onto cells at faster speed",
          "rule": "After approval, add 1\u20134 mL medium inclusive directly onto C\u2019s cells and explicitly acknowledge faster pipette speed to the simulator. This replaces tapping and is the exception to wall dispensing.",
          "fail": "Volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, dispense is not directed onto cells, or the faster-speed acknowledgment is missing."
        },
        "cd-collect": {
          "id": "cd-collect",
          "title": "Choose P1000 wide-bore and collect",
          "rule": "Explicitly select and use the P1000 wide-bore variant to transfer the suspension into a separate collection tube, using capacity-respecting draws.",
          "fail": "Collection uses standard/non-wide-bore tips or omits the required model selection."
        },
        "cd-dilute": {
          "id": "cd-dilute",
          "title": "Calculate dilution to exactly 12 mL",
          "rule": "Choose added medium as 12 mL minus the actual collected suspension volume. The tube must contain exactly 12 mL after dilution. The dilution addition has no 1\u20134 mL restriction.",
          "fail": "The model does not choose the dilution or the resulting tube volume is not 12 mL."
        },
        "cd-mix": {
          "id": "cd-mix",
          "title": "Mix after dilution with wide-bore",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, complete 1\u20135 up-and-down cycles inclusive after dilution and before distribution.",
          "fail": "Mixing is absent, exceeds five cycles, uses non-wide-bore, or occurs only before dilution."
        },
        "cd-distribute": {
          "id": "cd-distribute",
          "title": "Give each D well one-sixth",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, transfer one-sixth of the tube\u2019s starting, post-dilution volume into each of D\u2019s six wells: 2 mL each from 12 mL. Do not recalculate from the shrinking remainder.",
          "fail": "Any well receives a different share, a well is omitted, or distribution uses non-wide-bore."
        },
        "cd-motion": {
          "id": "cd-motion",
          "title": "Close D and distribute cells within wells",
          "rule": "Close D\u2019s lid and perform the simulated side-to-side and front-to-back plate-motion step before incubation.",
          "fail": "The required plate motion is skipped."
        },
        "cd-d-review": {
          "id": "cd-d-review",
          "title": "Image and review D",
          "rule": "Complete microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review after plate motion and before incubator placement. This review always passes.",
          "fail": "Acquisition or completed review is missing or incubation occurs first."
        },
        "cd-d-return": {
          "id": "cd-d-return",
          "title": "Put D in the incubator within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "From the final dispense into D\u2019s last well to incubator entry, allow at most 600 seconds, including plate motion, imaging and review.",
          "fail": "More than 600 seconds elapse or required intervening steps are bypassed."
        },
        "cd-lineage": {
          "id": "cd-lineage",
          "title": "Register D and dispose of C",
          "rule": "Register D as C\u2019s daughter with passage number increased by one (5 \u2192 6 here). Dispose of emptied C and preserve its lineage record.",
          "fail": "C is not disposed, or D\u2019s parentage/passage number is missing or incorrect."
        },
        "cd-day0": {
          "id": "cd-day0",
          "title": "Complete passage on day 0",
          "rule": "Complete C\u2192D passage, D registration and C disposal by day 0 24:00 (57600 seconds after the 08:00 epoch).",
          "fail": "Passage, registration or C disposal remains incomplete after day 0."
        },
        "cd-maintain": {
          "id": "cd-maintain",
          "title": "Maintain D every 48 hours, \u00b12 hours",
          "rule": "First feed is due 48 hours after initial incubator entry, with a 46\u201350-hour window. Repeat every 48 hours on the anchored schedule. The entire feeding workflow must fit within each \u00b12-hour window. Use A\u2019s pre/post imaging and review, full removal with tilt/no scraping, 2\u20134 mL wall addition per well, and 600-second return limit.",
          "fail": "Any subsequent feeding rule or the full-workflow timing window is missed."
        },
        "cd-final": {
          "id": "cd-final",
          "title": "Leave D ready",
          "rule": "At final submission, D is in its assigned incubator with its lid closed; source C is disposed.",
          "fail": "D is elsewhere, its lid is open, or C has not been disposed."
        },
        "d-schedule": {
          "id": "d-schedule",
          "title": "D feed schedule",
          "rule": "Complete each D feed within its assigned \u00b12-hour window."
        },
        "d-before": {
          "id": "d-before",
          "title": "D pre-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a fresh image for every D feed."
        },
        "d-remove": {
          "id": "d-remove",
          "title": "D complete removal",
          "rule": "Remove all old medium from every well with tilt, no scraping and at most one bottom touch."
        },
        "d-add": {
          "id": "d-add",
          "title": "D fresh medium",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall into each emptied well."
        },
        "d-after": {
          "id": "d-after",
          "title": "D post-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a new image after each D feed."
        },
        "d-return": {
          "id": "d-return",
          "title": "D incubator return",
          "rule": "Return within 600 seconds of the final dispense."
        },
        "d-final": {
          "id": "d-final",
          "title": "D \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned D feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "final-jobs": {
          "id": "final-jobs",
          "title": "Finish the workflow and complete all jobs",
          "rule": "Submit at day seven after running the workflow; all initiated jobs must be done, with no unfinished feed or wash sequence."
        },
        "final-robot": {
          "id": "final-robot",
          "title": "Finish pipetting and release the robot",
          "rule": "After executing pipetting and submitting at day seven, leave no held plate or attached tip."
        },
        "material-accounting": {
          "id": "material-accounting",
          "title": "Execute and conserve material",
          "rule": "After actual liquid transfers and day-seven submission, preserve material conservation and leave no cell clumps in waste."
        },
        "no-violation": {
          "id": "no-violation",
          "title": "Complete execution without violations",
          "rule": "Execute liquid handling and submit at day seven without terminal protocol violations or truncation."
        },
        "submitted": {
          "id": "submitted",
          "title": "Final submission",
          "rule": "Submit finish at exactly 604800 seconds."
        },
        "e-schedule": {
          "id": "e-schedule",
          "title": "E \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-before": {
          "id": "e-before",
          "title": "E \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-remove": {
          "id": "e-remove",
          "title": "E \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-add": {
          "id": "e-add",
          "title": "E \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-after": {
          "id": "e-after",
          "title": "E \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-return": {
          "id": "e-return",
          "title": "E \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-final": {
          "id": "e-final",
          "title": "E \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned E feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "f-schedule": {
          "id": "f-schedule",
          "title": "F \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-before": {
          "id": "f-before",
          "title": "F \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-remove": {
          "id": "f-remove",
          "title": "F \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-add": {
          "id": "f-add",
          "title": "F \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-after": {
          "id": "f-after",
          "title": "F \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-return": {
          "id": "f-return",
          "title": "F \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-final": {
          "id": "f-final",
          "title": "F \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned F feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "g-schedule": {
          "id": "g-schedule",
          "title": "G \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-before": {
          "id": "g-before",
          "title": "G \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-remove": {
          "id": "g-remove",
          "title": "G \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-add": {
          "id": "g-add",
          "title": "G \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-after": {
          "id": "g-after",
          "title": "G \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-return": {
          "id": "g-return",
          "title": "G \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-final": {
          "id": "g-final",
          "title": "G \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned G feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-intervention": {
          "id": "cd-intervention",
          "title": "Scientist intervention",
          "rule": "Complete scientist intervention when requested; do not invent an intervention on a branch that does not require it."
        },
        "equipment-recovery": {
          "id": "equipment-recovery",
          "title": "Recover failed acquisitions",
          "rule": "A failed acquisition must be followed by a successful image of the same plate and purpose without repeating material transfers."
        }
      },
      "journal_url": "data/gate-dashboard/journal-6aed5327ce592c90.json",
      "agent_trace_url": "data/gate-dashboard/agent-trillo-ipsc-maintenance__nzAALY5.json",
      "agent_trace_summary": {
        "available": true,
        "turn_count": 13,
        "tool_call_count": 12,
        "tool_error_count": 0
      },
      "url": "data/gate-dashboard/trillo-ipsc-maintenance__nzAALY5.json",
      "gate_results": {
        "a-schedule": true,
        "a-before": true,
        "a-remove": true,
        "a-add": true,
        "a-after": true,
        "a-return": true,
        "a-final": true,
        "b-schedule": true,
        "b-before": true,
        "b-remove": true,
        "b-add": true,
        "b-after": true,
        "b-return": true,
        "b-final": true,
        "d-schedule": true,
        "d-before": true,
        "d-remove": true,
        "d-add": true,
        "d-after": true,
        "d-return": true,
        "d-final": true,
        "b-rock": true,
        "cd-eligible": true,
        "cd-coating": true,
        "cd-wash": true,
        "cd-release": true,
        "cd-incubate-first": true,
        "cd-review-first": true,
        "cd-incubate-second": true,
        "cd-review-second": true,
        "cd-dislodge": true,
        "cd-collect": true,
        "cd-dilute": true,
        "cd-mix": true,
        "cd-distribute": true,
        "cd-motion": true,
        "cd-d-review": true,
        "cd-d-return": true,
        "cd-lineage": true,
        "cd-day0": true,
        "cd-maintain": true,
        "cd-final": true,
        "final-jobs": true,
        "final-robot": true,
        "material-accounting": true,
        "no-violation": true,
        "submitted": true
      },
      "gate_status": {
        "a-schedule": "completed",
        "a-before": "completed",
        "a-remove": "completed",
        "a-add": "completed",
        "a-after": "completed",
        "a-return": "completed",
        "a-final": "completed",
        "b-schedule": "completed",
        "b-before": "completed",
        "b-remove": "completed",
        "b-add": "completed",
        "b-after": "completed",
        "b-return": "completed",
        "b-final": "completed",
        "d-schedule": "completed",
        "d-before": "completed",
        "d-remove": "completed",
        "d-add": "completed",
        "d-after": "completed",
        "d-return": "completed",
        "d-final": "completed",
        "b-rock": "completed",
        "cd-eligible": "completed",
        "cd-coating": "completed",
        "cd-wash": "completed",
        "cd-release": "completed",
        "cd-incubate-first": "completed",
        "cd-review-first": "completed",
        "cd-incubate-second": "completed",
        "cd-review-second": "completed",
        "cd-dislodge": "completed",
        "cd-collect": "completed",
        "cd-dilute": "completed",
        "cd-mix": "completed",
        "cd-distribute": "completed",
        "cd-motion": "completed",
        "cd-d-review": "completed",
        "cd-d-return": "completed",
        "cd-lineage": "completed",
        "cd-day0": "completed",
        "cd-maintain": "completed",
        "cd-final": "completed",
        "final-jobs": "completed",
        "final-robot": "completed",
        "material-accounting": "completed",
        "no-violation": "completed",
        "submitted": "completed"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "trillo-ipsc-maintenance__Kizjr9v",
      "label": "Reference control",
      "role": "oracle",
      "grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-reviewed-v2",
        "scoring": "binary-reviewed-v2",
        "success": true,
        "reward": 1,
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": true,
          "a-before": true,
          "a-remove": true,
          "a-add": true,
          "a-after": true,
          "a-return": true,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": true,
          "b-before": true,
          "b-remove": true,
          "b-add": true,
          "b-after": true,
          "b-return": true,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": true,
          "d-before": true,
          "d-remove": true,
          "d-add": true,
          "d-after": true,
          "d-return": true,
          "d-final": true,
          "b-rock": true,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": true,
          "cd-wash": true,
          "cd-release": true,
          "cd-incubate-first": true,
          "cd-review-first": true,
          "cd-incubate-second": true,
          "cd-review-second": true,
          "cd-dislodge": true,
          "cd-collect": true,
          "cd-dilute": true,
          "cd-mix": true,
          "cd-distribute": true,
          "cd-motion": true,
          "cd-d-review": true,
          "cd-d-return": true,
          "cd-lineage": true,
          "cd-day0": true,
          "cd-maintain": true,
          "cd-final": true,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": true,
          "submitted": true
        },
        "failed_gates": [],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 604800.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 66
      },
      "original_grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-reviewed-v2",
        "scoring": "binary-reviewed-v2",
        "success": true,
        "reward": 1,
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": true,
          "a-before": true,
          "a-remove": true,
          "a-add": true,
          "a-after": true,
          "a-return": true,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": true,
          "b-before": true,
          "b-remove": true,
          "b-add": true,
          "b-after": true,
          "b-return": true,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": true,
          "d-before": true,
          "d-remove": true,
          "d-add": true,
          "d-after": true,
          "d-return": true,
          "d-final": true,
          "b-rock": true,
          "cd-eligible": true,
          "cd-coating": true,
          "cd-wash": true,
          "cd-release": true,
          "cd-incubate-first": true,
          "cd-review-first": true,
          "cd-incubate-second": true,
          "cd-review-second": true,
          "cd-dislodge": true,
          "cd-collect": true,
          "cd-dilute": true,
          "cd-mix": true,
          "cd-distribute": true,
          "cd-motion": true,
          "cd-d-review": true,
          "cd-d-return": true,
          "cd-lineage": true,
          "cd-day0": true,
          "cd-maintain": true,
          "cd-final": true,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": true,
          "submitted": true
        },
        "failed_gates": [],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 604800.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 66
      },
      "grading_revision": "zero-noop-v1",
      "grader_sha256": "01457fa8f4015c8263a0f1df0db7830ee76ce23c78a2806b8b98d8181807a767",
      "execution_note": null,
      "source_commit": "c9e6facd1e8c",
      "edition": "Baseline \u00b7 original instructions",
      "runtime": "8527cf0e77eae513b236f5df47f8fca9a810b3966019c7fcb7a6b707f0b412ed",
      "sha256": "112fd5d611d24660c6061e7f5cf8528363a6548435fb047d99a3543e8ede7a7c",
      "source": "jobs/day0-controls/jobs/ipsc-reviewed-controls-20261112T014010Z/trillo-ipsc-maintenance__Kizjr9v/artifacts/attempt.json",
      "exact_replay": true,
      "regraded": true,
      "rules": {
        "a-schedule": {
          "id": "a-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "Feed on days 0, 2, 4, and 6. The entire workflow, including imaging, review and incubator return, must fit within 09:00\u201317:00 on each day.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "a-before": {
          "id": "a-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "a-remove": {
          "id": "a-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "a-add": {
          "id": "a-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "a-after": {
          "id": "a-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "a-return": {
          "id": "a-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "a-final": {
          "id": "a-final",
          "title": "A \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned A feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "b-rock": {
          "id": "b-rock",
          "title": "Remove recovery medium at 24 \u00b12 hours",
          "rule": "B starts already thawed and plated in ROCK-containing medium. Remove that medium 22\u201326 hours after recovery, inclusive. With recovery at previous-day 19:00, removal is due on day 0 at 17:00\u201321:00. This window applies to removal, not the full imaging/review/return workflow.",
          "fail": "ROCK-containing medium is removed before 22 hours or after 26 hours, or any remains."
        },
        "b-schedule": {
          "id": "b-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "After the recovery feed, feed on days 2, 4, and 6, with the entire workflow within 09:00\u201317:00. The first feed uses the ROCK-removal exception in step 01.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "b-before": {
          "id": "b-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "b-remove": {
          "id": "b-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "b-add": {
          "id": "b-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "b-after": {
          "id": "b-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "b-return": {
          "id": "b-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "b-final": {
          "id": "b-final",
          "title": "B \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned B feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-eligible": {
          "id": "cd-eligible",
          "title": "Check C before passaging",
          "rule": "Obtain a pre-passage image and scientist assessment. Confluence of 70\u2013100% is acceptable, including both endpoints.",
          "fail": "Confluence is below 70% or eligibility evidence is missing. There is no block at 100%."
        },
        "cd-coating": {
          "id": "cd-coating",
          "title": "Empty all six coated D wells",
          "rule": "Remove all coating liquid from every destination well before source treatment.",
          "fail": "Any coating liquid remains in any of the six wells."
        },
        "cd-wash": {
          "id": "cd-wash",
          "title": "Remove medium, wash, and remove PBS",
          "rule": "Remove all spent medium from C. Wash with 1\u20134 mL PBS inclusive, then remove all wash liquid without a deliberate pause.",
          "fail": "Spent medium or PBS remains at its removal checkpoint, wash volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, or a deliberate hold interrupts washing/removal."
        },
        "cd-release": {
          "id": "cd-release",
          "title": "Add and fully remove ReLeSR",
          "rule": "Add 800\u20131,200 \u00b5L ReLeSR inclusive, then remove all of it. No thin film or fixed residual remains.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside the range or any ReLeSR liquid remains after removal."
        },
        "cd-incubate-first": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-first",
          "title": "Incubate for 2\u20134 minutes",
          "rule": "Place C in the incubator for 120\u2013240 seconds inclusive after ReLeSR removal.",
          "fail": "Initial incubation is missing, shorter than 120 seconds, or longer than 240 seconds."
        },
        "cd-review-first": {
          "id": "cd-review-first",
          "title": "Image and receive the first negative review",
          "rule": "Complete a new microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review. The first review deliberately fails and requires reincubation.",
          "fail": "Imaging/review is skipped or the model proceeds to collection despite the negative result."
        },
        "cd-incubate-second": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-second",
          "title": "Return C for a second incubation",
          "rule": "Return the plate to the incubator and execute a second incubation of at most 240 seconds. There is no lower-duration gate. These are separate limits, not a four-minute total cap.",
          "fail": "The model skips incubator return or the incubation step, or the second incubation exceeds 240 seconds."
        },
        "cd-review-second": {
          "id": "cd-review-second",
          "title": "Image again and obtain approval",
          "rule": "After reincubation, complete another microscope acquisition and scientist review. This second review always passes.",
          "fail": "The model proceeds before the second acquisition and review finish."
        },
        "cd-dislodge": {
          "id": "cd-dislodge",
          "title": "Dispense directly onto cells at faster speed",
          "rule": "After approval, add 1\u20134 mL medium inclusive directly onto C\u2019s cells and explicitly acknowledge faster pipette speed to the simulator. This replaces tapping and is the exception to wall dispensing.",
          "fail": "Volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, dispense is not directed onto cells, or the faster-speed acknowledgment is missing."
        },
        "cd-collect": {
          "id": "cd-collect",
          "title": "Choose P1000 wide-bore and collect",
          "rule": "Explicitly select and use the P1000 wide-bore variant to transfer the suspension into a separate collection tube, using capacity-respecting draws.",
          "fail": "Collection uses standard/non-wide-bore tips or omits the required model selection."
        },
        "cd-dilute": {
          "id": "cd-dilute",
          "title": "Calculate dilution to exactly 12 mL",
          "rule": "Choose added medium as 12 mL minus the actual collected suspension volume. The tube must contain exactly 12 mL after dilution. The dilution addition has no 1\u20134 mL restriction.",
          "fail": "The model does not choose the dilution or the resulting tube volume is not 12 mL."
        },
        "cd-mix": {
          "id": "cd-mix",
          "title": "Mix after dilution with wide-bore",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, complete 1\u20135 up-and-down cycles inclusive after dilution and before distribution.",
          "fail": "Mixing is absent, exceeds five cycles, uses non-wide-bore, or occurs only before dilution."
        },
        "cd-distribute": {
          "id": "cd-distribute",
          "title": "Give each D well one-sixth",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, transfer one-sixth of the tube\u2019s starting, post-dilution volume into each of D\u2019s six wells: 2 mL each from 12 mL. Do not recalculate from the shrinking remainder.",
          "fail": "Any well receives a different share, a well is omitted, or distribution uses non-wide-bore."
        },
        "cd-motion": {
          "id": "cd-motion",
          "title": "Close D and distribute cells within wells",
          "rule": "Close D\u2019s lid and perform the simulated side-to-side and front-to-back plate-motion step before incubation.",
          "fail": "The required plate motion is skipped."
        },
        "cd-d-review": {
          "id": "cd-d-review",
          "title": "Image and review D",
          "rule": "Complete microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review after plate motion and before incubator placement. This review always passes.",
          "fail": "Acquisition or completed review is missing or incubation occurs first."
        },
        "cd-d-return": {
          "id": "cd-d-return",
          "title": "Put D in the incubator within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "From the final dispense into D\u2019s last well to incubator entry, allow at most 600 seconds, including plate motion, imaging and review.",
          "fail": "More than 600 seconds elapse or required intervening steps are bypassed."
        },
        "cd-lineage": {
          "id": "cd-lineage",
          "title": "Register D and dispose of C",
          "rule": "Register D as C\u2019s daughter with passage number increased by one (5 \u2192 6 here). Dispose of emptied C and preserve its lineage record.",
          "fail": "C is not disposed, or D\u2019s parentage/passage number is missing or incorrect."
        },
        "cd-day0": {
          "id": "cd-day0",
          "title": "Complete passage on day 0",
          "rule": "Complete C\u2192D passage, D registration and C disposal by day 0 24:00 (57600 seconds after the 08:00 epoch).",
          "fail": "Passage, registration or C disposal remains incomplete after day 0."
        },
        "cd-maintain": {
          "id": "cd-maintain",
          "title": "Maintain D every 48 hours, \u00b12 hours",
          "rule": "First feed is due 48 hours after initial incubator entry, with a 46\u201350-hour window. Repeat every 48 hours on the anchored schedule. The entire feeding workflow must fit within each \u00b12-hour window. Use A\u2019s pre/post imaging and review, full removal with tilt/no scraping, 2\u20134 mL wall addition per well, and 600-second return limit.",
          "fail": "Any subsequent feeding rule or the full-workflow timing window is missed."
        },
        "cd-final": {
          "id": "cd-final",
          "title": "Leave D ready",
          "rule": "At final submission, D is in its assigned incubator with its lid closed; source C is disposed.",
          "fail": "D is elsewhere, its lid is open, or C has not been disposed."
        },
        "d-schedule": {
          "id": "d-schedule",
          "title": "D feed schedule",
          "rule": "Complete each D feed within its assigned \u00b12-hour window."
        },
        "d-before": {
          "id": "d-before",
          "title": "D pre-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a fresh image for every D feed."
        },
        "d-remove": {
          "id": "d-remove",
          "title": "D complete removal",
          "rule": "Remove all old medium from every well with tilt, no scraping and at most one bottom touch."
        },
        "d-add": {
          "id": "d-add",
          "title": "D fresh medium",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall into each emptied well."
        },
        "d-after": {
          "id": "d-after",
          "title": "D post-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a new image after each D feed."
        },
        "d-return": {
          "id": "d-return",
          "title": "D incubator return",
          "rule": "Return within 600 seconds of the final dispense."
        },
        "d-final": {
          "id": "d-final",
          "title": "D \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned D feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "final-jobs": {
          "id": "final-jobs",
          "title": "Finish the workflow and complete all jobs",
          "rule": "Submit at day seven after running the workflow; all initiated jobs must be done, with no unfinished feed or wash sequence."
        },
        "final-robot": {
          "id": "final-robot",
          "title": "Finish pipetting and release the robot",
          "rule": "After executing pipetting and submitting at day seven, leave no held plate or attached tip."
        },
        "material-accounting": {
          "id": "material-accounting",
          "title": "Execute and conserve material",
          "rule": "After actual liquid transfers and day-seven submission, preserve material conservation and leave no cell clumps in waste."
        },
        "no-violation": {
          "id": "no-violation",
          "title": "Complete execution without violations",
          "rule": "Execute liquid handling and submit at day seven without terminal protocol violations or truncation."
        },
        "submitted": {
          "id": "submitted",
          "title": "Final submission",
          "rule": "Submit finish at exactly 604800 seconds."
        },
        "e-schedule": {
          "id": "e-schedule",
          "title": "E \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-before": {
          "id": "e-before",
          "title": "E \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-remove": {
          "id": "e-remove",
          "title": "E \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-add": {
          "id": "e-add",
          "title": "E \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-after": {
          "id": "e-after",
          "title": "E \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-return": {
          "id": "e-return",
          "title": "E \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-final": {
          "id": "e-final",
          "title": "E \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned E feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "f-schedule": {
          "id": "f-schedule",
          "title": "F \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-before": {
          "id": "f-before",
          "title": "F \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-remove": {
          "id": "f-remove",
          "title": "F \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-add": {
          "id": "f-add",
          "title": "F \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-after": {
          "id": "f-after",
          "title": "F \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-return": {
          "id": "f-return",
          "title": "F \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-final": {
          "id": "f-final",
          "title": "F \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned F feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "g-schedule": {
          "id": "g-schedule",
          "title": "G \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-before": {
          "id": "g-before",
          "title": "G \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-remove": {
          "id": "g-remove",
          "title": "G \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-add": {
          "id": "g-add",
          "title": "G \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-after": {
          "id": "g-after",
          "title": "G \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-return": {
          "id": "g-return",
          "title": "G \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-final": {
          "id": "g-final",
          "title": "G \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned G feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-intervention": {
          "id": "cd-intervention",
          "title": "Scientist intervention",
          "rule": "Complete scientist intervention when requested; do not invent an intervention on a branch that does not require it."
        },
        "equipment-recovery": {
          "id": "equipment-recovery",
          "title": "Recover failed acquisitions",
          "rule": "A failed acquisition must be followed by a successful image of the same plate and purpose without repeating material transfers."
        }
      },
      "journal_url": "data/gate-dashboard/journal-112fd5d611d24660.json",
      "agent_trace_url": "data/gate-dashboard/agent-trillo-ipsc-maintenance__Kizjr9v.json",
      "agent_trace_summary": {
        "available": false,
        "turn_count": 0,
        "tool_call_count": 0,
        "tool_error_count": 0
      },
      "url": "data/gate-dashboard/trillo-ipsc-maintenance__Kizjr9v.json",
      "gate_results": {
        "a-schedule": true,
        "a-before": true,
        "a-remove": true,
        "a-add": true,
        "a-after": true,
        "a-return": true,
        "a-final": true,
        "b-schedule": true,
        "b-before": true,
        "b-remove": true,
        "b-add": true,
        "b-after": true,
        "b-return": true,
        "b-final": true,
        "d-schedule": true,
        "d-before": true,
        "d-remove": true,
        "d-add": true,
        "d-after": true,
        "d-return": true,
        "d-final": true,
        "b-rock": true,
        "cd-eligible": true,
        "cd-coating": true,
        "cd-wash": true,
        "cd-release": true,
        "cd-incubate-first": true,
        "cd-review-first": true,
        "cd-incubate-second": true,
        "cd-review-second": true,
        "cd-dislodge": true,
        "cd-collect": true,
        "cd-dilute": true,
        "cd-mix": true,
        "cd-distribute": true,
        "cd-motion": true,
        "cd-d-review": true,
        "cd-d-return": true,
        "cd-lineage": true,
        "cd-day0": true,
        "cd-maintain": true,
        "cd-final": true,
        "final-jobs": true,
        "final-robot": true,
        "material-accounting": true,
        "no-violation": true,
        "submitted": true
      },
      "gate_status": {
        "a-schedule": "completed",
        "a-before": "completed",
        "a-remove": "completed",
        "a-add": "completed",
        "a-after": "completed",
        "a-return": "completed",
        "a-final": "completed",
        "b-schedule": "completed",
        "b-before": "completed",
        "b-remove": "completed",
        "b-add": "completed",
        "b-after": "completed",
        "b-return": "completed",
        "b-final": "completed",
        "d-schedule": "completed",
        "d-before": "completed",
        "d-remove": "completed",
        "d-add": "completed",
        "d-after": "completed",
        "d-return": "completed",
        "d-final": "completed",
        "b-rock": "completed",
        "cd-eligible": "completed",
        "cd-coating": "completed",
        "cd-wash": "completed",
        "cd-release": "completed",
        "cd-incubate-first": "completed",
        "cd-review-first": "completed",
        "cd-incubate-second": "completed",
        "cd-review-second": "completed",
        "cd-dislodge": "completed",
        "cd-collect": "completed",
        "cd-dilute": "completed",
        "cd-mix": "completed",
        "cd-distribute": "completed",
        "cd-motion": "completed",
        "cd-d-review": "completed",
        "cd-d-return": "completed",
        "cd-lineage": "completed",
        "cd-day0": "completed",
        "cd-maintain": "completed",
        "cd-final": "completed",
        "final-jobs": "completed",
        "final-robot": "completed",
        "material-accounting": "completed",
        "no-violation": "completed",
        "submitted": "completed"
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "trillo-ipsc-maintenance__PKtFa8N",
      "label": "No-op control",
      "role": "noop",
      "grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-reviewed-v2",
        "scoring": "binary-reviewed-v2",
        "success": false,
        "reward": 0,
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": false,
          "a-before": false,
          "a-remove": false,
          "a-add": false,
          "a-after": false,
          "a-return": false,
          "a-final": false,
          "b-schedule": false,
          "b-before": false,
          "b-remove": false,
          "b-add": false,
          "b-after": false,
          "b-return": false,
          "b-final": false,
          "d-schedule": false,
          "d-before": false,
          "d-remove": false,
          "d-add": false,
          "d-after": false,
          "d-return": false,
          "d-final": false,
          "b-rock": false,
          "cd-eligible": false,
          "cd-coating": false,
          "cd-wash": false,
          "cd-release": false,
          "cd-incubate-first": false,
          "cd-review-first": false,
          "cd-incubate-second": false,
          "cd-review-second": false,
          "cd-dislodge": false,
          "cd-collect": false,
          "cd-dilute": false,
          "cd-mix": false,
          "cd-distribute": false,
          "cd-motion": false,
          "cd-d-review": false,
          "cd-d-return": false,
          "cd-lineage": false,
          "cd-day0": false,
          "cd-maintain": false,
          "cd-final": false,
          "final-jobs": false,
          "final-robot": false,
          "material-accounting": false,
          "no-violation": false,
          "submitted": false
        },
        "failed_gates": [
          "a-schedule",
          "a-before",
          "a-remove",
          "a-add",
          "a-after",
          "a-return",
          "a-final",
          "b-schedule",
          "b-before",
          "b-remove",
          "b-add",
          "b-after",
          "b-return",
          "b-final",
          "d-schedule",
          "d-before",
          "d-remove",
          "d-add",
          "d-after",
          "d-return",
          "d-final",
          "b-rock",
          "cd-eligible",
          "cd-coating",
          "cd-wash",
          "cd-release",
          "cd-incubate-first",
          "cd-review-first",
          "cd-incubate-second",
          "cd-review-second",
          "cd-dislodge",
          "cd-collect",
          "cd-dilute",
          "cd-mix",
          "cd-distribute",
          "cd-motion",
          "cd-d-review",
          "cd-d-return",
          "cd-lineage",
          "cd-day0",
          "cd-maintain",
          "cd-final",
          "final-jobs",
          "final-robot",
          "material-accounting",
          "no-violation",
          "submitted"
        ],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 0.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 0
      },
      "original_grade": {
        "protocol": "scientist-reviewed-v2",
        "scoring": "binary-reviewed-v2",
        "success": false,
        "reward": 0,
        "gates": {
          "a-schedule": false,
          "a-before": false,
          "a-remove": false,
          "a-add": false,
          "a-after": false,
          "a-return": false,
          "a-final": true,
          "b-schedule": false,
          "b-before": false,
          "b-remove": false,
          "b-add": false,
          "b-after": false,
          "b-return": false,
          "b-final": true,
          "d-schedule": false,
          "d-before": false,
          "d-remove": false,
          "d-add": false,
          "d-after": false,
          "d-return": false,
          "d-final": false,
          "b-rock": false,
          "cd-eligible": false,
          "cd-coating": false,
          "cd-wash": false,
          "cd-release": false,
          "cd-incubate-first": false,
          "cd-review-first": false,
          "cd-incubate-second": false,
          "cd-review-second": false,
          "cd-dislodge": false,
          "cd-collect": false,
          "cd-dilute": false,
          "cd-mix": false,
          "cd-distribute": false,
          "cd-motion": false,
          "cd-d-review": false,
          "cd-d-return": false,
          "cd-lineage": false,
          "cd-day0": false,
          "cd-maintain": false,
          "cd-final": false,
          "final-jobs": true,
          "final-robot": true,
          "material-accounting": true,
          "no-violation": true,
          "submitted": false
        },
        "failed_gates": [
          "a-schedule",
          "a-before",
          "a-remove",
          "a-add",
          "a-after",
          "a-return",
          "b-schedule",
          "b-before",
          "b-remove",
          "b-add",
          "b-after",
          "b-return",
          "d-schedule",
          "d-before",
          "d-remove",
          "d-add",
          "d-after",
          "d-return",
          "d-final",
          "b-rock",
          "cd-eligible",
          "cd-coating",
          "cd-wash",
          "cd-release",
          "cd-incubate-first",
          "cd-review-first",
          "cd-incubate-second",
          "cd-review-second",
          "cd-dislodge",
          "cd-collect",
          "cd-dilute",
          "cd-mix",
          "cd-distribute",
          "cd-motion",
          "cd-d-review",
          "cd-d-return",
          "cd-lineage",
          "cd-day0",
          "cd-maintain",
          "cd-final",
          "submitted"
        ],
        "failure": null,
        "truncated": false,
        "clock_s": 0.0,
        "conserved": true,
        "tips_used": 0
      },
      "grading_revision": "zero-noop-v1",
      "grader_sha256": "01457fa8f4015c8263a0f1df0db7830ee76ce23c78a2806b8b98d8181807a767",
      "execution_note": null,
      "source_commit": "c9e6facd1e8c",
      "edition": "Baseline \u00b7 original instructions",
      "runtime": "8527cf0e77eae513b236f5df47f8fca9a810b3966019c7fcb7a6b707f0b412ed",
      "sha256": "a5a8ca93391e31a5883899271b1bbfdc6e70189433d95c25e6f02672e9f907de",
      "source": "jobs/day0-controls/jobs/ipsc-reviewed-controls-20261112T014010Z/trillo-ipsc-maintenance__PKtFa8N/artifacts/attempt.json",
      "exact_replay": true,
      "regraded": true,
      "rules": {
        "a-schedule": {
          "id": "a-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "Feed on days 0, 2, 4, and 6. The entire workflow, including imaging, review and incubator return, must fit within 09:00\u201317:00 on each day.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "a-before": {
          "id": "a-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "a-remove": {
          "id": "a-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "a-add": {
          "id": "a-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "a-after": {
          "id": "a-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "a-return": {
          "id": "a-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "a-final": {
          "id": "a-final",
          "title": "A \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned A feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "b-rock": {
          "id": "b-rock",
          "title": "Remove recovery medium at 24 \u00b12 hours",
          "rule": "B starts already thawed and plated in ROCK-containing medium. Remove that medium 22\u201326 hours after recovery, inclusive. With recovery at previous-day 19:00, removal is due on day 0 at 17:00\u201321:00. This window applies to removal, not the full imaging/review/return workflow.",
          "fail": "ROCK-containing medium is removed before 22 hours or after 26 hours, or any remains."
        },
        "b-schedule": {
          "id": "b-schedule",
          "title": "Keep the feeding schedule",
          "rule": "After the recovery feed, feed on days 2, 4, and 6, with the entire workflow within 09:00\u201317:00. The first feed uses the ROCK-removal exception in step 01.",
          "fail": "A required feed is missed or the complete workflow falls outside its window."
        },
        "b-before": {
          "id": "b-before",
          "title": "Image and review before feeding",
          "rule": "Acquire a current pre-feed image and complete a simulated scientist review before medium exchange.",
          "fail": "Either acquisition or completed review is missing, stale, or occurs after feeding starts."
        },
        "b-remove": {
          "id": "b-remove",
          "title": "Remove all spent medium",
          "rule": "Tilt the plate and remove all spent medium. One touch to the plate bottom is allowed; scraping along the bottom is prohibited.",
          "fail": "Any spent medium remains, the plate is not tilted, or the tip scrapes the bottom."
        },
        "b-add": {
          "id": "b-add",
          "title": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL fresh medium per well, inclusive, regardless of confluence. Dispense down the wall.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside 2\u20134 mL or directed onto the cells."
        },
        "b-after": {
          "id": "b-after",
          "title": "Acquire a new image and review",
          "rule": "After feeding, request a new microscope acquisition, wait for acquisition to finish, then complete a simulated scientist review. This review always passes in this task. If a problem is flagged, request intervention before incubator return.",
          "fail": "The post-feed image or completed review is missing, out of order, or replaced with the pre-feed check."
        },
        "b-return": {
          "id": "b-return",
          "title": "Return within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "After completed review, return to the incubator within 600 seconds of the final fresh-medium dispense finishing. Exactly 600 seconds is allowed.",
          "fail": "Return precedes completed review or takes more than 600 seconds after the final dispense."
        },
        "b-final": {
          "id": "b-final",
          "title": "B \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned B feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-eligible": {
          "id": "cd-eligible",
          "title": "Check C before passaging",
          "rule": "Obtain a pre-passage image and scientist assessment. Confluence of 70\u2013100% is acceptable, including both endpoints.",
          "fail": "Confluence is below 70% or eligibility evidence is missing. There is no block at 100%."
        },
        "cd-coating": {
          "id": "cd-coating",
          "title": "Empty all six coated D wells",
          "rule": "Remove all coating liquid from every destination well before source treatment.",
          "fail": "Any coating liquid remains in any of the six wells."
        },
        "cd-wash": {
          "id": "cd-wash",
          "title": "Remove medium, wash, and remove PBS",
          "rule": "Remove all spent medium from C. Wash with 1\u20134 mL PBS inclusive, then remove all wash liquid without a deliberate pause.",
          "fail": "Spent medium or PBS remains at its removal checkpoint, wash volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, or a deliberate hold interrupts washing/removal."
        },
        "cd-release": {
          "id": "cd-release",
          "title": "Add and fully remove ReLeSR",
          "rule": "Add 800\u20131,200 \u00b5L ReLeSR inclusive, then remove all of it. No thin film or fixed residual remains.",
          "fail": "Addition is outside the range or any ReLeSR liquid remains after removal."
        },
        "cd-incubate-first": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-first",
          "title": "Incubate for 2\u20134 minutes",
          "rule": "Place C in the incubator for 120\u2013240 seconds inclusive after ReLeSR removal.",
          "fail": "Initial incubation is missing, shorter than 120 seconds, or longer than 240 seconds."
        },
        "cd-review-first": {
          "id": "cd-review-first",
          "title": "Image and receive the first negative review",
          "rule": "Complete a new microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review. The first review deliberately fails and requires reincubation.",
          "fail": "Imaging/review is skipped or the model proceeds to collection despite the negative result."
        },
        "cd-incubate-second": {
          "id": "cd-incubate-second",
          "title": "Return C for a second incubation",
          "rule": "Return the plate to the incubator and execute a second incubation of at most 240 seconds. There is no lower-duration gate. These are separate limits, not a four-minute total cap.",
          "fail": "The model skips incubator return or the incubation step, or the second incubation exceeds 240 seconds."
        },
        "cd-review-second": {
          "id": "cd-review-second",
          "title": "Image again and obtain approval",
          "rule": "After reincubation, complete another microscope acquisition and scientist review. This second review always passes.",
          "fail": "The model proceeds before the second acquisition and review finish."
        },
        "cd-dislodge": {
          "id": "cd-dislodge",
          "title": "Dispense directly onto cells at faster speed",
          "rule": "After approval, add 1\u20134 mL medium inclusive directly onto C\u2019s cells and explicitly acknowledge faster pipette speed to the simulator. This replaces tapping and is the exception to wall dispensing.",
          "fail": "Volume is outside 1\u20134 mL, dispense is not directed onto cells, or the faster-speed acknowledgment is missing."
        },
        "cd-collect": {
          "id": "cd-collect",
          "title": "Choose P1000 wide-bore and collect",
          "rule": "Explicitly select and use the P1000 wide-bore variant to transfer the suspension into a separate collection tube, using capacity-respecting draws.",
          "fail": "Collection uses standard/non-wide-bore tips or omits the required model selection."
        },
        "cd-dilute": {
          "id": "cd-dilute",
          "title": "Calculate dilution to exactly 12 mL",
          "rule": "Choose added medium as 12 mL minus the actual collected suspension volume. The tube must contain exactly 12 mL after dilution. The dilution addition has no 1\u20134 mL restriction.",
          "fail": "The model does not choose the dilution or the resulting tube volume is not 12 mL."
        },
        "cd-mix": {
          "id": "cd-mix",
          "title": "Mix after dilution with wide-bore",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, complete 1\u20135 up-and-down cycles inclusive after dilution and before distribution.",
          "fail": "Mixing is absent, exceeds five cycles, uses non-wide-bore, or occurs only before dilution."
        },
        "cd-distribute": {
          "id": "cd-distribute",
          "title": "Give each D well one-sixth",
          "rule": "Using P1000 wide-bore, transfer one-sixth of the tube\u2019s starting, post-dilution volume into each of D\u2019s six wells: 2 mL each from 12 mL. Do not recalculate from the shrinking remainder.",
          "fail": "Any well receives a different share, a well is omitted, or distribution uses non-wide-bore."
        },
        "cd-motion": {
          "id": "cd-motion",
          "title": "Close D and distribute cells within wells",
          "rule": "Close D\u2019s lid and perform the simulated side-to-side and front-to-back plate-motion step before incubation.",
          "fail": "The required plate motion is skipped."
        },
        "cd-d-review": {
          "id": "cd-d-review",
          "title": "Image and review D",
          "rule": "Complete microscope acquisition and simulated scientist review after plate motion and before incubator placement. This review always passes.",
          "fail": "Acquisition or completed review is missing or incubation occurs first."
        },
        "cd-d-return": {
          "id": "cd-d-return",
          "title": "Put D in the incubator within 10 minutes",
          "rule": "From the final dispense into D\u2019s last well to incubator entry, allow at most 600 seconds, including plate motion, imaging and review.",
          "fail": "More than 600 seconds elapse or required intervening steps are bypassed."
        },
        "cd-lineage": {
          "id": "cd-lineage",
          "title": "Register D and dispose of C",
          "rule": "Register D as C\u2019s daughter with passage number increased by one (5 \u2192 6 here). Dispose of emptied C and preserve its lineage record.",
          "fail": "C is not disposed, or D\u2019s parentage/passage number is missing or incorrect."
        },
        "cd-day0": {
          "id": "cd-day0",
          "title": "Complete passage on day 0",
          "rule": "Complete C\u2192D passage, D registration and C disposal by day 0 24:00 (57600 seconds after the 08:00 epoch).",
          "fail": "Passage, registration or C disposal remains incomplete after day 0."
        },
        "cd-maintain": {
          "id": "cd-maintain",
          "title": "Maintain D every 48 hours, \u00b12 hours",
          "rule": "First feed is due 48 hours after initial incubator entry, with a 46\u201350-hour window. Repeat every 48 hours on the anchored schedule. The entire feeding workflow must fit within each \u00b12-hour window. Use A\u2019s pre/post imaging and review, full removal with tilt/no scraping, 2\u20134 mL wall addition per well, and 600-second return limit.",
          "fail": "Any subsequent feeding rule or the full-workflow timing window is missed."
        },
        "cd-final": {
          "id": "cd-final",
          "title": "Leave D ready",
          "rule": "At final submission, D is in its assigned incubator with its lid closed; source C is disposed.",
          "fail": "D is elsewhere, its lid is open, or C has not been disposed."
        },
        "d-schedule": {
          "id": "d-schedule",
          "title": "D feed schedule",
          "rule": "Complete each D feed within its assigned \u00b12-hour window."
        },
        "d-before": {
          "id": "d-before",
          "title": "D pre-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a fresh image for every D feed."
        },
        "d-remove": {
          "id": "d-remove",
          "title": "D complete removal",
          "rule": "Remove all old medium from every well with tilt, no scraping and at most one bottom touch."
        },
        "d-add": {
          "id": "d-add",
          "title": "D fresh medium",
          "rule": "Add 2\u20134 mL down the wall into each emptied well."
        },
        "d-after": {
          "id": "d-after",
          "title": "D post-feed image and review",
          "rule": "Acquire and review a new image after each D feed."
        },
        "d-return": {
          "id": "d-return",
          "title": "D incubator return",
          "rule": "Return within 600 seconds of the final dispense."
        },
        "d-final": {
          "id": "d-final",
          "title": "D \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned D feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "final-jobs": {
          "id": "final-jobs",
          "title": "Finish the workflow and complete all jobs",
          "rule": "Submit at day seven after running the workflow; all initiated jobs must be done, with no unfinished feed or wash sequence."
        },
        "final-robot": {
          "id": "final-robot",
          "title": "Finish pipetting and release the robot",
          "rule": "After executing pipetting and submitting at day seven, leave no held plate or attached tip."
        },
        "material-accounting": {
          "id": "material-accounting",
          "title": "Execute and conserve material",
          "rule": "After actual liquid transfers and day-seven submission, preserve material conservation and leave no cell clumps in waste."
        },
        "no-violation": {
          "id": "no-violation",
          "title": "Complete execution without violations",
          "rule": "Execute liquid handling and submit at day seven without terminal protocol violations or truncation."
        },
        "submitted": {
          "id": "submitted",
          "title": "Final submission",
          "rule": "Submit finish at exactly 604800 seconds."
        },
        "e-schedule": {
          "id": "e-schedule",
          "title": "E \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-before": {
          "id": "e-before",
          "title": "E \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-remove": {
          "id": "e-remove",
          "title": "E \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-add": {
          "id": "e-add",
          "title": "E \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-after": {
          "id": "e-after",
          "title": "E \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-return": {
          "id": "e-return",
          "title": "E \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "e-final": {
          "id": "e-final",
          "title": "E \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned E feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "f-schedule": {
          "id": "f-schedule",
          "title": "F \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-before": {
          "id": "f-before",
          "title": "F \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-remove": {
          "id": "f-remove",
          "title": "F \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-add": {
          "id": "f-add",
          "title": "F \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-after": {
          "id": "f-after",
          "title": "F \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-return": {
          "id": "f-return",
          "title": "F \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "f-final": {
          "id": "f-final",
          "title": "F \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned F feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "g-schedule": {
          "id": "g-schedule",
          "title": "G \u00b7 schedule",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-before": {
          "id": "g-before",
          "title": "G \u00b7 before",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-remove": {
          "id": "g-remove",
          "title": "G \u00b7 remove",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-add": {
          "id": "g-add",
          "title": "G \u00b7 add",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-after": {
          "id": "g-after",
          "title": "G \u00b7 after",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-return": {
          "id": "g-return",
          "title": "G \u00b7 return",
          "rule": "Follow this culture\u2019s assigned feed obligations and reviewed handling requirements. Inspect the recorded windows and receipts."
        },
        "g-final": {
          "id": "g-final",
          "title": "G \u00b7 Complete feeds and leave ready",
          "rule": "Complete all assigned G feeds and incubator returns, then leave the plate in its assigned incubator with lid closed and no unfinished feed."
        },
        "cd-intervention": {
          "id": "cd-intervention",
          "title": "Scientist intervention",
          "rule": "Complete scientist intervention when requested; do not invent an intervention on a branch that does not require it."
        },
        "equipment-recovery": {
          "id": "equipment-recovery",
          "title": "Recover failed acquisitions",
          "rule": "A failed acquisition must be followed by a successful image of the same plate and purpose without repeating material transfers."
        }
      },
      "journal_url": "data/gate-dashboard/journal-a5a8ca93391e31a5.json",
      "agent_trace_url": "data/gate-dashboard/agent-trillo-ipsc-maintenance__PKtFa8N.json",
      "agent_trace_summary": {
        "available": false,
        "turn_count": 0,
        "tool_call_count": 0,
        "tool_error_count": 0
      },
      "url": "data/gate-dashboard/trillo-ipsc-maintenance__PKtFa8N.json",
      "gate_results": {
        "a-schedule": false,
        "a-before": false,
        "a-remove": false,
        "a-add": false,
        "a-after": false,
        "a-return": false,
        "a-final": false,
        "b-schedule": false,
        "b-before": false,
        "b-remove": false,
        "b-add": false,
        "b-after": false,
        "b-return": false,
        "b-final": false,
        "d-schedule": false,
        "d-before": false,
        "d-remove": false,
        "d-add": false,
        "d-after": false,
        "d-return": false,
        "d-final": false,
        "b-rock": false,
        "cd-eligible": false,
        "cd-coating": false,
        "cd-wash": false,
        "cd-release": false,
        "cd-incubate-first": false,
        "cd-review-first": false,
        "cd-incubate-second": false,
        "cd-review-second": false,
        "cd-dislodge": false,
        "cd-collect": false,
        "cd-dilute": false,
        "cd-mix": false,
        "cd-distribute": false,
        "cd-motion": false,
        "cd-d-review": false,
        "cd-d-return": false,
        "cd-lineage": false,
        "cd-day0": false,
        "cd-maintain": false,
        "cd-final": false,
        "final-jobs": false,
        "final-robot": false,
        "material-accounting": false,
        "no-violation": false,
        "submitted": false
      },
      "gate_status": {
        "a-schedule": "failed",
        "a-before": "failed",
        "a-remove": "failed",
        "a-add": "failed",
        "a-after": "failed",
        "a-return": "failed",
        "a-final": "failed",
        "b-schedule": "failed",
        "b-before": "failed",
        "b-remove": "failed",
        "b-add": "failed",
        "b-after": "failed",
        "b-return": "failed",
        "b-final": "failed",
        "d-schedule": "failed",
        "d-before": "failed",
        "d-remove": "failed",
        "d-add": "failed",
        "d-after": "failed",
        "d-return": "failed",
        "d-final": "failed",
        "b-rock": "failed",
        "cd-eligible": "failed",
        "cd-coating": "failed",
        "cd-wash": "failed",
        "cd-release": "failed",
        "cd-incubate-first": "failed",
        "cd-review-first": "failed",
        "cd-incubate-second": "failed",
        "cd-review-second": "failed",
        "cd-dislodge": "failed",
        "cd-collect": "failed",
        "cd-dilute": "failed",
        "cd-mix": "failed",
        "cd-distribute": "failed",
        "cd-motion": "failed",
        "cd-d-review": "failed",
        "cd-d-return": "failed",
        "cd-lineage": "failed",
        "cd-day0": "failed",
        "cd-maintain": "failed",
        "cd-final": "failed",
        "final-jobs": "failed",
        "final-robot": "failed",
        "material-accounting": "failed",
        "no-violation": "failed",
        "submitted": "failed"
      }
    }
  ],
  "errors": [
    {
      "id": "trillo-ipsc-maintenance__RPrbuss",
      "reason": "Bedrock rejected Chat Completions with max reasoning and function tools.",
      "exception": {
        "exception_type": "RuntimeError",
        "exception_message": "Bedrock HTTP 400; no retry",
        "exception_traceback": "Traceback (most recent call last):\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/trial.py\", line 500, in run\n    await self._run()\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/single_step.py\", line 40, in _run\n    await self._run_agent()\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/single_step.py\", line 76, in _run_agent\n    await self._run_agent_phase(\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/trial.py\", line 651, in _run_agent_phase\n    await asyncio.wait_for(\n  File \"/usr/lib/python3.12/asyncio/tasks.py\", line 520, in wait_for\n    return await fut\n           ^^^^^^^^^\n  File \"/opt/run/projects/trillo-rl/scripts/astra_solver.py\", line 83, in run\n    data, request_id = await asyncio.to_thread(request, payload)\n                       ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^\n  File \"/usr/lib/python3.12/asyncio/threads.py\", line 25, in to_thread\n    return await loop.run_in_executor(None, func_call)\n           ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^\n  File \"/usr/lib/python3.12/concurrent/futures/thread.py\", line 58, in run\n    result = self.fn(*self.args, **self.kwargs)\n             ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^\n  File \"/opt/run/projects/trillo-rl/scripts/astra_solver.py\", line 40, in request\n    raise RuntimeError(f\"Bedrock HTTP {exc.code}; no retry\") from None\nRuntimeError: Bedrock HTTP 400; no retry\n",
        "occurred_at": "2026-11-12T01:35:09.239026Z"
      },
      "source": "jobs/astra-original/jobs/ipsc-reviewed-astra-max-20261112T013234Z/trillo-ipsc-maintenance__RPrbuss/result.json",
      "grade_status": "No substantive scientific grade",
      "model_response": null
    },
    {
      "id": "trillo-ipsc-maintenance__fF5U2rN",
      "reason": "Bedrock rejected Chat Completions with max reasoning and function tools.",
      "exception": {
        "exception_type": "RuntimeError",
        "exception_message": "Bedrock HTTP 400; no retry",
        "exception_traceback": "Traceback (most recent call last):\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/trial.py\", line 500, in run\n    await self._run()\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/single_step.py\", line 40, in _run\n    await self._run_agent()\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/single_step.py\", line 76, in _run_agent\n    await self._run_agent_phase(\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/trial.py\", line 651, in _run_agent_phase\n    await asyncio.wait_for(\n  File \"/usr/lib/python3.12/asyncio/tasks.py\", line 520, in wait_for\n    return await fut\n           ^^^^^^^^^\n  File \"/opt/run/projects/trillo-rl/scripts/astra_solver.py\", line 83, in run\n    data, request_id = await asyncio.to_thread(request, payload)\n                       ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^\n  File \"/usr/lib/python3.12/asyncio/threads.py\", line 25, in to_thread\n    return await loop.run_in_executor(None, func_call)\n           ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^\n  File \"/usr/lib/python3.12/concurrent/futures/thread.py\", line 58, in run\n    result = self.fn(*self.args, **self.kwargs)\n             ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^\n  File \"/opt/run/projects/trillo-rl/scripts/astra_solver.py\", line 40, in request\n    raise RuntimeError(f\"Bedrock HTTP {exc.code}; no retry\") from None\nRuntimeError: Bedrock HTTP 400; no retry\n",
        "occurred_at": "2026-11-12T01:37:00.197804Z"
      },
      "source": "jobs/astra-original/jobs/ipsc-reviewed-astra-max-20261112T013234Z/trillo-ipsc-maintenance__fF5U2rN/result.json",
      "grade_status": "No substantive scientific grade",
      "model_response": null
    },
    {
      "id": "trillo-ipsc-maintenance__4dkMA76",
      "reason": "Adapter stopped on an unsupported timeout argument instead of returning a tool error.",
      "exception": {
        "exception_type": "RuntimeError",
        "exception_message": "Invalid terminal arguments",
        "exception_traceback": "Traceback (most recent call last):\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/trial.py\", line 500, in run\n    await self._run()\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/single_step.py\", line 40, in _run\n    await self._run_agent()\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/single_step.py\", line 76, in _run_agent\n    await self._run_agent_phase(\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/trial.py\", line 651, in _run_agent_phase\n    await asyncio.wait_for(\n  File \"/usr/lib/python3.12/asyncio/tasks.py\", line 520, in wait_for\n    return await fut\n           ^^^^^^^^^\n  File \"/opt/run/projects/trillo-rl/scripts/astra_solver.py\", line 113, in run\n    raise RuntimeError(\"Invalid terminal arguments\")\nRuntimeError: Invalid terminal arguments\n",
        "occurred_at": "2026-11-12T01:44:34.985516Z"
      },
      "source": "jobs/astra-tool-errors/jobs/ipsc-reviewed-astra-max-20261112T014022Z/trillo-ipsc-maintenance__4dkMA76/result.json",
      "grade_status": "No substantive scientific grade",
      "model_response": {
        "model": "us.openai.gpt-6-astra",
        "output": [
          {
            "arguments": "{\"command\":\"ls -la /workspace && ls -la /workspace/packet/reviewed && cat /workspace/packet/reviewed/TASK.md && printf '\\\\n---PROTOCOL---\\\\n' && cat /workspace/packet/reviewed/PROTOCOL.md && printf '\\\\n---INTERFACE---\\\\n' && cat /workspace/packet/reviewed/INTERFACE.md\",\"timeout\":120000}",
            "call_id": "call_b58b982bbf9959c281d4bd699d9cb221",
            "id": "fc_52b05f1aa287588ab943c5f469c26588",
            "name": "terminal",
            "status": "completed",
            "type": "function_call"
          }
        ],
        "usage": {
          "prompt_tokens": 325,
          "completion_tokens": 98,
          "prompt_tokens_details": {
            "cache_write_tokens": 0,
            "cached_tokens": 0
          }
        },
        "request_id": "b17e05d6-d4e7-427f-bce8-ad2434fe1004",
        "status": "completed",
        "elapsed_seconds": 1.7932740749999994,
        "cost_upper_bound_usd": 0.015475
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "trillo-ipsc-maintenance__Z6EAs3d",
      "reason": "Adapter stopped on an unsupported timeout argument instead of returning a tool error.",
      "exception": {
        "exception_type": "RuntimeError",
        "exception_message": "Invalid terminal arguments",
        "exception_traceback": "Traceback (most recent call last):\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/trial.py\", line 500, in run\n    await self._run()\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/single_step.py\", line 40, in _run\n    await self._run_agent()\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/single_step.py\", line 76, in _run_agent\n    await self._run_agent_phase(\n  File \"/opt/venv/lib/python3.12/site-packages/harbor/trial/trial.py\", line 651, in _run_agent_phase\n    await asyncio.wait_for(\n  File \"/usr/lib/python3.12/asyncio/tasks.py\", line 520, in wait_for\n    return await fut\n           ^^^^^^^^^\n  File \"/opt/run/projects/trillo-rl/scripts/astra_solver.py\", line 113, in run\n    raise RuntimeError(\"Invalid terminal arguments\")\nRuntimeError: Invalid terminal arguments\n",
        "occurred_at": "2026-11-12T01:42:42.763861Z"
      },
      "source": "jobs/astra-tool-errors/jobs/ipsc-reviewed-astra-max-20261112T014022Z/trillo-ipsc-maintenance__Z6EAs3d/result.json",
      "grade_status": "No substantive scientific grade",
      "model_response": {
        "model": "us.openai.gpt-6-astra",
        "output": [
          {
            "arguments": "{\"command\":\"pwd && ls -la /workspace && ls -la /workspace/packet/reviewed && cat /workspace/packet/reviewed/TASK.md && printf '\\\\n===== PROTOCOL =====\\\\n' && cat /workspace/packet/reviewed/PROTOCOL.md && printf '\\\\n===== INTERFACE =====\\\\n' && cat /workspace/packet/reviewed/INTERFACE.md\",\"timeout\":120000}",
            "call_id": "call_7fc2adb815cb501fb5de0edaa994cac3",
            "id": "fc_184621a14b3356f390a6b2d166390388",
            "name": "terminal",
            "status": "completed",
            "type": "function_call"
          }
        ],
        "usage": {
          "prompt_tokens": 325,
          "completion_tokens": 100,
          "prompt_tokens_details": {
            "cache_write_tokens": 0,
            "cached_tokens": 0
          }
        },
        "request_id": "aace1d10-cb45-4aa9-97a4-e1274e981eb3",
        "status": "completed",
        "elapsed_seconds": 1.8071901240000017,
        "cost_upper_bound_usd": 0.015625
      }
    }
  ]
}
