{
  "scope": "Physical feeding and selective passage acceptance criteria",
  "assessment_note": "These are review criteria, not results from a physical run. Missing evidence leaves a gate Not assessed; an observed deviation is a failure. Record approved-stop exemptions explicitly.",
  "gates": [
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-01",
      "step": "setup-1",
      "title": "Approve the exact run",
      "scientist_tacit": false,
      "criterion": "Pass when the plate/well manifest, SOP revision and scientist approval are recorded; fail when any is missing.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-02",
      "step": "setup-2",
      "title": "Match the staged inventory",
      "scientist_tacit": false,
      "criterion": "Pass when required reagents, coated plates, tips, tools and waste capacity match the approved setup; fail for a mismatch or shortage.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-03",
      "step": "setup-3",
      "title": "Confirm motion and imaging readiness",
      "scientist_tacit": false,
      "criterion": "Pass when the actual calibration, transfer route, Squid recipe and watching operator are confirmed; fail while any required setting remains unverified.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-04",
      "step": "feeding-1",
      "title": "Track plate identity and time out",
      "scientist_tacit": false,
      "criterion": "Pass when the correct plate reaches Squid with departure and transfer records; fail for an identity mismatch, missing transfer record or exceeded approved time limit.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-05",
      "step": "feeding-2",
      "title": "Review cells before choosing the feed",
      "scientist_tacit": true,
      "criterion": "Pass when current, focused images support a recorded scientist assessment for each well; fail when the image or assessment is missing.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-06",
      "step": "feeding-3",
      "title": "Match medium to cell coverage",
      "scientist_tacit": true,
      "criterion": "For the session-notes route, pass with 2 mL below 50% coverage, 3 mL around 50%, or 4 mL around 80%; fail for a mismatch or an unapproved amount.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-07",
      "step": "feeding-3",
      "title": "Remove liquid without touching colonies",
      "scientist_tacit": true,
      "criterion": "Pass when the approved tilt and bottom-aspiration technique is followed without colony contact; fail when removal is missing or a technique/contact deviation is observed.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-08",
      "step": "feeding-3",
      "title": "Add medium down the wall",
      "scientist_tacit": true,
      "criterion": "Pass when fresh medium runs down the well wall; fail when it is directed onto the cell layer or the addition is missing.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-09",
      "step": "feeding-3",
      "title": "Finish one well before starting another",
      "scientist_tacit": false,
      "criterion": "Pass when each well’s medium removal and replacement follow consecutively under the approved SOP; fail when an unrelated pause or intervening well violates that sequence.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-10",
      "step": "feeding-4",
      "title": "Cover and return the plate",
      "scientist_tacit": false,
      "criterion": "Pass when the lidded plate returns to its assigned incubator within the approved limits; fail for an uncovered, misplaced, late or unrecorded return.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-11",
      "step": "feeding-5",
      "title": "Record the next feed",
      "scientist_tacit": false,
      "criterion": "Pass when each feed or hold and its next due time follow the approved schedule and recovery override; fail for an unresolved well or missing schedule.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-12",
      "step": "passaging-1",
      "title": "Confirm that the source is ready",
      "scientist_tacit": true,
      "criterion": "For the session-notes route, pass when the scientist confirms around 80% coverage and authorizes selective passage; fail for a missing assessment, 100% coverage or absent approval.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-13",
      "step": "passaging-2",
      "title": "Keep the new coating ready",
      "scientist_tacit": false,
      "criterion": "Pass when all assigned destination wells are prepared without drying the coating under the selected SOP; fail for incomplete preparation or an observed drying event.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-14",
      "step": "passaging-3",
      "title": "Wash and leave a thin ReLeSR film",
      "scientist_tacit": true,
      "criterion": "For the session-notes route, pass with one PBS wash followed by 1 mL ReLeSR addition and prompt removal to a thin film; fail for an omitted, reordered or interrupted step.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-15",
      "step": "passaging-4",
      "title": "Use the approved treatment time",
      "scientist_tacit": true,
      "criterion": "Pass when actual incubation and any extensions match the scientist-approved SOP for this culture; fail when timing is missing or outside that approved rule.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-16",
      "step": "passaging-5",
      "title": "Compare images before continuing",
      "scientist_tacit": true,
      "criterion": "Pass when matched before/after images support a recorded proceed, extend or stop decision that is followed; fail when collection starts without approval or a stop is ignored.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Use the selected, approved SOP; session-notes-only criteria do not override another approved recipe."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-17",
      "step": "passaging-6",
      "title": "Tap gently and report splash",
      "scientist_tacit": true,
      "criterion": "For the session-notes route, pass when gentle side tapping is completed without reported splash; fail the handling gate for a reported splash or missing step, with external mishaps recorded separately from agent choices.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Downstream passage gates are not required after a scientist-directed stop; record the stop and assigned disposition instead."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-18",
      "step": "passaging-6",
      "title": "Use the specified collection pipette",
      "scientist_tacit": true,
      "criterion": "For the session-notes route, pass when collection uses the specified 5 mL serological pipette into the identified tube; fail for a different tool, mixed identity or missing collection.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Downstream passage gates are not required after a scientist-directed stop; record the stop and assigned disposition instead."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-19",
      "step": "passaging-7",
      "title": "Mix once before redistribution",
      "scientist_tacit": true,
      "criterion": "For the session-notes route, pass when one up/down mixing cycle is recorded before redistribution; fail when mixing is skipped or a different cycle count is recorded.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Downstream passage gates are not required after a scientist-directed stop; record the stop and assigned disposition instead."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-20",
      "step": "passaging-7",
      "title": "Account for the dilution",
      "scientist_tacit": false,
      "criterion": "Pass when measured collected and added volumes match the approved final-volume plan and homogeneity is maintained as required; fail for an unexplained volume mismatch or unmet mixing requirement.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Downstream passage gates are not required after a scientist-directed stop; record the stop and assigned disposition instead."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-21",
      "step": "passaging-8",
      "title": "Fill every destination well",
      "scientist_tacit": true,
      "criterion": "For the session-notes six-well route, pass when all six wells receive the approved 2 mL amount with appropriate mixing; fail for a missed well, wrong amount or observed loss of mixture uniformity.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Downstream passage gates are not required after a scientist-directed stop; record the stop and assigned disposition instead."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-22",
      "step": "passaging-8",
      "title": "Settle, cover and return the new plate",
      "scientist_tacit": false,
      "criterion": "Pass when the approved settling step and lidded return of all relevant plates are recorded; fail for a missing step, wrong location or unresolved transfer.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Downstream passage gates are not required after a scientist-directed stop; record the stop and assigned disposition instead."
    },
    {
      "id": "physical-gate-23",
      "step": "passaging-9",
      "title": "Link the new culture to its source",
      "scientist_tacit": false,
      "criterion": "Pass when source identity, new plate, passage number and future feed/imaging obligations are recorded; fail when lineage or follow-up is missing.",
      "status": "Not assessed",
      "applicability": "Downstream passage gates are not required after a scientist-directed stop; record the stop and assigned disposition instead."
    }
  ]
}
